|
St. Cuthbert Anglican Church | "Growing, Knowing & Sharing God's Love" | |
St. Cuthbert's, here is your weekly focus on things that are
happening in the parish. Read and stay connected.
| | |
Sibling Rivalry, Grace, and Resentment: Comparing Cain & Abel with the Parable of the Prodigal Son
This past week, as I went through my Bible reading, I could not but wonder about the comparison between the two storied brothers, Cain & Abel, and the brothers in the Parable of the Prodigal Son. If you take a deeper look across Biblical literature, the dynamic between brothers serves as a profound lens through which human nature, divine favour, and moral choice are examined. Few pairings capture the human heart's capacity for envy, alienation, and grace quite like Cain and Abel (Genesis 4) and the Two Brothers in the Parable of the Prodigal Son (Luke 15).
1. The Tale of Genesis: Cain and Abel
In the foundational narrative of Genesis 4, Adam and Eve’s firstborn sons present contrasting offerings to God:
-
Abel, a keeper of sheep, brings the firstborn of his flock with a heart of faith.
-
Cain, a tiller of the ground, brings an offering of the fruit of the ground.
When God has regard for Abel’s offering but not Cain's, Cain’s countenance falls. God issues a timeless warning: “Sin is crouching at your door; it desires to have you, but you must rule over it." Tragically, Cain fails to master his jealousy, leading to the first murder in human history.
-
The Core Tragedy: Cain’s resentment hardens into hostility. Instead of examining his own heart, he projects his failure onto his brother, destroying the very relationship that could have offered mutual support.
2. The Parable of Grace: The Prodigal and the Elder Brother
Millennia later, Jesus tells the Parable of the Prodigal Son (Luke 15:11–32), featuring another pair of brothers with starkly different attitudes:
-
The Younger Son demands his inheritance early, squanders it in reckless living, hits rock bottom, and returns home seeking mere servanthood. Instead, he is met with a lavish, unconditional embrace from his father.
-
The Elder Brother has stayed home, worked faithfully, and abided by the rules. Upon hearing the music and dancing for his wayward brother, he flies into a rage, refusing to enter the house.
-
The Core Tension: Like Cain, the elder brother is consumed by perceived injustice: Why celebrate someone who did everything wrong while I laboured faithfully?
3. Side-by-Side Comparison
| | |
4. Deep Theological Parallels
Examining these stories side-by-side reveals striking structural parallels:
-
The Danger of Self-Justification: Both Cain and the Elder Brother operate on a merit-based economy. Cain believes his sacrifice should have been accepted; the elder brother believes his obedience earns him exclusive rights to the father's favour.
-
The Anatomy of Resentment: In both texts, resentment begins internally (a fallen countenance, a bitter complaint) and threatens to sever community.
-
The Pursuit of the Disgruntled: In both accounts, the divine or paternal figure actively pursues the disgruntled brother. God questions Cain (“Why are you angry?”); the father leaves the party to entreat the older son (“Son, you are always with me...”).
5. Psychological Analysis - The Psychology of Merit, Envy, and Alienation of The Two Parallels
Both Cain (Genesis 4) and the Elder Brother (Luke 15) are driven by the same psychological engine: a transactional worldview colliding with unconditional grace. While their outward circumstances differ—one brings an agricultural offering, the other maintains decades of filial obedience—their internal cognitive distortions follow an almost identical trajectory.
a. The Transactional Mindset and Entitlement
At the root of both men’s distress is an implicit contract they believe they have struck with authority.
-
The Illusion of Control: Cain operates under the assumption that ritual performance guarantees divine favour; the Elder Brother believes that years of dutiful labour (“all these years I have been slaving for you,” Luke 15:29) entitle him to a proportional reward. Isn't he like most of us on this.
-
Grace as a Threat to Identity: When God regards Abel’s offering and the Father throws a feast for the prodigal, the transactional economy collapses. Psychologically, unmerited favour is experienced not merely as someone else's gain, but as an invalidation of their own identity. If favour is given freely, their lifelong currency of compliance loses its value.
b. Zero-Sum Thinking and Mimetic Desire
In René Girard’s framework of mimetic desire, rivalry emerges not because two people want different things, but because they measure their worth through the exact same object of validation.
