Supreme Court of Texas

Oral Argument

Schedule

 

The Supreme Court of Texas will hold oral arguments beginning at 9 a.m. CT on December 3, 4, and 5.


Oral arguments are streamed live and preserved on the Supreme Court's YouTube page. The public may also attend in person in the Supreme Court courtroom, 201 W. 14th St., Austin, TX.

Tuesday, December 3, 2024

Werner Enters., Inc. v. Blake

This car-crash case involves arguments about the sufficiency of the evidence, charge error, and damages.


Justice Lehrmann not participating.

For Petitioners: Thomas C. Wright (Wright Close & Barger, LLP), Houston, and Thomas R. Philips (Baker Botts LLP), Austin


For Respondents: Darrin M. Walker (Law Office of Darrin Walker), Kingwood

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

Ferchichi v. Whataburger Rests. LLC 

~consolidated for oral argument with~

Haven at Thorpe Lane, LLC v. Pate

The issue in these cases is the applicability of the Texas Citizens Participation Act to a motion to compel discovery that includes a request for attorney’s fees.

For Petitioners, Ferchichi: Adam Poncio (Poncio Law Offices, P.C.), San Antonio.


For Respondent, Whataburger: Karen L. Landinger (Germer PLLC), San Antonio


For Petitioner, Haven at Thorpe: Ray T. Torgerson (Porter Hedges LLP), Houston


For Respondents, Pate: Kyle Dingman (Brown Law Firm), San Antonio, and Russell Sloan (Russell Sloan, Attorney at Law), Austin

Read the case summary.


View the case documents for 23-0568 and 23-0993.

In the Matter of J.J.T.

The issue is whether the juvenile court erred in transferring a case to criminal district court where the defendant was a minor at the time of the murder but was charged after his 18th birthday.

For Petitioner: Melissa H. Stryker (Harris County District Attorney's Office), Houston, and Aaron L. Nielson (Office of the Attorney General), Austin


For Respondent: Jerry Michael Acosta (Jerry Michael Acosta & Associates, PLLC), Houston

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

Butler v. Collins

This certified question case concerns whether the Texas Commission on Human Rights Act preempts common law tort claims brought against the plaintiff’s former coworkers.

For Appellant: Ezra Ishmael Young (Law Office of Ezra Young), Ithaca, NY


For Appellees: Kirsten M. Castañeda (Alexander Dubose & Jefferson LLP), Dallas

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

Wednesday, December 4, 2024

BRP-Rotax GmbH & Co. KG v. Shaik

The issue in this case is whether the trial court had specific jurisdiction over a foreign manufacturer for claims based on an allegedly defective product.

For Petitioner: Wallace B. Jefferson (Alexander Dubose & Jefferson LLP), Austin


For Respondents: Shannon Turner Hays (Payne Mitchell Ramsey Law Group), Dallas

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

Lane v. Comm. for Lawyer Discipline

The main issue in this disciplinary appeal is whether the four-year limitations period in Texas Rule of Disciplinary Procedure 17.06 applies to a judgment imposing reciprocal discipline under Part IX of the rules.

For Appellant: Nejla K. Lane (Nejla Kassandra Keyfli Lane), Kyle


For Appellee: Michael G. Graham (Office of the Chief Disciplinary Counsel), Austin

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

Perez v. City of San Antonio

This certified question concerns Article I, Section 6-a of the Texas Constitution, which prohibits the state of Texas and its political subdivisions from prohibiting or limiting religious services.

For Appellants: John Greil (The University of Texas School of Law - Law and Religion Clinic), Austin


For Appellee: Jane Webre (Scott Douglass & McConnico LLP), Austin


For Amicus Curiae, The State of Texas: William F. Cole (Office of the Attorney General – Solicitor General Division), Austin

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

Thursday, December 5, 2024

Leibman v. Waldroup

The main issue in this appeal is whether the plaintiffs’ negligence suit against Leibman to recover damages for injuries sustained in a dog attack triggered the Texas Medical Liability Act’s expert-report requirement.

For Petitioner: LaVerne Chang (Cardwell & Chang PLLC), Houston 


For Respondents: Maureen Farrell (Muery & Farrell, PC), Austin, and Kyle Herbert (Herbert Law Firm, PLLC), Houston

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

Kensington Title-Nev., LLC v. Tex. Dep’t of State Health Servs.

The Administrative Procedure Act waives sovereign immunity in a suit seeking a declaration about an administrative rule’s “applicability.” The issue in this case is whether the request for declaratory relief challenges a rule’s application (how the rule applies) as opposed to its applicability (whether the rule applies).

For Petitioner: C. Chad Lampe and Warren V. Norred (Norred Law, PLLC), Arlington


For Respondent: Kateland R. Jackson (Office of the Attorney General), Austin

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

Seward v. Santander

The issues include (1) when an off-duty officer working for a private employer is considered to be on duty; (2) whether negligence claims by police officers responding to a request for assistance should have been pleaded as premises-liability claims; and (3) whether the common law “firefighter rule” applies.

For Petitioner, Home Depot U.S.A., Inc.: Arthur K. Smith (Law Offices of Arthur K. Smith, A Professional Corporation), Prosper


For Petitioners, Chad Seward and Point 2 Point Global Security, Inc.: David M. Walsh IV (Kershaw Anderson King, PLLC), Dallas


For Respondents: Niles S. Illich (Palmer Perlstein), Addison

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

Was this email forwarded to you? Click here to subscribe to Supreme Court advisories.


Questions about this email, reply to scotxinfo@txcourts.gov or email Director of Public Affairs Amy Starnes at amy.starnes@txcourts.gov.


Follow Supreme Court news via X (formerly Twitter) @SupremeCourt_TX and LinkedIn at Supreme Court of Texas.

Supreme Court of Texas

(512) 463-1312

X Share This Email
LinkedIn Share This Email
Visit the Court's website
Rules & Standards