|
There's an old Whitehall joke…
… the left hand doesn't know what the right hand is doing...
... sometimes you wonder if they're even attached to the same body.
The government's business department wants to protect workers from exploitative zero-hours contracts.
Fair-enough.
NHS Employers says the proposed reforms could cost the health service £900m a year.
Not so, fair-enough.
Meanwhile, NHS England is instructing hospitals to cut spending on bank staff by between 7.5% and 15% annually over the next three years.
Work that one out.
One arm of government potentially makes flexible staffing more expensive. Another demands hospitals spend less on it.
Has anyone joined the dots?
The legislation is designed to give workers predictable hours, reasonable notice of shifts and compensation when shifts are cancelled at short notice.
All perfectly understandable, but hospitals are not supermarkets...
... nobody knows how many patients will turn up at A&E tomorrow, which nurse will call in sick or which ward will suddenly need reinforcements.
The NHS depends on staff banks to keep services running.
Around 85% of bank workers already have substantive NHS contracts. They choose to work extra shifts, often because the flexibility suits them.
The proposals could turn that simple arrangement into an administrative nightmare.
NHS Employers estimates the new rules could require more than 1,400 additional administrative and management staff equivalents.
That's around seven for every NHS trust, including mental health, community and ambulance services. At precisely the time the NHS is cutting management costs.
It puts the recurring annual cost at £900m.
That's an estimate, not an invoice. The detailed workings aren't publicly available and NHS Employers acknowledges the precise impact is uncertain, but even half that amount would be an unwelcome surprise.
Here's the question.
Why should the NHS receive exemptions that private-sector employers might be denied?
Care homes, hospitality businesses and retailers also face unpredictable demand. The answer cannot simply be that the NHS is special.
The distinction should be between workers who depend on insecure hours and people with permanent jobs, who voluntarily take additional shifts.
The same principle could apply to everyone, but… there's another, more intriguing question.
Who in Whitehall is supposed to make sure one department's bright idea doesn't land another with an enormous bill?
The answer is in HMTreasury's Consolidated Budgeting Guidance.
(paragraphs 1.63 onwards)
It says, [sic];
'...departments proposing policies must quantify the financial consequences, including costs falling on other departments. They must consult, agree how the costs will be financed and do so before the policy decision', and…
… here's the fascinating bit…
… ‘unless otherwise agreed’, the normal presumption is that the department originating the policy absorbs the additional costs.
Read that again… it raises some interesting questions.
-
Did the business department consult DH++?
-
Did DH++'s permanent secretary, as accounting officer, establish what the changes could cost?
-
Did Treasury sign off the financial consequences… and most importantly...
...who agreed to pick up the bill?
Dunno.
Perhaps everything has been properly assessed, agreed and funded.
Perhaps the final regulations will accommodate the NHS's concerns and the £900m will evaporate.
NHS Employers has publicly called for a full financial impact assessment before the rules are finalised.
That hardly inspires confidence in HMG, that the financial consequences have been settled.
There is an entire Whitehall machinery designed to prevent precisely this sort of problem.
- Permanent secretaries,
- accounting officers,
- interdepartmental consultations,
- Cabinet committees,
- impact assessments
- Treasury spending rules.
The machinery exists. Is anyone using it?
There is a much bigger issue, here.
The NHS already struggles to distinguish between genuinely unpredictable staffing demands and permanent vacancies disguised as temporary shortages.
It shouldn't need insecure employment to cover predictable gaps.
Equally, employment protections shouldn't make it unnecessarily difficult to staff a hospital safely.
Both problems are manageable, but they require government departments to work together, understand operational reality and agree who pays before announcing what everyone else must do.
The legislation isn't yet fully implemented. The DH++ has time to get this right.
So, before anyone starts arguing about exemptions, perhaps Parliament should ask three simple questions.
-
Who calculated the cost?
-
Who approved it?
-
Who is paying?
The NHS (and fire services) may need an exemption from the new rules. What it really needs is an explanation of who agreed to the bill for the Bill.... Rayner or Cooper?
And, if nobody did...
...has the NHS been stitched up?
|