Weekly Newsletter

Friday, Sept. 19, 2025

Thank you for subscribing to Suncoast Searchlight's newsletter.

We’re here to keep you informed on the local issues that matter most. Each week, we share our latest in-depth reporting, along with the most important stories from around the region, so you stay connected and up to date with what’s happening in your community.


Enjoying this newsletter thanks to a friend? Subscribe here to get it in your inbox. 📬

NEW FROM SUNCOAST SEARCHLIGHT:

SHE PAID HIS BOND. ICE TOOK HIM. BRADENTON FAMILY'S SAGA SHOWS HOW FLORIDA JAILS FUEL DEPORTATIONS


In the early morning hours on July 12, Oscar Romero Santos drove his red Ram truck toward the Bradenton home he shared with his wife. When he turned onto his block, a Manatee County Sheriff’s deputy followed. 


As Romero Santos pulled into the driveway, the deputy flashed his emergency lights.

Romero Santos parked, got out of the truck and walked quickly towards the house, the 45-year-old later recounted in Spanish to Suncoast Searchlight. 


“That’s when [the deputy] came running from the other side of the car and put handcuffs on me,” he said. 


Inside, his wife Sheysa Romero Santos slept, unaware of what was transpiring on her doorstep — or that it would be the last time she’d be that close to her husband for the foreseeable future.


Only when Romero Santos called from the jail did his wife learn what had happened. She hustled to the courthouse and paid $650 to cover his bonds on misdemeanor charges of driving without a license and obstruction of justice without violence, believing it would bring him home. 


Instead, Immigration and Customs Enforcement detained him and deported him to Honduras within weeks. He's not alone.


The jail-to-deportation pipeline is one of the main engines of Trump’s mass-deportation push in Florida. Routine arrests, even for minor charges, are a direct gateway into ICE custody — the most frequent method of immigration arrests in the state, according to a Suncoast Searchlight analysis of local and national data.

HOW WE ANALYZED THE DATA ON ICE DETAINERS, ARRESTS AND DEPORTATIONS IN FLORIDA


To examine how local jails are fueling an immigration crackdown in Florida, we analyzed hundreds of thousands of federal immigration arrest, detainer and deportation records.


Click here to read our methodology

Interested in volunteering for Suncoast Searchlight?


Want to stand up for local journalism? We’re looking for volunteers to help with community events and other projects that keep our First Amendment strong — your time and energy make a real difference in defending democracy close to home.


Sign up to be a volunteer here.


Suncoast Searchlight partners with Gigafact to produce weekly fact briefs — concise, 150-word news stories that take real claims circulating online and fact check them. Each brief offers a direct “yes” or “no” answer to the question or claim, followed by a clear explanation backed up by credible, high-quality sources.


THIS WEEK'S FACT BRIEFS:



HERE'S WHAT ELSE WE RECOMMEND READING THIS WEEK


HOW WEALTHY DO YOU HAVE TO BE TO LIVE IN SARASOTA?

FROM SARASOTA MAGAZINE

Sarasota, once a sleepy Gulf Coast town, is now thick with transplants — many of them powerhouse CEOs and entrepreneurs — who have graduated well past the threshold of high-net-worth into the ultra-high-net-worth stratum: $30 million and up. For many, that’s just the starting point. According to IRS data analyzed by the Tax Foundation, Sarasota County gained more than $2.6 billion in net adjusted gross income from migrating households between 2021 and 2022, ranking it third among all Florida counties in total wealth inflow. But the paradox of Sarasota’s wealth is that, for all its abundance, many households and systems are under strain. Nearly 42% of Sarasota County households fall into the ALICE category, which stands for “Asset Limited, Income Constrained, Employed.” About 50% of local public school students qualify for free or reduced lunch. Hundreds of children are on waiting lists for subsidized care for important services such as preschool.

