The Great Divide
By Jan Markell
March 5, 2019
Someone appropriately said that when Lucifer fell from Heaven he landed in the church choir loft. There aren't a lot of choirs today, so today he might have landed in the midst of the church worship team somewhere between the drums and bass guitar.
Not all contemporary music is inappropriate and unsound. Not all of it is too noisy. Still, music in the church is the great divider and has created the worship wars.
I have just completed a two-week series on "Understanding the Times" radio and in almost 19 years, have never struck such a chord -- no pun intended.
My radio guests and I -- Pastor Brandon Holthaus and Eric Barger -- have dealt with calls and e-mail responses non-stop. Many people are heartsick about today's music in the church.
Some of the following issues were discussed:
- Today's music is, once again, the product of the church-growth movement. This is one way you grow a church: lights, smoke, sound, and "worship-tainment." Church growth is a part of seminary training just as much as theology!
- As a result, when the entertainment angle goes too far, church can seem like a performance at a local nightclub. Is this how a church prepares the people for the preaching from the Word of God?
- Some lyrics are out-of-control as well. Some songs sound more like a valentine love song. Some words are inappropriate. Some are embarrassing. Hear some examples: You are my desire/no one else will do/cause no one else could take your place/to feel the warmth of your embrace (Kelly Carpenter: Draw Me Close). Or, I wanna sit at your feet/lay back against you and breathe/feel your heartbeat/this love is so deep/it's more than I can stand (Kari Jobe: The More I Seek You.) Or, I want to look on the face of the one that I love/long to stay in your presence/it's where I belong/oh it's where I belong with you my love (Kim Walker: Jesus Culture). This is "theoeroticism" or romance to God and is inappropriate! Who sings, "In the secret, quiet hour, I want touch your face and know you more" in church?
- Some songs today represent outrageous theology as well. The popular song "Reckless Love" has 86 million listens on YouTube but is God's love "reckless"? God's actions were intentional and well planned when He sent His son to the cross. He knew us before the foundations of the world.
- How sound are some of the producers of today's music such as "Hillsong," "Jesus Culture", Bethel music, and music produced by the New Apostolic Reformation? The lyrics may promote troubling theology including the Prosperity Gospel and Kingdom Now/Dominion Theology. What good can come from an outfit that produces "Naked Cowbody," a Hillsong production in New York?
|Footage of Hillsong New York featuring "Naked Cowboy"
- Does some of today's music work people up, almost into an altered state of unconsciousness with repetitive words? Why must choruses be sung two-dozen times, inducing a trance-like look on the faces of many?
Is this Bethel music at "The Send" worshiping God or working up people into a near frenzy with repetitive words?
- Should your church be endorsing the originators, writers, and producers of some of today's music if their lifestyles are questionable? If they won't take a stand on important issues such as LGBTQ? If you accept the art, aren't you accepting all of the artist?
- How worshipful is the music when ear plugs are distributed as you enter the sanctuary? What if the volume is above 80 decibels? Do you know that is hazardous to your health?
- But it works! The church is vanishing in Australia -- except for Hillsong with 40,000 attendees! Maybe the ends justify the means!
- Do you know that every time you sing a song a church pays royalties to the producers of those songs? Should we be furthering the outreach of outfits that are not standing for sound doctrine and songwriters/producers who are not leading Godly lives?
We are to "come before His presence with singing" (Psalm 100:2) but with just any style of music?
Does anything go?
Is the music reflecting the majesty of God or just making us feel good?
s the music focusing on the truth of Scripture?
Could the great end-time falling away predicted in the Bible be hitting the music industry as well as some of our pulpits? Or are the critics of today's music being overly critical and legalistic?
Too often today, anything goes if it works.
Hundreds will unsubscribe from these e-mails and more may stop listening to "Understanding the Times" radio as a result of this discussion. We counted the cost. We just find it troubling that some seem to be worshiping worship.
Due to volume, we cannot reply to every e-mail.
Check our daily headlines here. Sign up for the RSS-feed and have them delivered to your in-box by 10:30 a.m. CST.
Support this ministry
May 11 in Toronto, Canada. Speakers include Amir Tsarfati, Jan Markell, Jack Hibbs and Barry Stagner. Consult Behold Israel for details. You must purchase a ticket.
UNDERSTANDING THE TIMES RADIO
Find complete syndication for "Understanding the Times" radio on
830 radio outlets here.
They include American Family Radio Network, CSN Network, HOPE-FM Network, Bott Radio Network, The Psalm FM Network, Sirius Satellite Network, The Word FM, the Life FM Network, The Calvary Radio Network, The Penfold Network, Salem Communications, OnePlace.com, and individual radio stations.
We are live Saturdays, 9 a.m. CST out of Minneapolis/St. Paul, MN. You can listen live here.
New programming is posted to our website on Saturday morning at Complete Archives.
Awaiting His return,
You may pass on these items or have people sign up on our website. You can access our radio programming from the last year at Complete Archives. Programming goes back to 2010 at One Place. Also see the website for other options to catch the program, "Understanding the Times."
Please report e-mail address changes.
Also, we truly appreciate those who remember us prayerfully and financially. Donate on our website (gifts are tax-deductible with receipts sent out in January).
Olive Tree Ministries, Inc.
Maple Grove, MN 55311-6452
763-559-4444 or 763-210-8291