|
How do we bring the equity and excellence approach to grading? | |
Here’s the latest from Creative Leadership Solutions, where we believe in evidence, passion, and results. We value respect, trust, service, collaboration, and reason. As we put the finishing touches on the latest publication from Creative Leadership Press, Fearless Grading, we've been thinking about how we bring the equity and excellence approach to conversations with our clients across the country. | |
FEATURED CONTENT
Grading Reform Without Tears: From Theory to Action
Leaders, have you thought about your summer professional development needs? Are you on a journey toward more equitable grading practices that focus on fairness and accuracy? This May 23 webinar highlighted the journey to achieving grading that is focused on fairness, accuracy, and learning. They discussed highlights and challenges from implementing the 4,3,2,1 grade scale and provided strategies to help teachers put the work into action in the classroom.
Watch past webinars
Register for upcoming webinars
| |
| |
|
The Schools We Need Now:
The Critical Middle Level
(It features a current principal and two previous principals.)
June 6, 2023
3:00-4:00 ET
| |
Read More
Further reading to explore equity and excellence in grading
| |
If school officials remain fixated on test scores as the ultimate measure of accountability, they will miss the big picture of what schools can accomplish. Numbers cannot tell the whole story. How can you expand how you measure the efficacy, excellence, and narrative of your school? | |
While the we may have left the darkest days of the pandemic behind us, there are lessons about equity, excellence, and adaptability that can still serve us. Check out this conversation between Douglas Reeves and Joe Feldman from 2020, the takeaways from which impact grading practices today. | |
Service Highlight
Just one of the many services we offer
| |
|
Action Research Task Force for Improved Grading Practices
Effective feedback is one of the most important impacts on student achievement. Grading is a critical part of feedback. When grading practices are improved, there is a consequent improvement in student achievement, classroom climate, school discipline, increased elective offerings, and teacher morale. Despite this evidence of positive impact of improved feedback and grading practices, the subjects of grading and reporting are among the most hotly debated and emotional issues in education. Most grading systems, particularly at the secondary level, have not changed for more than a century. Despite a mountain of evidence testifying to the ineffectiveness of traditional grading practices the vast majority of schools persist in them. Even more recent movements, such as “standards-based grading,” are fraught with peril if they are not established on a firm foundation of trust and communication among faculty, students, parents, administrators, and governing board members.
CLS will collaborate with teachers and leaders in either a virtual, blended, or live format. CLS will support the facilitation of the Action Research Task Force and support the district in analyzing their existing grading and reporting structure, leaving with a plan to make significant improvements that will bear fruit in the form of better engagement and student results. In addition to facilitating the grading task force meetings, each day CLS is in the district CLS will meet with the cabinet, district and school leaders, department leaders, and teacher-leaders, as directed by the district. CLS will provide feedback to district leadership on school and district meetings and classroom observations.
| |
CLS Associates understand that every system is unique. | |
| |
Dr. Terry Metzger has 35 years experience in education. She has enjoyed a wide variety of experiences in her career, beginning with early childhood and afterschool programs, teaching in middle and elementary school settings, and serving as a school and district administrator. She is currently the Superintendent of Denair Unified School District. Additionally, Terry is passionate about coaching and mentoring new and aspiring educational leaders.
Dr. Metzger believes that schools must provide students with the skills they need to effectively compete in our global economy. She says, “It is critical for students to apply their learning to solve challenging problems and equally important for them to conduct themselves with integrity as they work with others in college, the workplace, and life. Because students learn in different ways and at different rates, schools should provide a variety of rich opportunities for students to build upon their strengths and connect learning to their lives.” Two current initiatives related to this broad goal are the implementation of equitable grading practices and the development of career technical education pathways.
| |
We want to work on grading reform in my district, but every time we bring it up, there is a lot of push back. How can we move forward without picking a fight? | |
It can be daunting to reform something that strikes a different chord with everyone involved. Teachers, students, and parents all have personal experiences with grading that influence their perspective. When we tinker with perspectives, we have to offer safe alternative thinking routes. Here are three that might help keep the conversation going:
-
There are a lot of things that won’t change when we change our grading practices. Students will still earn grades for each course. We will still have report cards, transcripts, and Honor Roll. We will still provide specialized instruction for English learners and students with disabilities. Reassurance that many of our practices won’t change can help people be open to examining one or two areas of change.
-
Grades are feedback; a way to communicate how well students are doing with the concepts presented. We want to communicate with students and their parents accurately, and we want to evaluate student performance fairly. Focusing on those two things – fair and accurate – requires us to rethink how we’ve been doing things up to this point. Because all parties will typically agree that we want things to be fair and accurate, this puts us on the same team.
-
If we want students to improve their performance, we have to give them feedback that is specific and timely. It’s not enough to say, “You didn’t do well on this assignment.” Giving specifics and offering a chance to do something with that feedback helps students know what they need to do differently. Helping students take ownership of their learning is another idea with which people can typically agree.
When we center our conversations around FAST (Fair, Accurate, Specific, and Timely) feedback as a way to improve outcomes for students, it becomes our common WHY. Knowing the why allows us to move on to the WHAT and the HOW collectively rather than each person holding tightly to their own perspective.
| | | | |
Creative Leadership Solutions | Website | |
| | | |