FROM THE DIRECTOR
Since April 15, 2015 Akumal has been in the spotlight with the announcements of public policy instruments for the conservation and efficient use of the marine resources.
 
Public policy instruments, when effective, are models that governments use to execute strategies to achieve conservation objectives. However, these instruments and decrees of protected areas and conservation frameworks seem to serve as a very convenient moment for the politicians to make political speeches for the sake of the abundant photo opportunities, hand-shaking ceremonies and press coverage. Yet the actual decision-making and implementation based on technical and scientific evidence is lacking.
 
Unfortunately, so far, not one public policy instrument has provided a clear and successful mechanism for efficient management of Akumal Bay. On the contrary, it seems the more conservation frameworks are established the more chaotic and confusing the situation becomes.
 
In our 24 years of existence as a non-profit organization we have produced information that is intended to provide various elements focused on the appropriate use of the coastal and marine resources in Akumal. In many instances, we have collaborated with national and international research institutes, other NGOs, government bodies and individuals with strong knowledge and background on water quality, geohydrology, geography, biodiversity, fisheries, environmental education and design and the operation of protected areas, amongst others.
 
What is more, throughout these years we have pursued to have a well-informed and participative community regarding the decision taking, besides its marked differences in origin, culture and background.
 
As an example, the push for and finally the establishment of the Akumal Fish Refuge in April 2015 was possible due to the active participation of all sectors of Akumal and similarly for the Akumal Bay Refuge Area for the Protection of Marine Species in March 2016.
 
Unfortunately, the decree process of a third framework, the Biosphere Reserve of the Mexican Caribbean (made in December 2016) arose merely as an international commitment made by the Mexican government to increase the protected area of the country´s overall marine-coastal and terrestrial surface. The overall objectives were not clear and the process was not transparent---community consultation, expert input, scientific data to support the initial declaration were missing.
 
So far, the authorities have not been able to publish the final regulation instruments of the three conservation frameworks:
  • the Management Plan for the Akumal Fish Refuge
  • the Protection Program for the Refuge of Protected Marine Species
  • the Management Program for the Biosphere Reserve.
The management plans or programs (specific to each decreed area) would outline details for the protection and conservation efforts including the use of the resources as well as activities within these areas. 

Currently, the Protection Program (for the Refuge of Protected Marine Species) is under the revision of the authorities after the final draft went through public consultation. Although the final version is still unknown, it seems that this Program was not designed for the original intention of species protection as a whole, but only to regulate the commercial activities related to snorkeling with turtles tours.
 
This creates confusion amongst the users of the bay (swimmers, boat traffic, dive practices, scientific research, coral restoration, etc), especially regarding the delimited areas for the snorkelling with turtles. A vast majority of people have complained on several accounts regarding the unclear rules, poor law enforcement, the lack of action and knowledge of the on-site inspectors, the role some of the community members play in persuading the tourists to follow rules (bad manners and aggressive conduct towards the tourists), the constant display of disputes and fights between members of the abundant cooperatives, the high number of permit holders operating in an unsustainable way, the unclear manner and methods used to estimate the bay's carrying capacity and the inefficient buoy system that disregards safety, as there is no delineation to keep swimmers away from navigation channels.
 
In Mexico, there are a very few cases of species refuge areas and none of them have proven effective so far. An example is the "Vaquita Marine Refuge Area" in the Gulf of California. In 2012 a refuge was declared by the Mexican authorities to protect the Vaquita's dwindling population. Yet, despite the implementation of this refuge the Vaquita's continued drop in numbers indicates that it is ineffective and unsuccessful.
 
READ MORE ABOUT THE VAQUITA
The Protection Program for the Vaquita Refuge was used as a model to elaborate the Protection Program for the Akumal Bay Protected Marine Species Refuge. Seeing the results of the Vaquita Refuge leaves me with very little faith in the success of this regulation instrument here in Akumal.
 
As a complement to the Protection Program in Akumal for the non-extractive use of marine turtles (snorkelling with turtles), SEMARNAT, through the General Direction of Wild Life issues the tour permits based on individual Management Plans created by each operator. These plans should include information on the species subjected to exploitation (touristic activity), its environment, the way the activities would be performed in time and space, the number of tourists to be attended per day (a wish number not necessarily a scientific estimate), the staff employed and the equipment and installations utilized.
 
