Legislation Spotlight:
Recovery of Noneconomic Damages by
Adult Children and Parents of Adult Children in Medical Malpractice
The Florida Legislature has long wrestled with altering Florida’s long-standing law banning adult children and parents of adult children from receiving noneconomic damages in medical malpractice lawsuits involving the death of their parents or adult children. In an attempt to address the criticism, SB 248, filed by Senator Yarborough, and HB 77, filed by Representative Roach, sought to expand the application of the Florida Wrongful Death Act to allow certain parents and children of a deceased patient who dies due to medical negligence to recover noneconomic damages. Under existing law, all of a decedent’s statutory survivors may recover some economic damages for the loss of the decedent. However, there is a tiered priority of classes of survivors who may recover noneconomic damages, which notably includes damages for a survivor’s pain and suffering, for the decedent’s wrongful death.
The original filed bills aligned in that neither capped the amount of noneconomic damages adults could recover. However, Senator Yarborough, as Chair of the Senate Judiciary Committee, filed an amendment early during Session that placed caps on damages that could be awarded in medical malpractice lawsuits as part of his legislation. The Senate Judiciary Committee voted favorably on the proposed amendment, placing caps on noneconomic damages at $500,000 per claimant, regardless of the number of health care practitioners who are liable. The limits would be $750,000 on “non-practitioners” who are liable. The cap would drop to $150,000 for health care practitioners in emergency medical cases.
After amending the Senate version, the legislative efforts to alter the ban stalled, as Representative Roach publicly came out against the damages caps, telling reporters: “Any discussion of caps is a non-starter for me. I will continue to fight for a full repeal of [the law].” The legislative efforts appear stalled for the 2024 Session; however, given the broad support this change received, these efforts will more than likely emerge in subsequent Sessions.
The Government Affairs Team at Stearns Weaver Miller, in conjunction with the Medical Malpractice Group is actively monitoring all aspects of these possible changes, including the possibility of this issue arising in the 2025 Legislative Session. We will continue to provide updates on the proposed changes, including the possible impacts on Florida healthcare facilities.
|