The Unveiling... Our little known History.



The Bloodstained Eiffel Tower

 

The Trump administration has announced that on August 3, 2025, it will revoke the humanitarian Temporary Protected Status of about 500,000 Haitians, leaving them without work permits and at risk of deportation to an unstable and dangerous land. 


Why, we wonder? Not why is the administration doing such a cruel, heartless thing. We know why. But we wonder why Haiti is so unsafe and desolate when, as British diplomat Spenser St. John wrote in 1884: “No country possesses greater capabilities, or a better geographical position, or more variety of soil, of climate, or of production.”


And yet, violence, and despair born of poverty have engulfed the country for centuries. Why are they so poor? 


And what does it have to do with the Eiffel Tower? 


Well, a lot, actually. Let’s go back a few centuries. France colonized the island in the late 1600s, and by 1760, it had become the most profitable colony in the Americas, due to the production of plantation crops for export, coffee and sugar. It’s important to note that this colony, then called Saint-Domingue, was also among the harshest slave systems, with the average lifespan of enslaved persons being 21 years old. 


This brutal system naturally engendered rage within the slave population, who had little to lose. In 1791, a group of former slaves led a revolt, the most successful slave rebellion in history, and Haiti became independent in 1804. 


But not entirely. Even after being driven out, France sent warships that gathered off the coast of Haiti, threatening continued violence and domination unless Haiti paid them for their losses – of land, materials, and the human bodies they had purchased to do all the work that made them wealthy. Haiti was thus held for ransom. 


According to The New York Times, “Haiti became the first and only nation to have to pay reparations to its former masters and their descendants for generations.”


So, while the freed country should have thrived, given their abundant resources and trade experience, due to France’s extortion, they sunk deeper and deeper into poverty and debt until “…by the early 20th century, half of the taxes on Haiti’s coffee crop, by far its most important source of revenue, went to French run credit companies and banks. After Haiti’s other debts were deducted, its government was left with pennies — 6 cents of every $3 collected — to run the country.” (NYT)


And this imposed poverty has resulted in government corruption, conflict, and violence for centuries.


France, on the other hand, flourished–in part from pirated funds from the country they had so ruthlessly exploited. A hefty amount of the booty went to build their iconic Eiffel Tower, symbol of ingenuity, technological superiority, and of all things, liberty.


So as we admire this paean to Western culture, let us remember what made it possible: as is often the case, brutal colonization that resulted in generations of fabulous wealth for the colonizer and destitution for the conquered. 


***

France’s president, Emmanuel Macron, recently acknowledged the injustice of requiring Haiti to pay for its freedom. He has gone so far as to establish a joint Franco-Haitian commission to study the history and “assess relations.” Though he freely admits wrongdoing, he doesn’t discuss how to make it right. The answer is right before his eyes in his own country’s violent and greedy deeds: reparations. 


No mention of that, though. And no surprise there. Though there have been isolated instances of redress such as debt forgiveness or land restitution, and a few lawsuits have won group settlements, colonial powers have not made full-scale repayment to the countries or people they subjugated. Colonizers mostly take and take and when forced to stop taking, they abandon and demonize, as we did with the enslaved in this country. 


Is it any surprise we’re doing the same thing with Haitian immigrants fleeing the horrific legacy of colonial rule?



*This is a very complex story that has been shortened and simplified here. Much of the information comes from The New York Times who published an excellent series of in-depth investigative reports on these events. We encourage further reading for deeper understanding:



New York Times article - The Ransom: The Root of Haiti’s Misery:Reparations to Enslavers



New York Times article - The Ransom: How a French Bank Captured Haiti






Listen. Learn. Act.