The activity of non-extractive exploitation of the marine turtles in the Akumal Bay has not been effective.  As an example, the number of permit holders has grown exponentially in the last years from 5 permitted groups in 2015 to more than 30 groups in 2017. It is unknown what criterion the authorities applied to issue the permits. But clearly having more actors interacting with tourists, divers and boats in a reduced space of less than 20 hectares of a very fragile and extremely deteriorated ecosystem hasn't swayed the authorities' decision in issuing permits in a sustainable or scientific-based way.
 
To have a fully effective Refuge Area all three authorities (SEMARNAT, CONANP and PROFEPA) must be in constant coordination-knowing who is permitted to operate, effectively managing the refuge area and enforcing any violations. But when there are marginal coordinated efforts with what appears as minimal management of the protected area and poor communication and dissemination of information, deeper levels of confusion is created for all users of the Bay.
 
In this regard, the Biosphere Reserve could bring all the necessary elements for better overall management. Most recently, CONANP has carried out the first preliminary workshop with different sectors of the society to help create a better Management Program. CEA has participated actively providing information that can be used for better decisions and better management of the Akumal Bay with maps of the bathymetry, marine turtles distribution, high resolution imagery showing the presence of reef within the newly created circuits established by CONANP and a map of the seagrass abundance and distribution in conjunction with UNAM. By all means, we have tried to persuade the authorities of the rationality and value of such information and the need to incorporate scientific-based decisions into the Management Program.
 
We urge CONANP to reconsider the information that led them to establish the swim circuits and the regulations for swimming with turtles. It is worth clarifying that the swim circuits and the buoy system derived from the carrying capacity study concluded in December 2016 was not shared nor was there indication on how the carrying capacity or snorkeling circuits/routes were determined within the Protection Program. 
 
Had CONANP used more accurate information to include in the Protection Program and the decisions to establish a buoy system, or SEMARNAT for the swim with turtle permits, we may not have the current layers of confusion we currently see in Akumal today.
 
However, we are facing a good opportunity to improve the decision making based on more technical and scientific information, especially that obtained from local, Akumal-based research and not based on other instruments or plans from elsewhere in the country.
 
The Management Program of the Biosphere Reserve of the Mexican Caribbean is underway. It implies the order of much greater and diversified amount of activities in more than 5 million hectares. It is a real challenge for the authorities. Therefore, it is imperative the process of its elaboration is inclusive, allows and promotes the active participation of all sectors of the society and includes relevant scientific information. This can be the solution to a better and more organised Akumal Bay.
 
Our role as NGOs is to work to improve conditions of life of the communities based on outreach activities, environmental education, research and support. This must be achieved in collaboration with the academia, research institutes, private sector, other NGOs, society in general, and the relevant authorities.
 
We are keen to pursue a better and close collaboration with all actors, especially with the authorities, however, a more scrutinized revision of all proposals is needed before their publication and implementation.
 
The Management Program of the Biosphere is said to be published by October this year. Ensuring the commitment of all parties to contribute to an effective instrument is a priority. By the end of the year we will be able to know the final version of the document and we will inform.

MONTHLY "RECICLATON" COMES TO AKUMAL
Beginning in April, a reciclaton has been held monthly in Akumal pueblo. So far, a grand total of
5,254 kilograms of recycled materials has been collected since April. 

As a reminder, the Reciclaton is the last Friday of every month. The next dates are below. Be sure to circle your calendars and bring your clean and dry recyclables to the Akumal Domo. 
FISH REFUGE MONITORING AND SURVEILLANCE PROJECT 
As most of you are aware the Fish Refuge Monitoring and Surveillance Project was launched in January of this year. Since then, significant progress has been made:
 
Video Surveillance
Most cameras have been installed within the fish refuge and are now allowing for a continuous stream of video to monitor any illegal activity.
 
Data Tracking + Collecting
The smart phone app to document sport fishing activity has gone through the design phase and is currently in the beta test phase before being launched to additional commercial/sport fishing outfits.
 
Community Involvement
CEA hosted its first training workshop with the Fishing Coop of Tulum (Pescadores de Tulum) to go over protocols and procedures as they will be assisting in the monitoring and surveillance of the project by land and sea.
 
As part of the project, a survey has been created to help gauge the public's current understanding of the fish refuge. Conclusions and results from the survey will provide direction for future information campaigns. We would love it if you could offer your input.

The survey should take about 5-7 minutes of your time. 

