Supreme Court of Texas

Oral Argument

Schedule

 

The Supreme Court of Texas will hold oral arguments on October 1, 2, and 3. Arguments on October 1 and 3 will begin at 9 a.m. Arguments on October 2 will begin at 10 a.m.


Oral arguments are streamed live and preserved on the Supreme Court's YouTube page. The public may also attend in person in the Supreme Court courtroom, 201 W. 14th St., Austin, TX.


Below is the schedule of cases.

Tuesday, October 1, 2024

Univ. of Tex. at Austin v. Gatehouse Media Tex. Holdings, II, Inc.

The issue in this case is whether the Texas Public Information Act gives the University of Texas discretion to withhold information concerning the results of disciplinary proceedings.

For petitioners: Kateland R. Jackson (Office of

the Attorney General), Austin


For respondent: John F. Bash (Quinn Emanuel

Urquhart & Sullivan LLP), Austin

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

Save Our Springs All., Inc. v. Tex. Comm’n on Env’t Quality

The issue is whether a Texas Commission on Environmental Quality order approving a permit to discharge wastewater into a creek violates state and federal law governing water-quality standards.

For petitioner: William G. Bunch (Save Our

Springs Alliance, Inc.) Austin


For respondent, Texas Commission on Environmental Quality: Rance Craft (Office of the Attorney General)

Austin


For respondent, The City of Dripping Springs: David Tuckfield (The AL Law Group, PLLC), Austin

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

Bertucci v. Watkins

These cross-petitions raise issues of briefing waiver and whether fiduciary duties are owed among business partners.

For petitioners/cross-respondents: Steven A.

Fleckman (Munck Wilson Mandala, LLP), Austin


For respondent/cross-petitioner: Elizabeth G.

“Heidi” Bloch (Greenberg Traurig, LLP), Austin

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

In re Jane Doe Cases

This mandamus arises out of the “tag-along” transfer of the underlying lawsuit to an MDL involving other sex-trafficking cases. The issue in this case is whether the MDL panel erred by refusing to remand the case, thereby allowing it to remain in the MDL.


(Justice Huddle not participating.)

For relator: Kelly Sandill (Hunton Andrews

Kurth LLP), Houston


For real party in interest: Walter A. Simons

(Bracewell LLP), Houston

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

Wednesday, October 2, 2024

Pohl v. Cheatham

This case raises questions about the extraterritorial reach of Texas’s civil barratry statute and whether barratry claims are subject to a two- or four-year statute of limitations.


(Justice Devine not participating.)

For petitioner, Michael A. Pohl, et al.: Parth S. Gejji (Beck Redden LLP), Houston


For petitioner, Robert E. Ammons, et al.: Thomas R. Phillips (Baker Botts LLP), Austin


For respondents: David Eric Kassab (The Kassab Law Firm), Houston

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

EIS Dev. II, LLC v. Buena Vista Area Ass’n

The central issue in this case is the interpretation of a deed restriction.

For petitioner: Lance Caughfield (Baker Moran Dogget Ma & Dobbs, LLP), Plano


For respondents: Brent M. Rubin (Carrington, Coleman, Sloman & Blumenthal, LLP), Dallas

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

Port Arthur Comm. Action Network v. TCEQ

At issue in this certified question is the meaning of the phrase “has proven to be operational” in the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality’s definition of “best available control technology.”


(Justice Young not participating.)

For appellant: Amy Catherine Dinn (Lone Star Legal Aid), Houston


For appellees: Lanora C. Pettit (Office of the Attorney General), Austin


For intervenor, Port Arthur LNG, LLC: Aaron M. Streett (Baker Botts), Houston

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

Thursday, October 3, 2024

Henry S. Miller Com. Co. v. Newsom, Terry & Newsom, LLP

In this case, the issues are the propriety of an assignment of a legal-malpractice claim and whether a jury instruction impermissibly commented on the weight of the evidence.


(Justice Lehrmann not participating.)

For petitioner/cross-respondent: P. Michael Jung (Clark Hill PLC), Dallas


For respondents/cross-petitioner: Thomas C. Wright (Wright Close & Barger, LLP), Houston

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

425 Soledad, Ltd. v. CRVI Riverwalk Hosp., LLC

A main issue is whether a creditor’s bona fide protections pass to a subsequent purchaser if the property is purchased through a receivership sale rather than through foreclosure.

For petitioners: Kurt Kuhn (Kuhn Hobbs PLLC), Austin


For respondent: Jane Webre (Scott Douglass & McConnico LLP), Austin

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

In re State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co.

The issue in this case is whether the trial court must sever and abate Insurance Code claims when a motorist sues her insurance company for underinsured motorist benefits and violations of the Insurance Code.

For relators: Melissa A. Lorber (Enoch Kever PLLC), Austin


For real party in interest: Carlos R. Cortez (Cortez Law Firm PLLC), Dallas

Read the case summary.


View the case documents.

Was this email forwarded to you? Click here to subscribe to Supreme Court advisories.


Questions about this email, reply to scotxinfo@txcourts.gov or email Director of Public Affairs Amy Starnes at amy.starnes@txcourts.gov.


Follow Supreme Court news via X (formerly Twitter) @SupremeCourt_TX and LinkedIn at Supreme Court of Texas.

Supreme Court of Texas

(512) 463-1312

X Share This Email
LinkedIn Share This Email
Visit the Court's website
Rules & Standards