5th Circuit Deems Indian Child Welfare Act Unconstitutional In Part

04/09/21 Victoria Wicks

Earlier this week the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals released an extensive opinion on the Indian Child Welfare Act. Lawyers immediately started to examine its potential effect on legal processes in place for more than 40 years. An attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union says much of the law still stands, but some important protections have been found unconstitutional. 

ACLU’s Stephen Pevar says he is dismayed to find that valuable ICWA protections have been ruled unconstitutional.

He notes in particular two requirements on state courts or agencies that have been found to invade state sovereignty. The language in the ruling is that they, quote, “commandeer state actors.”

One of those requirements is that courts must hear testimony from a qualified expert witness before removing Native children from their homes.

Pevar says the expert is ideally a member of the same tribe as the child.
He says Congress put that provision in place because before ICWA, children were removed from their homes for situations acceptable under tribal customs.

“On many reservations it’s not only normal but encouraged that children spend weeks if not months living with the grandmother or grandfather, or an aunt or uncle, and many state court judges and social workers were viewing that as abandoned.”

He says the expert witness can testify that an action is not traditional and that under tribal customs it does present a risk to a child.

Senate Leader Says Noem Special Session Lacks Support
04/08/2021, By Lee Strubinger

One legislative leader says the State Senate has little appetite to take up two key special session topics floated by Governor Kristi Noem. 

Governor Noem says she wants lawmakers to protect fairness in women’s sports and to make changes to a voter approved medical marijuana program during a special session this spring. 

Governor Kristi Noem wants legislators to change the voter approved medical marijuana program by limiting medical marijuana plant cultivation to just three plants and prevent patients under 21 from inhaling marijuana. 

Lee Schoenbeck is the leader of the Senate. He says if changes to the medical marijuana program came up, they would have to be narrow in scope and limited to administrative rules that weren’t controversial. 
“And, even at that there is very little interest—and I mean very little interest—in the Senate,” Schoenbeck says. “Because I polled them, in taking that issue up in a special session.”  

Indigenous Group To Open Lakota-Based School

04/07/2021, By Lee Strubinger

A new community-based school in Rapid City will immerse students in Lakota language and culture. 

The effort is a response to the refusal by state and local leaders to open similar schools around the state. 

The NDN collective is behind the new school. The non-profit organization focuses on indigenous advocacy and has tried to push the state to approve schools that teach Oceti Sakowin essential understandings. That curriculum is centered around Lakota language and culture. State lawmakers rejected the proposals twice, so now organizers are taking the idea into their own hands. 

Sarah Pierce is the Director of Education Equity at NDN Collective. She says the new Rapid City school will be designed by indigenous people for indigenous people. It will teach subjects in Lakota. 

“No one knows needs better than authentic community representation,” Peirce says. “That will set the school apart. With the cultural norms, such as kinship, and the priority of Lakota language and culture as a deep embedded foundational aspect of the school—not an elective—will set us apart.” 

The Economist Examines SD’s Tradeoff Between Lives And Livelihoods
04/08/2021, By Seth Tupper

South Dakota’s approach to the pandemic is attracting worldwide scrutiny.
 
A London-based magazine, The Economist, recently published an article about the state.  

Callum Williams is a senior writer for the magazine. In an interview with SDPB’s Lori Walsh on “In the Moment,” Williams said South Dakota is making a rare calculation about lives and livelihoods. 

“What has happened, in effect, is that South Dakota or the government of South Dakota in fact has chosen to protect the economy even though the deaths from COVID have been high,” Williams said. “Now that’s a very uncomfortable tradeoff to make. And the article doesn’t judge whether that’s the right tradeoff to make, either. It just is the tradeoff.” 


More From SDPB's "In the Moment"
Results Of DAPL Hearing

04/09/2021, By Victoria Wicks

A District of Columbia federal judge has agreed to postpone his decision whether to shut down the Dakota Access Pipeline.

Judge James Boasberg held a status hearing Friday to give the Army Corps of Engineers an opportunity to explain why the pipeline should not cease operations.

Last summer Judge Boasberg declared the pipeline to be illegal, having been constructed without an adequate environmental review, in violation of the National Environmental Policy Act.

A lawyer for the Army Corps told Judge Boasberg that the agency has been consulting with various tribes, the state of North Dakota, and Dakota Access, and he projected the study would be complete a year from now.
FEMA To Open Applications For COVID-19 Funeral Reimbursements

04/09/2021, By John Nguyen

The Federal Emergency Management Agency is opening applications for COVID-related funeral expenses on Monday (April 12). 

FEMA officials say up to $9,000 are available for each victim whose death may have been caused by or was likely the result of COVID-19. Money can go towards reimbursing expenses like caskets, burial plots or clergy services. 

Applicants require documentation like death certificates and receipts. If approved, FEMA will send money by mail or direct deposit. 

Individuals can find more information on funeral assistance online at FEMA dot GOV. 
Unemployment Update

04/09/2021, By Kyle Ireland

The Department of Labor and Regulation reports a total of 243 new claims for unemployment benefits. That’s a decrease of nearly 60 claims from the week before.  
 
The latest number of continued state claims is 3,792 for the last week of March. That’s a decrease of more than 1,000 from the prior week’s total.  
 
The state has paid out roughly $366 million in benefits since March of 2020. 
COVID Update

04/09/2021, By John Nguyen
 
The state health department reports 270 new coronavirus cases. More than 40 of those new cases are virus variants.
 
Seven people have died. That brings the state’s death toll to 1,946. 
 
Active cases and hospitalizations are down slightly. There are 2,484 current infections and 97 people hospitalized. 
 
Roughly 48 percent of South Dakotans have received at least one vaccine dose. About 33% have finished the vaccine series. 
8th Circuit Says Meade County Conviction Stops Short Of Unconstitutionality

04/08/2021, By Victoria Wicks

The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled against a man who sued investigators and prosecutors in Meade County.

Oakley Engesser served 12 years in prison before being exonerated by witnesses who were not brought to trial to testify.

Engesser says the investigation and prosecution were so flawed that they violated his constitutional rights. But the Eighth Circuit disagrees.

Oakley Engesser was convicted in 2001 of vehicular manslaughter. He was accused of driving the red Corvette owned by Dorothy Finley, who years later was determined to be the driver.

Finley was killed when the speeding car crashed into another vehicle on Interstate 90 near Sturgis and rolled a number of times in the median.

Each day, SDPB's journalism team works to bring you pertinent news coverage.

We then compile those stories into one short and clear daily podcast so that you can stay informed.

Subscribe to "SDPB News" on Apple Podcasts or Spotify today.

More SDPB News
Aberdeen Central, Changing Of The Guards
04/09/21 Nate Wek

A lot can change quickly when it comes to jobs in sports, and in the high school ranks of South Dakota it’s no different.
 
Just over a month ago, long time Aberdeen Central athletic director Gene Brownell announced that after 23-years, he would be retiring. From there, legendary Golden Eagles girls’ basketball coach Dawn Seiler accepted the vacant AD position, which effectively will end her high school hoops coaching career. And then this week, Mikayla Arechigo, who was an assistant under Dawn Seiler, was announced as the new girls’ basketball coach.


More SDPB Sports
South Dakota's gun laws:
are too strict.
are not strict enough.
are fine as is.
Looking to Subscribe to The Morning Report?

Click here & sign up for SDPB "00-News & Information" and you will begin to receive The Morning Report straight to your inbox.