|
Hi everyone,
We're emailing you yet again because we have one correction and one clarification to yesterday's newsletter:
Correction: New Date for Public Meeting
At yesterday's Board of County Commissioners (BCC) meeting it was announced that in light of the FAA proposed permanent restrictions, the BCC would discuss what to do with the lawsuit at the Budget Meeting scheduled for Thursday, September 3rd at 5 PM.
Gregg objected, arguing that this did not provide adequate notice for residents to attend.
But the County Attorney argued that the 48-hour notice was legally sufficient.
This morning the County Attorney called Gregg to let him know that upon further review the September 3rd date was not an option because the notice requirement for budget meetings is seven days, not 48 hours. Because of this, the meeting where the BCC will discuss the proposed FAA restrictions and what to do with the lawsuit will now be added on to the Agenda for the BCC meeting that is scheduled for September 15th, starting at 9:30 AM.
Clarification: AI-generated summary could mislead
In our rush to deliver an update on the Mar-a-Lago flight restrictions and the FAA's Notice of Proposed Rule Making (NPRM), one of our highly engaged readers pointed out some potentially misleading information in our AI-generated Summary. They cited these problematic sections and provided clarification that we are sharing with you:
How the Airspace Rules Work:
During High-Security Travel (Active TFRs): When President Trump or other high profile public figures are actively traveling in the area, the FAA will temporarily issue a Temporary Flight Restriction (TFR). During these times, pilots must follow the much stricter temporary flight rules and security alerts that are issued.
During Normal Times (No TFR Active).
The reader suggested the following additions to the AI-generated summary that might help clarify to residents why this is a very dangerous moment, and that they are advised to act and register their views in a short period of time:
1. "Operating normally" means the rerouted flight paths stay — permanently.
The summary says airlines will "continue to operate normally." Today's "normal" is the configuration created in October 2025, when flights were rerouted off their historic paths and concentrated over neighborhoods northeast of the airport — affecting, by the airport's own estimate, about four times as many residents as before, and generating more than 6,000 noise complaints (versus fewer than a dozen a month historically). This rule makes permanent the airspace behind that rerouting. The FAA's "no extra costs" conclusion is real but narrow: its analysis counted costs to pilots, airlines, and small businesses only. Residents under the relocated flight paths appear nowhere in it.
2. Airport flights are allowed through the zone on paper — but not in practice.
The rule's text permits aircraft landing at or departing the airport to fly through the one-mile zone on approved routes. But the routes the FAA currently approves were redesigned in January 2026 specifically to avoid the zone — that is why the noise moved. So the "allowed flights" list should not be read as "planes fly the way they used to." Notably, nothing in the proposed rule requires the rerouting to continue: the rule would permit the FAA to restore flight procedures through the area tomorrow. The rerouting persists as a separate FAA choice — one the FAA's own Chief Operating Officer recommended against, urging a "commercial traffic exemption" or a smaller zone instead. (Controllers already route airliners through the heart of the zone whenever wind conditions require it.)
3. The zone's ceiling is double what the Secret Service asked for — and the FAA's new justification fails against flight records.
The Secret Service's September 2025 request (in the rulemaking docket) asked for a ceiling of 1,000 feet. The FAA imposed 2,000 feet. If the ceiling were lowered to 1,000 feet, as the Secret Service requested, then all outbound flights could continue to fly exactly as they did before any flight restrictions were imposed (as outbound flights are above 1,000 feet by the time they reach Mar-a-Lago). 1,000 feet is also the ceiling that was just ruled on in the Trump Tower flight restriction in NYC.
4. The restriction would be permanent and around-the-clock — including when the President is not in Florida — with no end date and no review requirement.
The proposed rule contains no sunset provision and no requirement that the FAA ever revisit it. That is the break from history, not the continuation of it: the FAA's own proposal recounts that the flight restrictions over the homes of Presidents Nixon, Carter, and Reagan were all revoked when each president left office — and Reagan's Pacific Palisades zone was revoked mid-term, when the Secret Service said it was no longer needed. President Bush's Crawford ranch zone was cut in half in 2010 for the same reason. Making the past practice the model would mean writing a review-and-termination condition into the rule. The proposal contains none.
5. Residents have roughly 30 days to be heard
Comments are due about October 2, 2026 (30 days from the September 2 publication) at regulations.gov, Docket No. FAA-2026-10827. This is the public's only guaranteed opportunity to shape a rule with no expiration date, and objections filed in this docket are what preserve the right to challenge the final rule in court later.
If you want to comment, click the link (submit online comments) below.
Submit online comments
We appreciate your understanding and patience as we sort through these fast-moving events, and encourage you to email our office with any questions: district2@pbc.gov
|