-
Scarcity of Affection: Both Cain and the Elder Brother view paternal or divine love as a finite pie - that scarcity mentality that most of us are taught or just resort to as the way life is supposed to run. Abel’s acceptance feels like Cain’s rejection; the younger brother’s fatted calf feels like the Elder Brother’s deprivation (“you never gave me even a young goat!" The elder. brother of the Prodigal fumed).
-
The Blindness to Abundance: This zero-sum distortion blinds them to what they already possess. It blinds them from having "an abundance mentality" that God desires our lives to have. Cain retains his status as the firstborn with the opportunity to “do well” and be accepted (Genesis 4:7); the Elder Brother literally owns the rest of the estate ("all that is mine is yours," Luke 15:31), and none saw this abundance. Envy narrows their perceptual field until only the rival's blessing is visible and the "scarcity mentality" won the day.
c. Narcissistic Injury and Externalization of Blame
When their expectations of superiority are unmet, both characters suffer a narcissistic injury—a wound to their self-image as the "righteous" or "deserving" son. Instead of engaging in self-reflection, they defend their ego through externalization:
-
Relational Distancing: Notice how the Elder Brother refuses to claim kinship, referring to his sibling as "this son of yours" rather than "my brother." Similarly, Cain’s chilling rhetorical question—"Am I my brother’s keeper?"—is a psychological severance of fraternal responsibility. How many times have we found ourselves in this exact same positions in our lives?
-
Moral Inversion: By framing the authority figure as unjust (God as arbitrary; the Father as indulgent), both men elevate themselves to the position of moral judge. Anger becomes a protective shield against vulnerability, grief, or the humility required to admit they, too, need grace.
Conclusion
Friends in Christ, while Cain and Abel's story ends in the dark tragedy of violence, the Parable of the Prodigal Son offers a different ending, an open door to redemption—challenging you and I today, to identify with the elder brother and abandon our self-righteous bitterness in favour of communal joy. May we be encouraged by the redemptive ending that we see for the Prodigal Son. Otherwise for us, these two texts map out the dangerous pitfalls of human envy YET we should claim them for the radical, transformative power of unmerited grace that is ever present to us should we desire to access it. May you be blessed by this comparison of the two brothers that I got as I meditated on these two stories.
Rev. Monte
| | Guess Who I Met At the Crozier Fund Gala Dinner? | | Please meet Charlie Demers, our new Deacon Postulant Intern, who is joining us in January 2027. Be on the lookout for his bio, which will be in the next issue of The Communicator. | | Just this past week, they struck again on two separate occasions. Below is one such example: | | And as you can see, this is definitely not Rev. Monte, and it is not anything that would ever be requested of any parishioner at any time by any rector in the Anglican Church. When you receive such e-mails report them for phishing and then immediately delete them afterwards. | | |
Join me for the Advent study series after our Thursday Services on these 4 Thursdays in the Narthex:
16 November
3 December
10 December
17 December
Copies of the book are available at the Church Office for $20 each.
| | |
Congratulations To Our Newest ODNW Recipient
Congratulations to Len Reimer ODNW for his investiture in the Order of the Diocese of New Westminster which he received on Saturday the 7th of November at St. Andrews' Wesley Church in Downtown Vancouver. Len was among 46 other recipients of this ODNW for those who have served exceptionally in God's church in the Anglican Diocese of New Westminster. We now have our newest couple, both of whom have the ODNW designation.
| | |
2027 Canadian Church Calendars
are for sale by the ACW at a cost of $10/each.
| | |
White Gift Box
Sunday, November 29.
White gift box will be passed around after the offertory.
Monies collected will go towards supporting our
Christmas Hamper Outreach ministry.