READ THE STORY HERE



LOBBYISTS FOR A BILLIONAIRE AND A CHARTER NETWORK PUSHED FLORIDA LAWMAKERS TO EXPAND A SCHOOL PRIVATIZATION PROGRAM

FROM SEEKING RENTS

Records obtained by Seeking Rents show that billionaire hedge-fund manager Ken Griffin and New York City’s Success Academy charter network lobbied heavily for a new Florida law that massively expands the state’s “Schools of Hope” program, which gives charter operators grants and loans to open new schools. The measure — signed by Gov. Ron DeSantis — was drafted with input from Success Academy and advanced by Republican leaders, some of whom received millions in campaign contributions from Griffin. The law redefines “persistently low-performing” schools so broadly that the state’s list grew from 51 to 267 schools, including some rated A and B, allowing charters to open in far more places — even in affluent communities or inside existing public schools rent-free.

READ THE STORY HERE



THESE DOLPHINS LEARNED TO HUNT ALONGSIDE A FLORIDA ANGLER. RESEARCHERS STUDYING WHY

FROM TAMPA BAY TIMES

Over the years, Justin Dymond has built a special bond with a group of wild dolphins in Crystal River. Every night, as he flicks on his boat lights to go bow-and-arrow fishing, dozens of dolphins arrive and hunt alongside him. Dymond’s boat lights stun fish, making them easier for dolphins to capture. In turn, the dolphins push fish toward the shallows, helping Dymond and his clients catch them. Tampa Bay Times joined a recent boating trip as researchers work to learn more about this rare group of dolphins.

READ THE STORY HERE



YEARS OF FIGHTING SARASOTA RECYCLING PLANT OVER DUST, NOISE HAS RESIDENTS FEELING HOPELESS

FROM SARASOTA HERALD-TRIBUNE

Sarasota’s Central Cocoanut neighborhood is renewing its fight against U.S. Recycling, a scrap yard residents say has long disrupted their lives with dust, noise, and heavy truck traffic. After years of frustration, neighbors are pressing city officials to take stronger action, with the Coalition of City Neighborhood Associations recently naming the issue a strategic priority and launching a new initiative to hold the company accountable.

READ THE STORY HERE



TENSIONS RISE IN BRADENTON'S HORSE POOP DEBATE AS COMPANIES AGREE TO PAUSE RIDES

FROM BRADENTON HERALD

Horseback riding companies have agreed to pause operations along Palma Sola Bay for a month after new DNA testing showed traces of horse bacteria in the water, though at levels too low to quantify. The move, suggested by the Sarasota Bay Estuary Program, is meant to test whether horses are contributing to water pollution, but Suncoast Waterkeeper criticized the plan as scientifically flawed, arguing it won’t provide clear results during the rainy season. Business owners say the shutdown is a financial burden but hope it ends what they described as a years-long conflict with Suncoast Waterkeeper over whether horses are polluting the bay.

READ THE STORY HERE



BRADENTON SPILLS 1.7 MILLION GALLONS OF SEWAGE INTO MANATEE RIVER, REPORT SAYS

FROM BRADENTON HERALD

Bradenton’s wastewater plant spilled an estimated 1.7 million gallons of sewage into the Manatee River during a Sept. 8 overflow, the city’s largest spill this year, caused by heavy rain and equipment failure. Operators opened a bypass for more than five hours, releasing partially treated wastewater. The incident highlights ongoing pollution from the aging facility, which regularly exceeds state nutrient limits even as Bradenton is investing over $100 million in upgrades, including new clarifiers, pipe lining, lift station improvements and a deep injection well. The city remains under a 2032 deadline to stop discharges into the Manatee River, and, under the terms of a legal settlement reached with advocacy group Suncoast Waterkeeper, it must pay additional fines to support water quality improvement projects.

READ THE STORY HERE



LOCAL OFFICIALS IN FLORIDA WORRY THEY COULD FACE SUSPENSION IF THEY OPPOSE DESANTIS

FROM WUSF

Local officials in Manatee and Hillsborough counties say they’re afraid they could be suspended by Gov. DeSantis if they vote in ways that his administration opposes. The law allows the governor to suspend local officials for things like “malfeasance, misfeasance, neglect of duty, drunkenness, incompetence, permanent inability to perform duties, or commission of a felony.” While historically mostly used in criminal or misconduct cases, some elected leaders and experts believe the threat of suspension is being used to stifle actions by local governments — for example over development rules, libraries’ book choices, or decisions seen as unsupportive of state policy.