TAKE THE FISH REFUGE SURVEY
 

SURVEILLANCE TEAM FOR AKUMAL FISH REFUGE

As part of our commitment to ensuring the sustainable use and conservation of natural resources in Akumal, in particular related to the Akumal Fish Refuge, we are pleased to announce the start of community surveillance operations that the Fishing Cooperative of Tulum / Cooperativa de Productividad Pesquera Pescadores de Tulum (SCPPT) under the agreement with the National Commission of Protected Natural Areas and PROFEPA.

The surveillance team will be conducting scheduled land-based patrols in both evenings and days along various routes in Akumal with the objective of detecting, gathering evidence and filing official complaints to the competent authorities of for both illicit fishing and environmental activities.  Please note that the schedule will not be made public as the intention is not to alert those participating in illegal fishing within the refuge. 

The surveillance patrols of the SCPPT will be supported by the technologies installed at CEA, such as video surveillance cameras, the use of an application for mobile devices, as well as a monitoring drone.
          
In order to be easily recognizable, the surveillance personnel will wear a uniform and an identification badge with relevant information including their photo and name. 
We appreciate your support with this important task of monitoring the proper use and preservation of the natural resources of Akumal.
15TH ANNUAL FESTIVAL DE LA TORTUGA MARINA 

Save the dates! The 15th annual Festival de la Tortuga Marina will be held on October 20, 21 and 22. 

For more information be sure to like the Festival's facebook page.
BIENNIAL MEETING FOR REEF RESTORATION NETWORK TO BE HELD IN AKUMAL

We are pleased to announce that the Reef Restoration Network Biennial Meeting with be held in Akumal in the fall. This meeting is a chance for various organizations and bodies in the four countries along the Mesoamerican Reef  (Mexico, Honduras, Guatemala and Belize) to participate in workshops and strategy sessions under the context of restoring/conserving the second large reef system in the world. 

More information and details will be available on our website soon. 
Recyclables Fashion Show
Students from the Telesecundaria Jose Vasconcelos designed and created clothing made from recycled material. Students then took part in a fashion show with other students from CECYTE in Tulum, and staff from Bahia Principe. 

Images below show two students who created and showcased their designs. 
Final Annual Turtle Report 2016 
Our data has been crunched and finalized, a report sent to the authorities and the abbreviated/translated version is now available online. 

2017 TURTLE SEASON
Turtle season is in full swing. For residents, hotels and condos, there are resources on our website for your information or to pass to your guests on how to help protect the turtles and ensure a successful nesting season. 

Nesting Updates
Just like last year, we are keeping a running tally of nest counts and posting them to our Facebook page. 

As of August 17, 2017, there were 1006 nests on the four beaches monitored and patrolled by CEA's Turtle Team. 

Turtle Talk + Walk Series
For those interested in learning more and observing nesting activity, join us for our Turtle Talk + Walk Series. If you are interested, please drop a us line for more information--www.communications.ceakumal@gmail.com. 
Special Guests at CEA
Las Alamos Secondary School
On June 12, close to 200 students from Las Alamos Secondary School in Cancun came to Akumal on a field trip to learn about the karst system and water quality, corals and monitoring activities and of course turtles.
 
Students learned theory and then focused on practical land-based hands-on activities to reinforce their learnings---for example, identifying turtle tracks and the difference between a nest and an attempt, how to identify healthy corals from bleached or damaged corals and understanding how to better protect our natural resources. Below is a collection of images from the students´activities throughout the day. 

Note that the turtle used is an acrylic model and Styrofoam balls were used as a substitute for turtle eggs. Students worked as a tortuguero would in the relocation of a nest.
Volunteer Opportunities
COASTAL ECOSYSTEMS
Coral Reef Monitoring + Research: Phase 2
SEPTEMBER 2---NOVEMBER 30
Volunteers will monitor both fish and corals, and each of the volunteers is expected to specialize in either one of these. Before you can start the actual monitoring work, you must be able to identify 100% of the coral or fish species encountered here to make sure the data collected is accurate. 

The first three weeks of this project will mostly be spent learning fishes or corals,becoming familiar with the monitoring methodology, and going snorkelling in the bay for some underwater identification practice. You will also be given general lectures (wildlife, reefs, oceanography, etc.) to give you a better perspective on your work. By week four you should be ready to start monitoring. 
Your support helps our conservation efforts.
CENTRO ECOLÓGICO AKUMAL| www.ceakumal.org | + 52 984-875-9095

STAY CONNECTED