|
End of Animal Exploitation?
Dr. Rao's Team WON the Oxford Union Debate!
Could this be the start of a great awakening?
SOS #248 -- J. Morris Hicks -- (12-8-23)
| |
|
Yesterday, I received the best news I have ever heard about climate change. The message came from my good friend and colleague, Dr. Sailesh Rao:
We won the Oxford Union debate on the proposition, “This House Would Go Vegan” by a margin of 112-84.
| |
Dr. Rao begins: At a venue where reason generally prevails, our factual case for the proposition on environmental, health and ethical grounds won over the emotional case made for the opposition on traditional and cultural grounds.
This is a critical step in making progress on the grassroots front towards a thriving future. We intend to leverage this win and do the rounds of universities and institutions around the world to overcome the systemic obstacles found at the UN and other mainstream institutions.
(Below, or on his website, you can read Dr. Rao's complete opening statement in the debate.
But first, some Oxford Union info from Wikipedia)
| |
The Oxford Union Society, commonly referred to as the Oxford Union, is a debating society in the city of Oxford, UK.
Its membership is drawn primarily from the University of Oxford. Founded in 1823, it is one of Britain's oldest university unions and one of the world's most prestigious private students' societies.[1] The Oxford Union exists independently from the university[2] and is distinct from the Oxford University Student Union.
| |
The Oxford Union has a tradition of hosting some of the world's most prominent individuals across politics, academia, and popular culture ranging from Albert Einstein and Michael Jackson to Sir Winston Churchill, Ronald Reagan and Queen Elizabeth II.
Dr. Rao continues...
As COP28 in Dubai illustrates, with the meat and dairy industry in full force promoting their unsustainable products as sustainable nutrition while the organizers make back room fossil fuel deals while touting projected progress on future emissions, we must lead, not follow, the political class to solve our global ecological crisis.
| |
The Oxford Union event began with a guided tour of the historic buildings in Frewin Court. We posed for group photos with the members of the Oxford Union, similar to the group photos with Mother Theresa and Albert Einstein hanging in the gallery.
The dinner that followed was 100% vegan -- and even those speaking for the opposition were served the same vegan dishes. The rationale was that the Vegans were in an overwhelming majority at the dinner table.
For once, the shoe was on the other foot, when normally, the Vegans make do with salad and boiled vegetables, while the majority feasts on animal foods.
The debate began with the President of the Oxford Union, Disha Hegde, making the case for the proposition and introducing the speakers for the opposition.
Then the President-Elect of the Oxford Union, Hannah Edwards, spoke first for the opposition and introduced the speakers for the proposition. Then each of us spoke, alternating between the proposition and the opposition, making the environmental, health and ethical case for going Vegan or not, in that order.
News articles on the debate with more details can be found here and here. The videos of the debate are expected to be uploaded on the Oxford Union Youtube channel by the end of the month.
- Meanwhile, here is the complete text of the debate speech I made on the environmental case for the House to go Vegan, with references for all the facts used in the speech. I’m especially indebted to Glen Merzer, Carl LeBlond, Ken and Alison Hamje, Paul Papin and Mythili Rao for all the help in writing this speech:
Dr. Rao's Opening Presentation Begins Here.
Ladies and Gentlemen, it is my privilege to speak at a venue where, 200 years ago, you began rebelling against false orthodoxy [1]. Today, I want to rebel with you against false orthodoxy -- by speaking on bovine matters.
| |
I mean, of course, cows. Yes, there is a Cow in the Room and not everyone can see it. I hope that by the end of the debate, eyes will be opened. The orthodoxy, the herd opinion if you like, is that animal agriculture has little to do with climate change.
I believe that is very wrong. I believe that based on data. I am an environmentalist by occupation, but a systems engineer by profession. Systems is what I do.
I invented the protocol for transforming early analog internet connections to more robust digital connections, while accelerating their speed ten-fold. Still today, any data accessed on the internet likely passed through a device implementing this protocol.
I plead that this House rebel once again by voting for the proposition, “This House Would Go Vegan.”
Veganism is defined as a “philosophy and way of living that seeks to exclude, as far as is possible and practicable, all forms of exploitation of animals for food, clothing or any other purpose [2].”
The proposition asks that this House Go Vegan, not Be Vegan, implying that this is a journey, not a destination. I highly recommend this journey on ethical, health and environmental grounds.
I will now focus on the
environmental reasons to Go Vegan.