READ THE STORY HERE



FORMER FLORIDA SURGEON GENERAL SPEAKS OUT AGAINST PLAN TO LIFT VACCINE MANDATES

FROM WUSF

Florida’s former Surgeon General, Dr. Scott Rivkees, is strongly criticizing a proposal by current Surgeon General Joseph Ladapo to end vaccine mandates for schoolchildren, arguing it risks a return of dangerous, preventable diseases. WUSF Rivkees, now with Brown University’s School of Public Health, warns lifting mandates undermines both child and public health, pointing to historical data on measles, chickenpox, and other illnesses; he also says the medical community (in Florida and beyond) and elected officials have “strongly criticized” Ladapo’s plans.

READ THE STORY HERE



EARLY SCHOOL BOARD MEETINGS PASS, SPAWN RESIDENT CONCERNS

FROM VENICE GONDOLIER

The Sarasota County School Board voted to move some meetings from evenings to 10 a.m., sparking backlash from residents and students who say the change reduces public access and silences community voices. Board members Karen Rose, Robyn Marinelli and Bridget Ziegler argued morning meetings prioritize board business and safety, while critics — including retirees, parents, and students — countered that the shift excludes working people and youth most affected by board decisions. Although a few residents supported the change, citing security concerns and personal responsibility to attend, others questioned the board’s motives, with member Tom Edwards joining opponents in warning that trust and participation would erode under the new schedule.

READ THE STORY HERE




CITY REJECTS APPEAL TO BOTANICAL GARDENS GRAND TREE REMOVAL

FROM WSLR

Selby Botanical Gardens wants to break ground on a $61 million makeover that includes construction of a new conservatory it calls the “crown jewel” of its campus on the Bay. But that new conservatory will require the removal of 102 trees, including seven grand trees, which enjoy special protection under the City of Sarasota’s tree ordinance. On Monday, the Sarasota City Commission rejected a resident’s appeal, arguing she did not have legal standing. Still, Kelly Franklin’s appeal put Sarasota’s high-profile botanical garden in an awkward position, forcing it to make legal arguments why it should be allowed to cut down trees. Ultimately, though, Selby’s lawyer argued that Franklin lacked legal standing because the value of her home, half a mile from Selby, is not affected, and because she is not more affected than anyone else.

READ/HEAR THE STORY HERE



VOLUNTEERS PAINT PRIDE CROSSWALK AT HARVEST SARASOTA CHURCH

FROM SARASOTA OBSERVER

After the Sarasota City Commission voted to comply with state order removing crosswalk art, workers destroyed some 300 sidewalk murals of the Avenue of Art in Burns Court and the rainbow crosswalk in downtown Sarasota. But at The Harvest Sarasota church, new color was introduced on Sept. 14. Volunteers, including representatives and staff of local LGBTQ+ organizations like Project Pride and Equality Florida, worked together to create a new Progress Pride Flag crosswalk on the organization's property.

READ THE STORY HERE



DID YOU MISS OUR PREVIOUS NEWSLETTER?

HERE'S WHAT WE SHARED:

Suncoast Searchlight hires first development director, marking next chapter in its growth


Suncoast Searchlight has taken a major step forward with the hiring of its first development director.


Samantha Ramlall joined the organization on Monday, bringing experience in fundraising, community engagement and nonprofit advancement to a newsroom now entering its next phase: building long-term financial support for independent, accountability reporting in the region.


“This is a milestone moment for us,” said Emily Le Coz, executive editor-in-chief of Suncoast Searchlight, which is the newsroom name of the Community News Collaborative, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization. “Since we started publishing in February, we have demonstrated the demand for substantive journalism in the community. Samantha’s arrival ensures we can sustain and grow that work by inviting the community to invest directly in it.”


Ramlall comes to Suncoast Searchlight from the statewide nonprofit Children’s Home Society of Florida, where she worked for eight years and most recently served as associate vice president of major gifts.


As the newsroom’s development director, Ramlall will lead fundraising efforts, cultivate donor relationships and organize events that connect its mission with the people it serves. She will also oversee membership programs and philanthropic partnerships that are critical to sustaining nonprofit newsrooms in today’s challenging media environment.

Streets of Paradise co-founder's firing sparks turmoil at Sarasota homeless nonprofit


In 2016, Greg Cruz, a former gang member, felon and single father of four, began making a dozen sandwiches at a time on his kitchen counter and taking them to Sarasota’s City Hall to hand out to homeless individuals.


