VIEW THIS EMAIL AS A WEBPAGE >>

16 January 2025 — “Clinton’s Ditch” Opens a Path Westward


One of the maritime milestones we are commemorating this year is the completion of the Erie Canal. On 26 October 1825 the United States celebrated the opening of the canal; cannons were fired in succession along the route from Buffalo to Albany. New York governor DeWitt Clinton and other dignitaries boarded the packet boat Seneca Chief with two ceremonial kegs of Lake Erie water and a cargo of goods representative of the bounty of the Great Lakes. On 4 November the boat had arrived at the other end of the canal in Albany and then made its way down the Hudson River to New York City. Governor Clinton poured water from the kegs into the harbor, creating a “wedding of the waters,” celebrating the navigable route between the Atlantic Ocean and the Great Lakes.

pen drawing of Gov Clinton pouring water off of side of boat from keg

Governor Clinton pouring water from Lake Erie into New York Harbor for a "Wedding of the Waters." Image: PD

The canal project was a response to practical challenges faced by the United States in its early expansion. The territories in the Great Lakes region were rich with commodities like timber and minerals, as well as promising farmland, and their settlers represented a growing market for goods from the east, but transporting goods overland was slow and expensive, and the Appalachian mountain range proved a daunting barrier. The young nation’s leaders knew that improving the transportation of people and goods between the states and territories was important for the nation’s economy, and also for national cohesion.


One of the notable proponents of such a canal was grain merchant Jesse Hawley, who attributed his bankruptcy to the high costs of shipping his grain to market in the East. Using the nom de plume “Hercules,” Hawley penned a series of essays appearing in the Genesee Messenger in 1807 in favor of building a canal from Lake Erie. The idea found favor with many in the New York state legislature, and in 1810 that body appointed seven men to the Commission to Explore a Route for a Canal to Lake Erie and Report, a name that would be shortened to the Erie Canal Commission. One noteworthy member of the Commission was DeWitt Clinton, a skilled politician and mayor of New York City. His name would be most closely associated with the project; detractors loved to call the canal “Clinton’s Ditch” or “Clinton’s Folly.”


The commissioners set about exploring the practical challenges of building the canal; since such an undertaking on this scale was new to American shores, they dispatched amateur engineer Canvass White to thoroughly study the canal system in the United Kingdom. At the same time, they were bending the ears of legislators to build support for the project. The federal government exhibited little interest in funding such a grand undertaking; the difficulties in a small canal project to bypass the falls in the Potomac River had soured many in the nation’s capital on the idea of a canal on a larger scale. President Thomas Jefferson thought it a great idea, but too immense an undertaking for the time. If the canal were to be built at all, the burden would have to be shouldered by New York State alone. On 1 July 1817 Clinton assumed the office of governor of the state, and three days later construction began on his “Great Ditch.”

advertisement with list of tolls charged per weight of various cargoes on the canal

Canal tolls were assessed by weight. When the canal opened, the cost for shipping many types of cargo was one-tenth of the price it would have cost to ship it over land via wagon. PD

The “Erie School of Engineering”


The United States at this time had no native-born trained civil engineers, and had to rely on trained engineers from abroad. One of those men, Englishman William Weston, was described by historian Elting E. Morison in this way: “Knowing not much, he knew a great deal more than anyone else and was in frequent demand.” The commission instead entrusted men with proven surveying experience for the undertaking, and those men would learn on the job and adapt their approaches to the circumstances for each portion of the waterway. The chief engineer of the canal was Benjamin Wright; assistant chief engineer was James Geddes. The commission had evidence of their surveying skill, at least, when in the spring of 1818 Wright and Geddes took readings to record the elevations along the course of the canal; they covered two different routes from Rome to Syracuse. When their readings were compared afterwards, the difference between them was less than two inches. Charles Brodhead would be appointed chief engineer of the eastern portion of the canal. Writing in American Heritage’s Invention & Technology, author John Tarkov wrote of what would later be dubbed the Erie School of Engineering:


In all the many other details of canal building, they learned as they went, becoming engineers long after the title had been conferred on them. This was as true for the younger engineers on the canal as it was for men like Geddes and Wright. Virtually every American engineer of consequence during the first half of the nineteenth century learned his profession either on the Erie Canal or from an engineer who had been there. The Erie was truly, as a number of historians have said, America’s first school of engineering. Men learned things there because they had to, and they learned them in whatever way they could: by mistakes, by watching and asking questions, and by accepting expert authority without regard to rank.


The planned waterway was divided into three parts: east, middle, and west, each with its own topographical challenges. The engineers invented and adapted as they worked. Two useful inventions were a machine for felling trees and one for pulling stumps, speeding up the process of clearing land. Canvass White, who had observed the English canal system, adapted the formula for hydraulic cement, which was the hard and durable substance used in lining canal locks and arches, to the types of limestone found near the canal construction. The local formulization eliminated the need to import hydraulic cement from England, which would have necessitated either a much higher budget or substituting a less desirable construction method.


The completed Erie Canal celebrated by Governor Clinton in 1825 was 363 miles long, from Albany to Buffalo. It had 83 locks and 18 aqueducts. The total cost was $7,143,789 (roughly $228 million today). The laborers, armed with simple tools like axes and shovels, were paid between 80 cents and a dollar a day. The canal would contribute to the rapid expansion of cities along its banks like Buffalo, Albany, Syracuse and Rochester, earning the waterway yet another nickname: “Mother of Cities.” As a project that drastically transformed the landscape in parts of the state, however, the canal also exacted a human cost, displacing the indigenous peoples who had lived in its path.

hand drawn map of New York with names of tribes of the Haudenosaunee nation

“Map of Ho De No Sau Nee Ga or the Territories of the People of the Long House in 1720” by Lewis H. Morgan, 1857. In the drive to create a canal network, indigenous people were displaced from their lands, separating them from waterways and other natural elements integral to their cultural practices. PD

The canal was a marvel for its time; a symbol of man’s conquest of nature and a physical representation of America’s drive westward that would eventually lead it to the shores of the Pacific. It fed the new western territories with immigrants and served to maintain their connection to the eastern part of the country as the borders stretched. The Erie Canal promised the country that a waterway, even a man-made one, would be a means of transportation, communication, and an enduring part of our culture. 



Extra Credit


Digital exhibition: Two Hundred Years on the Erie Canal


History of the Erie Canal Documentary


Mules on the Erie Canal




Sea History Today is written by Shelley Reid, NMHS senior staff writer. Past issues can be read online by clicking here.

Facebook  Twitter  Instagram  YouTube