|
When a renovation of the building was announced in 2021, preservationists sought official landmark status for 60 Wall Street, hoping to protect the colonnade that adored its street-level facade, as well as the mirrored, 100 foot-tall atrium that connects Wall and Pine Streets, which was for decades open to the public. In the end, however, the City’s Landmarks Preservation Commission declined to designate the building a legally protected landmark.
Using as metrics the average size of a Manhattan apartment (approximately 750 square feet) and the architectural guideline that about 85 percent of an apartment building’s interior can be used as residential space (with the rest going to common areas like hallways, elevator shafts, stairwells, and utility cores, as well as laundry and trash rooms), 60 Wall Street could yield approximately 1,920 new dwellings. That would make the project the largest-ever conversion of an office building to residential use in New York, and in the nation as a whole. It would surpass the current record holder – the nearby, recently converted office building at 25 Water – by 600 units, or roughly 45 percent. For context, this one tower may contain more homes than several multi-building residential complexes in Lower Manhattan, including Gateway Plaza (Battery Park City), Independence Plaza (Tribeca), and Southbridge Towers (the Seaport District). Based on 2020 census data, which indicate that the typical size of a Lower Manhattan household is now 2.02 persons, 60 Wall Street may bring approximately 3,878 new residents to the community.
The flood of such conversions is transforming Lower Manhattan. A May report from the Downtown Alliance noted that while Lower Manhattan currently has 37,283 units in 351 residential buildings, there are another 8,987 apartments in 32 buildings now under construction or planned for development. Of these, slightly more than 7,500 units are office-to-residential conversions.
The Alliance report highlighted two recently announced conversions: 61 Broadway (with 796 apartments) and 80 Broad Street (with 326 homes). These are slated to be followed by 111 Wall Street (1,500), 222 Broadway (798), 80 Pine Street (713), 101 Greenwich Street (614), 77 Water Street (600), 30 Broad Street (521), 100 William Street (430), 40 Exchange Place (382), 75 Maiden Lane (300), 100 Wall Street (169), Two Wall Street (169), 40 Fulton Street (169), 64 Fulton Street (49), One Maiden Lane (12), 14 Maiden Lane (nine), and Five Hanover Square (unknown number of units).
Many of these office conversions are likely to take place under the terms of the City’s 467-m program (also known as the Affordable Housing from Commercial Conversions Tax Incentive Benefits), which mandates that 25 percent of the apartments created must be set aside as affordable units, in exchange for tax abatements on the entire property for 25 to 35 years.
But some critics argue that the scheme is overly generous to developers and doesn’t deliver enough benefits to the public. In a 2025 analysis, then-City Comptroller Brad Lander noted, “post-pandemic conversion activity already appears on track to exceed the totals subsidized... in the Financial District in the 1990’s and 2000’s,” but that the 467-m program is “likely too generous in Lower Manhattan.”
Mr. Lander’s report added that the “opportunity cost” (meaning property taxes that will never be collected as a result of 467-m) “is $3.8 billion in Lower Manhattan. The opportunity cost outside of Lower Manhattan is $1.4 billion.” This appears to mean that out of a projected total of $5.1 billion in waived revenue, some 75 percent of these benefits will go to developers in Lower Manhattan. The analysis further indicated that “the opportunity cost per income-restricted unit in Lower Manhattan is $1.8 million,” while, “outside of Lower Manhattan, the opportunity cost per unit is $0.9 million.” In this context, the City appears to be “paying” (in the form of taxes forgiven) twice as much in Lower Manhattan for each affordable unit created under 467-m, compared to the same costs elsewhere.
Matthew Fenton
|