Conflicts of Interest
What Are They?
“A Conflict of Interest (COI) is a situation in which an individual or organization has competing primary and secondary interests. A COI may strongly predispose an individual or organization to exploit a professional or an official capacity in some way for personal or organizational benefit. An improper COI occurs when an individual’s or organization’s interests unduly influence judgments concerning professional responsibility.”1
For example, a person might have a loyalty to an employer and also loyalty to a family business. The conflict itself is not necessarily harmful – because it can be managed. But without transparency and management, a conflict may result in bias-influenced behavior or decisions that impact the university, faculty, employees, students, conduct of research, university business partners, etc., which would be inappropriate and likely harmful.
Potential Harms of Conflict of Interest When Not Disclosed and Managed:
- Diminished trust, sense of fairness and justice among co-workers
- Damage to the reputation / integrity of the university
- Waste or abuse of university resources
- Corrosion of university culture
- Violation of federal and/or state law
What does USA have in place to support prevent conflicts of interest?
- Policies and procedures
- Annual COI disclosure and review process for specified employees
- Guidance for managing conflicts of interest
- External Professional Activity (EPA) request process
- Informational COI web page
Policy Spotlight
Conflict of Interest and Conflict of Commitment policy: This is USA’s umbrella policy, under which more specific conflict of interest (COI) and conflict of commitment (COC) policies fall, including the External Professional Activities (EPA) policy, featured below. The COI/COC policy provides general information about USA’s COI/COC program, particularly the annual COI Disclosure process.
External Professional Activities (EPA) policy: This policy defines conflicts of commitment (COC) and external professional activities (EPA), and establishes guidelines for when and how an EPA request form should be submitted for review and approval by a faculty member’s Department Chair and Dean.
Conflict of Interest Issues - In the News!
1LD Claxton, per Bekelman, et al., 2003; Boyd and Bero, 2006; Stark, 2000;Thompson, 1993.