If you wish to register for a hamper or know of someone in
need of a hamper please contact Beth: 604-594-8822
in the church office or email bfortin@stcuthbert.ca.
| | |
Ladies Breakfast hosted by St. Cuthbert ACW
Saturday, November 21 at 8:30 am.
Cost: $10.00 person includes breakfast & craft.
| | |
Men's Breakfast
Saturday, November 28 at 8:30 am
Please RSVP to Philip Kenny at philipaskenny@hotmail.com
| |
Hanging Outdoor Christmas Lights
Saturday, November 28
10:00 am to noon
Please come and help Susan Gage & Cathy Sendecki hang the Christmas lights on the wisteria arches and door frames.
Many hands make the work go faster!
| | |
St. Cuthbert Anglican Church Women
Christmas Potluck
Monday, December 7 at 6:00 pm
All Ladies Welcome!!
10775 Delsom Crescent
Bring a dish to share and a gift of $10.00 or a regift.
Cory McCaig: 604-594-9736
| |
Children's Ministries Focus
For more information, contact: obiea@stcuthbert.ca
| |
|
The Children’s Ministry at St. Cuthbert Anglican Church is seeking enthusiastic volunteers to help make this year’s Christmas Pageant, “Joy to the World,” and the children’s Christmas celebrations a memorable experience.
We welcome support with church set-up on Thursday, December 10 from 5pm, the final dress rehearsal and Christmas party hall set-up on Saturday, December 12 by 10am, and coordination on pageant day, Sunday, December 13 during the 10am service.
Whether you can assist with costumes, props, decorations, logistics, children’s supervision or hospitality, your time and support will be greatly appreciated.
If you are interested, please email obiea@stcuthbert.ca by Sunday, December 7. Thank you for helping our children share the joy of Christmas!
| |
Christmas Pageant 2026 – Get Involved!
Preparations for our 2026 Christmas Pageant, “Joy to the World,” are officially getting underway!
The pageant will take place during our 10:00 a.m. service on Sunday, December 13, 2026, and rehearsals will begin on Sunday, October 11 during the Sunday School, continuing through Saturday, December 12.
This year, we would also love to have parishioners and volunteers involved behind the scenes. If you are willing and able to help, we are particularly looking for support with:
- Costume/Wardrobe coordination assistance
- Pageant coordination
- Props and logistics
- General support throughout the preparation and rehearsals
If you are interested in volunteering, please reach out to the Children’s Ministry Team as soon as possible.
We look forward to preparing together for a joyful celebration of the birth of Christ!
| |
Sunday School and Nursery
At St. Cuthbert Anglican Church, we are passionate about nurturing children and youth in faith and creating a welcoming environment where families can grow spiritually together.
- Sunday School registration remains open! Families who have not yet registered are warmly encouraged to complete a registration form and join us. We would be delighted to welcome your children into our Sunday School community.
- A functioning nursery is available during services, providing parents with a safe, caring, and supportive space for younger children while families participate in worship.
Our desire is to continue building a strong, vibrant, and Christ-centred children’s ministry where every child feels welcomed, supported, encouraged, and connected to the life of the Church.
As we settle into the 26/27 Church School year, we are seeking a few additional Alternative Sunday School Teachers to step in occasionally when regular teachers are unavailable, helping to support our team and prevent burnout. No teaching experience is necessary - just a heart for children and a willingness to serve.
Thank you to all our parents, guardians, teachers, volunteers, and parish members for partnering with us in this ministry. We look forward to welcoming more families as we continue this year together.
Sunday School registration remains open, and we would be happy to have you join us! More information about Sunday School registration forms, volunteer opportunities, and the year ahead will be shared in church.
If you are interested in supporting our teachers and helping our children grow in faith, please contact the Director of Children's Formation. Thank you for helping us build a strong, supportive, and faith-filled Children's Ministry community!
Obie,
Director Children Formation
| | |
Light The Night
We're excited to announce that St. Cuthbert will be hosting the upcoming DYM (Diocese Youth Movement) event on Saturday, November 21st from 4:00-8:00pm.
