|
On March 20, 2024, Governor Murphy signed into law, P.L. 2024, c.2, which amended the 1985 New Jersey Fair Housing Act (“the Amended FHA”). In accordance with the Amended FHA, the Borough filed a timely Fourth Round Declaratory Judgment complaint with the Affordable Housing Dispute Resolution Program (“the Program”) on January 22, 2025, seeking a Compliance Certification and/or Judgment of Compliance and Repose approving its Housing Element and Fair Share Plan. On May 19, the Honorable Gregg A. Padovano, J.S.C., issued an Order setting the Borough’s Fourth Round Obligations to include a “Present Need” obligation of 65 and a “Prospective Need” obligation of 480.
On June 19, the Borough Planning Board adopted a Housing Element and Fair Share Plan (the “Borough HEFSP”). The Mayor and Council endorsed the Borough HEFSP by resolution. The Borough submitted the Borough HEFSP to the Program on June 20.
Trelia Franklin Lakes 1, L.L.C. (“Trelia”), the contract purchaser of 370-378 Pulis Avenue in Franklin Lakes, filed an objection to the Borough HEFSP on August 29. An additional objection was filed by the Fair Share Housing Center. The Fourth Round statutorily-prescribed process is now in the mediation stage, with the Program tasked to mediate a resolution of the issues between the Borough and its two objectors by a December 31 deadline.
The Borough seeks to resolve Trelia’s objection to the Borough HEFSP in the context of a global settlement of the Borough’s Fourth Round obligation. By resolution adopted on November 6, the Mayor and Council authorized its affordable housing counsel to negotiate with Trelia in an effort to settle its objection as part of a global settlement.
Trelia has proposed a development on its 7.4 acre site of 46 units as shown on a concept plan prepared by Trelia, consisting of 4 single family homes located on the Pulis Avenue frontage and 42 townhouse units. If a settlement is reached by the Borough with Trelia, there would be an ordinance adopted in 2026 and eventually the project would be subject to site plan approval by the Borough Planning Board, and issues including, but not limited to, drainage, traffic and access, would be addressed in the Planning Board approval process.
The Borough, like most municipalities, decided to seek approval of its Fourth Round affordable housing plan by the Program in accordance with the Amended FHA. Had the Borough decided not to follow this statutorily-prescribed process, it would have been exposed to the potential for “builders’ remedy” lawsuits, which are lawsuits brought by property owners or developers seeking to have the Borough meet all or a portion of the Borough’s obligation on property owned by the property owner or developer. Builders’ remedy lawsuits can result in high density development on sites chosen by individual property owners. By following the statutory process, the Borough is retaining its authority to meet its obligation through an appropriate planning process. Should the Borough be able to secure approval from the Program, it will have repose from builder’s remedy lawsuits. Should the mediation process before the Program fail, the Borough could face arguments regarding loss of immunity.
The Borough will keep the public informed as the status of this ongoing process with regular e-blast updates.
|