In the last newsletter, I linked to a Planet Money broadcast on the origins and state of our current plastic recycling system. Subsequently Eco-Cycle, a recycling/compost/reuse nonprofit in Boulder, CO, posted in their newsletter an extensive response to the piece. Here it is in part:
As the NPR story rightly highlights, recycling alone is not going to solve our plastics pollution problem. The solution lies in the recognition that we don’t have a plastics recycling problem, we have a plastics production problem.
[W]e as a non-profit, mission-based recycler thank NPR for pulling back the curtain on Big Oil’s misleading of the public.
Plastics recycling in its current form is neither sustainable nor adequate, yet the plastics industry is currently on a trajectory to triple their production by 2050. As they execute on this plan, they are doing precious little to create recycling markets - as aluminum, steel, paper and glass industries do - by using recycled plastics to make new plastic products.
Many media stories have wrongly blamed recyclers for the lack of plastics recycling. This NPR story puts the blame fully where it belongs: with the petrochemical companies that are trying to use recycling to placate the public into thinking their products are fully “recyclable” in an effort to justify their increased use of fossil fuels.
[W]hile there are significant challenges with recycling plastic, plastics are only a small fraction of the overall material we recycle and should not cause us to abandon all recycling.
Recycling remains one of the fastest, most cost-effective local solutions to reduce climate emissions. It is also critical to our national economy, as we have seen during this pandemic. Your newspaper is needed to produce toilet paper, your glass bottles can become medical vials, your recycled aluminum and steel are critical feedstock for new products. Recycling is an essential part of our manufacturing economy - we need to do more of it and we need to continue to invest in recycling programs for many materials aside from just plastics.