That simple act became part of the origin story of Streets of Paradise, a local nonprofit that has provided meals, home furnishings and resiliency services to Sarasota’s unhoused community for nearly a decade, operating almost entirely with the devoted support of volunteers dedicated to its “Love-Act-Repeat” philosophy.


Though Cruz did not found the organization alone, his personal history and visibility made him inseparable from the group’s identity.


That’s why his abrupt firing last week stunned supporters and unleashed a wave of anger online.


Streets of Paradise’s board of directors abruptly dismissed Cruz “without cause” at a brief board meeting, leaving his longtime partner and co-CEO Cathy Bryant as sole leader. It offered him two weeks' severance pay while dictating confidentiality, non-compete and donor solicitation restrictions for the next 12 months.


When Cruz disclosed the firing on Facebook, the backlash was immediate. Volunteers, donors and community members filled social media with comments of outrage and disbelief, calling for transparency the board says it cannot provide.


In the days since, Suncoast Searchlight spoke with all of the major figures at the center of the turmoil. What emerged was a portrait of an organization in conflict.



Privatization push emerges at New College as ex-insider breaks with DeSantis allies


A former senior member of New College of Florida President Richard Corcoran’s administration is leading a push to privatize the institution — a dramatic turn for a conservative insider once tapped to help carry out Gov. Ron DeSantis’ ideological overhaul of the Sarasota-based school. 


Nathan Allen, a New College alumnus who served as Corcoran’s vice president of strategy and special projects in 2023 and 2024, said his experience inside the project left him disillusioned and convinced that the college’s future is not secure under the current administration or state control.


Allen has laid out a multimillion-dollar proposal to wean New College off taxpayer dollars over the next decade, arguing that the surge of state funding that fueled the school’s conservative makeover has been misdirected and cannot be relied on to last. His plan, if realized, would require a tuition hike and bring about the college’s second radical transformation in as many years.


“This college has one fickle benefactor, and that’s Tallahassee,” Allen told Suncoast Searchlight during an interview. “The minute that that benefactor decides that it doesn’t want to spend this kind of money on the college, what does the college do?”


Allen has so far campaigned quietly, speaking one-on-one with alumni, faculty and community members, but his pitch has already gained traction with prominent figures.


Sarasota County seeks stormwater rate increase. But audit finds millions available



Sarasota County administrators are stiff-arming recommendations from a stormwater consultant and plan to push another rate hike on residents despite a new audit showing the utility could have more than $70 million over the next five years without raising rates.


Just two years after a substantial increase in stormwater environmental utility rates, Sarasota County staff is once again asking taxpayers to open their wallets to bolster water quality and flood protections ahead of future storms. The proposed tax increase comes as county leaders scramble to fill gaps in the stormwater system that last year left thousands of homes flooded in unsuspecting neighborhoods miles from the coast.


A joint investigation by the Florida Trident and Suncoast Searchlight into the failures found the county ignored sediment buildup in Phillippi Creek, left key stormwater positions sitting vacant while work orders piled up and overlooked glaring system vulnerabilities noted by consultants years earlier. All contributed to a stormwater utility operating in disarray.


In response, the county hired new Stormwater Director Ben Quartermaine, who has proposed raising annual rates by more than one-fourth on average to fund the department’s turnaround.


But the recommendation contradicts a newly released audit by Steve Suau — a retired department head who was hired July 18 as a consultant to review stormwater ordinances and projects. Operating on a $30 million annual budget, his audit notes, the department already has a glut of stormwater money available and suggests not throwing more taxes at the problem.

GOT A TIP OR STORY IDEA?


Share your tips and story ideas using our online form. Your name and contact info will be kept confidential.

Suncoast Searchlight is a 501c3 nonprofit news organization whose mission is to produce investigative and explanatory journalism that serves and empowers the residents of Florida’s Suncoast region (Sarasota, Manatee, and DeSoto counties). We shine a light on critical issues affecting our community. Through independent reporting and collaboration with diverse media partners, we foster transparency, accountability and an informed citizenry, ensuring that all voices are heard and that the public has access to the information they need to drive meaningful change.


CONTACT US:

Suncoast Searchlight

PO Box 99 Sarasota, FL 34230

(941) 724-4450