It is undeniable that human civilization has adversely impacted life-support systems on the planet. Scientists have identified nine planetary boundaries that we must stay within for the sustainability of life on earth. At the moment, we have transgressed six of them [3] and any one of these transgressions could end life as we know it.
The good news is that when we Go Vegan,
we help resolve all six of them.
That’s the power we have as individuals to reverse our existential crisis.
-
Animal agriculture is the leading cause of ecological destruction because it uses 37% of the ice-free land area of the planet just to graze animals [4], while bottom trawling an area of the ocean floor the size of South America every year for industrial fishing [5].
- Animal agriculture is the only major activity in which we destroy forests and replace them, not with other trees for timber or paper, but with grass, which drastically reduces the diversity of life that the land can support.
-
Animal agriculture is the primary reason why humans have reduced the number of trees on the planet by half, from 6 trillion to 3 trillion, over the past 10,000 years [6]. Restoring those 3 trillion trees can draw down enough carbon to completely reverse climate change.
-
Animal agriculture is grossly inefficient because animals must eat 39 pounds of plants to produce one pound of human food, on average [7], a burden which the world can no longer afford.
- By going Vegan, we can give nearly 40% of the ice-free land area of the planet, as well as the entire ocean, back to nature.
- When we restore the native ecosystems on that land, we can grow most of the 3 trillion trees that we cut down over the past 10,000 years. This helps resolve all six planetary-boundary transgressions.
Here is a handy list of all nine of those planetary boundaries, six of which we have blown past.
Dr. Rao discusses those six below this image.
| | Dr. Rao's List of Six Planetary Boundary Transgressions | |
#1. The least violated transgression is fresh-water change. Rewilding the land that is currently used for grazing animals will restore the fresh-water cycles of the planet.
#2. The next is land-system change. Going vegan will allow us to return nearly 40% of the land area of the planet back to nature, resolving this planetary-boundary transgression.
#3. The next worst transgression is climate change, which can be resolved when the excess carbon in the atmosphere is absorbed in the trees and soil -- that we can restore the ecosystems of the planet.
#4. The next is chemical pollution, which would be safely stored away in regenerating forests when we Go Vegan. Eating animal foods currently delivers concentrated doses of this chemical pollution into our bodies through bioaccumulation. Therefore, going Vegan addresses chemical pollution for both the Earth and ourselves.
#5. The next worst transgression is nitrogen and phosphorus loading, mainly through our overuse of synthetic fertilizers for crops. Since over half the crop outputs are fed to farmed animals, going Vegan will resolve this transgression as well.
#6. All of these transgressions impact wildlife, and biodiversity loss is the worst of the six planetary-boundary transgressions.
By restoring habitats for wild animals and allowing them to live freely in the ocean, we will resolve this transgression as well. If instead, we let wild animals die, we die. It is that serious.
Nine Planetary Boundaries Since 2009
| |
J. Morris Hicks added the above graphic of the nine planetary boundaries -- illustrating how badly we have performed since 2009. Dr Rao continues below: | |
There are two explanations for perhaps the gravest threat ever posed to civilization – and all life on earth: – the imminent danger of runaway climate change [8].
One explanation–the one we hear about all the time from our leading climate spokespeople–is the burning of fossil fuels. It is certainly true that the burning of fossil fuels contributes greenhouse gasses to the atmosphere, thereby warming the planet.
But the other explanation – what I call the Cow in the Room—is rarely addressed: The human folly of exploiting animals that is animal agriculture.
When these two sources of greenhouse gasses are compared in the media, fossil-fuel burning is always emphasized, and is almost always assigned the greater responsibility for warming the planet.
But the opposite is true. When you factor in the potential carbon absorption of the forest land cleared for animal agriculture, you find, with any honest accounting –- as I published in a peer-reviewed paper –- that animal agriculture is responsible for at least 87% of greenhouse gasses on an annual basis [9].
When I made that calculation:
-
I did not include the respiration of farmed animals.
-
I did not include the bottom trawling of the oceans by industrial fishing.
-
I did not include the carbon released by pasture-maintenance fires set annually on grazing lands around the world.
-
I did not include the loss of phytoplankton populations and sea forests due to industrial fishing.
I did not include those factors mainly because they haven’t been reliably assessed due to a futile attempt by the orthodoxy to hide the Cow in the Room.
