|
Here we go again…
Consultants in England plan to strike on 25th and 26th November. Emergency cover will continue, but…
Doctor Findlay is dead and Holby City long since closed in the cuts.
… patients facing disrupted appointments and treatment deserve a fuller explanation than the trope that; ministers have left doctors with no alternative.
The question is; what justifies putting this settlement ahead of other demands on public money.
Consultants carry exceptional responsibilities.
Their judgement saves lives; their teaching helps produce the next generation of specialists.
A health service that exhausts experienced doctors is storing up trouble, but…
… responsibility cannot confer an automatic first claim on the national purse. Nurses, care workers, teachers, the bin-men and the patients themselves have interests that government must weigh alongside those of senior doctors.
After five years as a consultant, pay is roughly three times the UK median full-time annual earnings of £40,911 in April 2026… ~£123,672 basic, and…
… 2011 BMA survey, quoted by the Competition Commission… the mean gross annual private income for a consultant to be approximately £72,000...
... about £111,100 in today’s money.
The BMA’s demands extend well beyond an annual salary increase. It wants to reduce the standard working week from 40 to 35 hours while maintaining basic pay…
… alongside more protected professional time and improved out-of-hours remuneration.
Reducing contracted hours by an eighth at the same salary, increases pay per contracted hour by approximately 14.3%.
That’s arithmetic, not an estimate of the eventual settlement’s cost.
Nevertheless, it is a substantial proposal whose consequences deserve public examination.
-
How would hospitals replace the hours?
-
How much additional staffing would be required?
-
What improvement in retention would make the change worthwhile?
England’s current consultant basic salary scale runs from £113,565 to £150,569.
Those figures exclude additional payments and should not be confused with take-home pay. They are, however, essential context when the public is asked to judge competing priorities.
High salaries don’t disprove overwork or unfair treatment. They do make it reasonable to demand a clear account of what a more generous settlement would do for patients.
The BMA’s headline; suffering a 25% reduction in 17 years needs some assumptions attached.
In its published comparison; for a consultant with five years’ service, covering 2008/09 to 2024/25, the reduction was 25.1% using RPI inflation and 11.8% using CPI.
That leaves the political question unanswered.
Why should restoring consultants’ former purchasing power take precedence over improving the circumstances of people who earn far less, or funding the treatment patients are waiting for now?
Historical loss is relevant. It does not, by itself, determine who should receive the next or the last, pound of public money.
Nor can ministers dismiss the dispute simply by invoking affordability.
The Government has planned for a 2.4% pay uplift in 2027/28, below the latest annual CPI inflation rate of 3.5%.
The award is not final, and future inflation remains uncertain, but consultants might have reasonable grounds to challenge that starting point.
Britain’s economy is growing, just.
Growth does not abolish the choices between higher pay, additional treatment, social care and investment.
Families facing rising prices are entitled to ask why one professional group’s preferred settlement should take precedence.
The consultants’ strongest answer is that better terms would keep experienced doctors working and improve the service.
Let's have a closer look.
Independent GMC research records, continuing workplace difficulties and greater pressure on trainers. Protected time for teaching and improving care has real value, but …
… the retention argument needs testing.
HMG’s evidence reports that consultant leaver-rates have fallen. It warns that awards above its funding assumption would require choices within existing health budgets.
Those are ministerial arguments to scrutinise, but they can’t simply be ignored.
The public should expect both sides to put numbers on the table;
-
the cost of the proposed changes,
-
the capacity they would release or remove, and
-
the results patients could expect.
The BMA’s ability to behave like thugs, to bully the Government into a settlement does not establish that consultants have the strongest claim on public money.
Ministers must answer to patients waiting for treatment, families struggling with bills and workers with no comparable bargaining power.
Consultants are entitled to argue for more.
They are not entitled to come first simply because they can make everyone else pay for saying no.
|