The Texas Medical Association (TMA) recently obtained a successful verdict on its legal challenge in federal court to parts of HHS’ interim rules implementing the federal No Surprises Act (NSA). HHS has since announced it will be issuing updated guidance to comply with the Court’s ruling. They will comply with the court's order by 1) withdrawing and updating guidance documents that relied on the now-vacated provisions of the rule; 2) providing training on any new guidance; and 3) opening the arbitration process. In particular, federal officials will allow arbitration to be initiated within 15 business days after the independent dispute resolution portal is opened.
The No Surprises Act (NSA) is the new federal law that protects patients with ERISA plans from the most pervasive types of surprise out-of-network bills. The lawsuit argued that parts of the Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR) rule were inconsistent with the actual terms of the NSA and should be invalidated. Judge Jeffrey Kernodle of the Eastern District of Texas (Tyler) agreed and vacated these provisions on a nationwide basis.
TMA challenged the rule’s so-called “rebuttable presumption” that directed IDR entities to assume that the QPA is the appropriate out-of-network payment amount unless a party submits credible information that clearly demonstrates that the QPA is materially different from the appropriate out-of-network rate. This standard, plaintiffs argued, was unlawful because it is inconsistent with the NSA‘a specific terms and exceeds the scope of the agencies’ authority. TMA additionally argued that the federal agencies should have provided an opportunity for advance public notice and comment. In each case, the plaintiffs asked the court to vacate the challenged provisions of the interim final rule.
There is also a separate broader challenge to the NSA itself that argues that major parts of the statute—the provisions that establish the IDR process and the provisions that bar providers from sending balance bills—are unconstitutional.
The overall IDR process is not disturbed and will still be available to resolve payment disputes between payers and out-of-network providers. But Judge Kernodle’s ruling sets aside parts of the IDR rule—the parts that gave guidance to IDR entities—that were meant to help keep health care costs down. With those guardrails no longer in place, providers could be more likely to use the federal IDR process to obtain higher out-of-network payments when doing so is not warranted. This could make the IDR process more likely to become inflationary, leading to higher health care costs and premiums.
This decision will inform ongoing activity at the agencies and in other courts. Federal officials have already indicated that they will issue a final IDR rule by May 2022 and will likely be reviewing Judge Kernodle’s decision with an eye towards whether the final rule can include provisions that are similar to those in the interim final rule—as well as whether to rescind or replace the challenged provisions. The final rule will likely affect the timeline of current litigation and perhaps trigger future lawsuits.
In the meantime, other lawsuits are pending: the TMA lawsuit is one of six NSA-related legal challenges that have been filed by health care providers. Briefing has now been completed in two cases pending in the District of Columbia where a hearing may soon be scheduled. And briefing is ongoing or could soon begin in lawsuits in Georgia, Illinois, and New York.