But it seems clear to me that if we could estimate these factors and include them in the calculation, we would find that animal agriculture is responsible for – wait for it – well over 100% of greenhouse gas emissions into the atmosphere.
| | |
Now that sounds unbelievable, right?
How could it possibly be responsible for more than 100%?
Because the evidence points to the possibility that the earth will start cooling in a Vegan world even if we continue to conduct all our other activities as we do today.
The cessation of animal agriculture will result in healthy oceans, healthy forests and healthy soils, and if we want to reverse climate change, then we must adopt a strategy that can draw down greenhouse gasses from the atmosphere.
Healthy oceans and sea forests can do that. Healthy soils and trees can do that.
Solar panels and electric cars cannot.
Now, I am not a supporter of the fossil-fuel industry -– far from it. It is my engineering assessment that we must wean ourselves off fossil fuels gradually.
But we burn fossil fuels to heat and cool our homes, to transport ourselves, to manufacture goods, to ship goods. These are all social goods.
On the other hand, what social good comes
from animal agriculture?
-
Nothing. Only obesity, heart disease, diabetes, cancer, biodiversity destruction, soil depletion, fouling of our waterways, antibiotic resistance, dangerous and dehumanizing work, animal cruelty, climate catastrophe, world hunger -- and let’s not forget pandemics.
Indeed, there is nothing that will not improve when we end the cruelty and folly of exploiting animals.
I have just given you the intellectual reasons to Go Vegan, but lasting change comes not from the head, but from the heart.
| |
|
In that regard, I have made a pinky promise to our granddaughter, Kimaya, that the world will go largely Vegan by 2026, which is the year we will have killed almost all the wild animals if we don’t change course.
Ladies and Gentlemen, I am confident that true to your 200-year tradition of rebelling against false orthodoxy, this House will once again break away from the herd, see the Cow in the Room and vote for the proposition to help our generation keep this sacred promise for all the children of the world.
Thank you for your consideration, from the bottom of my heart!
Sailesh Rao
| |
|
The Bottom Line
from J. Morris Hicks
The above argument by Dr. Rao is the most compelling summary of this crucial topic that I have ever seen!
That's why I wanted to do my best to get it quickly into the hands, and brains, of the maximum number of people. Please share it with everyone you know.
Here are two links you can use to share it with others:
| |
|
Sincerely, Jim
For all of the innocent children...I'm just trying to do my part to "promote health, hope and harmony on planet Earth."
J. Morris Hicks — hpjmh.com
500 Bank Street, Suite 215
New London, CT 06320
jmorrishicks@me.com
PS: What can YOU do to help promote health, hope and harmony?
1st: Become a healthy vegan -- making sure that over 80% of your calories are derived from whole, plant-based foods. As such, you will be doing your part in dismantling the leading driver of climate change: global animal agriculture. As a personal bonus, you will get healthier, eliminate most prescription drugs, lose weight and save money at the same time.
2nd: Start "walking the talk" of sustainable living. Let your actions do the talking for your friends and family. My thoughts on that process are in my updated SOS Memo #200 from earlier this year.
3rd: Check out the FREE stuff in the appendix below and start sharing all of this info with your friends & family.
4th: Schedule a FREE Zoom call with me and your group. Contact me at jmorrishicks@me.com to arrange.
In the APPENDIX below, you can read about what we must do to understand much more about the climate dilemma in which we find ourselves -- along with what it will likely take to prevent a collapse of civilization.
This appendix can help you get that done:
Appendix to SOS Memos
(lots of data, FREE books, scientific reports, videos & more)
| |
|
You can join my mailing list and find all of my previous postings by visiting the SOS Memos page on my website.
Want some FREE professional help getting started eating whole, unprocessed plants? My friends at Rochester Lifestyle Medicine may have just what the doctor ordered. Check it out.
| |
Again, my primary website is hpjmh.com with a powerful summary that appears on the landing page. | |
|
Want to get started nurturing your own health
and the health of our planet?
Take our dietary survey at 4leafsurvey.com (2 min). With your answers to 12 multiple choice questions, the survey provides an estimate as to what percent of your daily calories are being derived from whole, plant-based foods.
Over 80% from whole plants = "4Leaf Level" of eating
(The average American or European gets less than 7%)
Click to learn all about this dietary assessment tool:
About the 4Leaf Survey
For much more about 4Leaf, visit 4leafprogram.com
Also: Link to the FREE e-copy of the The 4Leaf Guide
| | | | |