Register by following this link
| |
Youth Led Service
Sunday, November 29 at 10:00 am
Every 5th Sunday, the youth volunteer to lead the service.
| |
Find our photos and news on our Instagram: @stcuthbertyouth
For more information reach out: Youthleader@stcuthbert.ca
— Rainoa Lonogan
| | |
Thursday Communion Service
November 19 at 10:00 am
Princess Elizabeth of Hungary
Readings: Tobit 12:6b-10; Psalm 146:4-9; Luke 12:32-34
Please plan to park in the 116th Street Parking Lot as the Roadworks have already started, creating expected inconvenience delays.
| | Property Development Focus | |
St Cuthbert Property Development Committee Update SCPDC – November 1,2026
The Property Development Committee has been working to fulfill its mandate covered under the Resolution from Vestry 2026 and provides the following update:
January 2026 – Purpose Driven applied for a $55,000 grant from VanCity to undertake the full Feasibility Study.
March 2026 – Vancity approved an Organizational Grant in the amount of $30,000. This meant that only the first part of the Feasibility Study could be completed with the funds available. The decision at the time was to complete the first part of the study and be able to show Vancity the progress with the hope of securing the remaining funding.
May 2026 – Part 1 of the Feasibilty Study completed with Purpose Driven.
July 2026 – Correspondence received from Purpose Driven confirming that funding for the second part of the Feasibility Study was a unavailable as the financial situation had changed.
October 2026 – Property Development Committee met to plan next steps regarding funding for the second half of the Feasibility Study and are looking at three potential funding options:
-
Option 1: (Recommended) Capital campaign or targeted fundraising from individuals/congregation. The funding method could be a grant, a donation, a loan, or a combination of these methods.
- Option 2: Table the project for 2 years pending market changes.
- Option 3: Sell one or two properties, (Rectory and/or Rental Property), demolish the office/hall, and build a modern hall, daycare, and kitchen (dropping the housing component).
The committee recognizes that our original mandate was to avoid burdening the church with debt as part of the Feasibility Study. However, given that further grant funding for 2026 is unavailable, alternate funding sources are required. Feasibility Study completion is critical before pursuing next project steps. Thus the committee is exploring alternate funding options and a Special Vestry meeting is required to vote on the following question:
"Do you support the motion to empower the St. Cuthbert Trustees to source up to $30,000 to complete the Purpose Driven Feasibility Study without restricting the funding method? The funding method could be a grant, a donation, a loan, or a combination of these methods."
The date of the Special Vestry meeting is to be determined, understanding that two weeks notice is required. In addition, a Town Hall Meeting has been scheduled for 7:00pm Monday November 23,2026 to provide the Property Development update for 2026 and address any questions.
On behalf of the Property Development Committee
Respectfully
Philip Espezel,
Chair
| Committees & Ministries Focus | |
October
Stewardship Pledge Drive
| | Planned Giving Initiative for 2027 | | |
Thanks to the early birds who returned their pledge forms, we are
49.75%
towards our 2027 Goal.
We will soon be winding down the receipt of the Pledge Forms for the 2027 Financial Giving Year. Your Pledge helps the parish plan what it can do and develop a reasonable budget. Things might change, hopefully for the better, so that you can adjust your pledge. If you still have your pledge lying somewhere in your house, please fill it in, bring it in and mark it to the attention of "The Envelope Secretary." If you did not receive a Pledge Letter, which contains the Pledge Form, there are extra letters in the Letter Cubicles in the Narthex. Alternatively, e-mail info@stcuthbert with your new address. Thank you for engaging with this Planned Giving Initiative for St. Cuthbert's for 2027.
| |
...........Bereavement & Resilience Group meets twice a month, on the second and fourth Tuesdays. This ministry is still downloading. We have not yet set the start date. We will let you know as soon as we have set the date. | |
|
Our Mission Statement
“To seek and encourage growth as a Christ–Centred community, empowered by the Holy Spirit, to know God and to make God known
in word and deed.”
| | Community ~ Connection ~ Communication ~ Continuity ~ Compassion | | | | |