HAVE A PROJECT SOMEWHERE IN TEXAS?

WE'VE PROBABLY BEEN THERE.



THE LOCATION STRATEGY TOP 10




IF YOU'RE NEW TO OUR TOP 10, WELCOME. WE SEND OUT THE TOP 10 DATA CHARTS WE SEE EACH WEEK WE THINK OUR CLIENTS SHOULD KNOW ABOUT. WE HOPE YOU WILL ENJOY IT, AND WE NEVER GIVE/SELL OUR LIST TO ANYONE.


DON'T MISS OUT! WE ARE UPDATING OUR CONTACT LISTS. IF SOMEONE HAS FORWARDED THIS TO YOU, SEND US AN EMAIL AND WE'LL GET YOU SIGNED UP TO RECEIVE IT DIRECTLY.


MORGAN STANLEY SAYS NO RECESSION

While many economists are still forecasting a recession this year, brought on primarily by fed funds rate increases, morgan stanley now forecasts only one quarter of downturn. That's short of the official defintion of a recession, at least under presidents not named Joe Biden.


US-Morgan-Stanley-now-sees-a-down-quarter-in-Q2-and-slower-2024-growth-but-no-recession2303060442 image

BLS FIRES UP THE MAGIC SPREADSHEET


Yesterday's job report beat expectations again. The charts below show how response rates have fallen for the payroll and job openings surveys. They used to cover about 1/3 of jobs but now only cover about 10%.


The payroll chart below also shows how the BLS has increased the adjustments it makes as response rates fall -- so as the data declines in quality the BLS is accelerating its upward adjustments. Maybe these numbers are still accurate, and maybe they aren't. But any numbers coming out of the government should be taken with a giant gain of salt.

HOUSTON = FEWEST JOB LOSSES


The Federal Government requires employers engaging in mass layoffs to give workers notice under the Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification (WARN) Act. These announcements can be found at the Texas Workforce Commission website. We've compiled the 2023 notices below by MSA.


Dallas by far has the most with almost 3,000 mass layoffs announced. Austin was next with about 1,600. Houston comes in the very bottom with about 350. But even in the markets with high numbers, they are mostly attributed to one or two companies like Interceramic (Dallas) or META and U-Haul (Austin). Even Houston has one relatively large loss in Boston Scientific. These are one-off events and not really indicative of the broader market, at least not yet.


IMMIGRATION'S IMPACT


When we think of waves of immigration affecting US population, we probably think of Ellis Island and the Statue of Liberty. But changes to the immigration laws in 1965 are still shaping our population today. Today's population is around 340 million and should approach 400 million by 2100. In fact, the US is projected to be one of the worlds top 10 fastest growing countries this century. Without those immigrants, current population would be about 300 million and fall to around 225 million in 2100. The US would be Japan or Italy.


Without taking an overt political position, as someone in an industry that depends on new real estate development, I'd rather do it in one of the world's fastest growing countries than one that is going to need one-third fewer homes by the end of the century. Just saying.


VTI-Population-projections-with-and-without-immigration2303060442 image

HOME PRICES MAY STILL INCREASE THIS YEAR

Prices declined slightly in January, but CoreLogic is projecting that home prices will be rising again by January 2024. If I had one message for the Fed it would be this: you can adjust rates all you want, but demographics is destiny and they are moving powerfully in favor of housing this year and in 2024.

US-HPA-Small-decline-in-Jan2303070439 image
US-CoreLogic-HPA-4pc-above-Jan2303070439 image

RATES DRIVE AFFORDABILITY TO A 25-YR LOW

Housing affordability is at a record low - housing hasn't been this unaffordable in more than 25 years. An analysis by Wells Fargo (2nd chart) gives the reason: mortgage rates are almost exclusively responsible for current record levels.

US-Housing-affordability2303070439 image
US-Drivers-of-housing-affordability2303070439 image

THE FED STOPPED BUYING MORTGAGES TOO

It's now been more than a decade since we had any idea what real estate prices actually would be without enormous amounts of stimulus from the Fed. The money-printing-for-mortgages scheme entered its first phase between 2009 and 2010 and then was almost non-stop from 2013 to 2022, topping out at around $1.7 trillion in 2018. The Fed had begun to pull back on its MBS assets in 2018 and 2019, but of course, reversed course in 2020 and engaged in a frenzy of new MBS buying.  In that period the Fed purchased an additional $1.4 trillion in MBS. That finally ended (for now) in the fall of 2022. The Fed still holds over $2.6 trillion in MBS assets.

If we look at year-over-year changes in these MBS purchases alongside Case-Shiller home prices, we again see a clear correlation. It's clear that once markets think the Fed may again increase its MBS purchases, home prices again surge. Since 2020, the Fed’s MBS stockpile has equaled at least 20 percent of all the household mortgage debt in the United States. In early 2022, Fed-held MBS assets peaked at 24 percent of all US mortgage debt, but they still made up over 20 percent of the market as of late 2022.

2023-03-08_08-27-19 image

PRICES DROPPING BUT ON LOW VOLUME

The number of new listings has dropped 25% YOY - almost as much as listings dropped in March of 2020. I think this is likely to provide some kind of buffer because although we may see moves up and down, they are likely to be on low volume as so little product is actually available.


US-new-listings2303070439 image

HALF OF MORTGAGES ARE VINTAGE 2020 OR LATER

Half of mortgages were issued in 2020 or later; the next largest category is before 2012. It's going to be hard to get this ~60% of homeowners out of their houses until we at least see rates under 6%. I don't see how that happens much before 2024. Until then we'll have to figure out how to get newly formed households into our product.

US-The-distribution-of-outstanding-mortgage-loans-by-vintage-and-rate2303070439 image

Below is the cumulative distribution function for mortgages by current interest rate. Basically what this chart tells you is that 98% of mortgages are below current rates -- a key factor in why so many houses are staying off the market.


US-Mortg-by-rate2303070439 image

JOBS!


Houston


Dallas


Scott Davis

LOCATION STRATEGY, LLC

1302 Waugh Drive #178

Houston, Texas 77019

832.304.DIRT (3478)

www.locationstrategyllc.com