Weekly Newsletter

Friday, June 27, 2025

Thank you for subscribing to Suncoast Searchlight's newsletter.

We’re here to keep you informed on the local issues that matter most. Each week, we share our latest in-depth reporting, along with the most important stories from around the region, so you stay connected and up to date with what’s happening in your community.


Enjoying this newsletter thanks to a friend? Subscribe here to get it in your inbox every week.

NEW FROM SUNCOAST SEARCHLIGHT:

Sarasota County officials downplayed flood risk. Tropical Storm Debby exposed their failures



A five-month investigation by Suncoast Searchlight and Florida Trident found that Sarasota County’s stormwater system was in disarray well before Tropical Storm Debby flooded homes, damaged infrastructure and claimed a life last year.


Despite public assurances that the county was well-protected against flooding, internal records and interviews show officials ignored maintenance warnings, failed to follow emergency protocols and left key positions unfilled.


Among the most serious failures: a berm near Laurel Meadows that hadn’t been inspected in decades gave way during the storm, sending water rushing into homes. Stormwater gates meant to manage flooding at Celery Fields and Cow Pen Slough were not operated according to county protocols. And despite knowing for years that sediment buildup was choking Phillippi Creek, the county failed to act — even as residents and other agencies repeatedly raised concerns.


A 2022 consultant report warned the county it lacked the staff and long-term planning needed to manage its sprawling stormwater system. Most of its recommendations were delayed or ignored.


Now, with another hurricane season underway, many of those vulnerabilities remain unresolved — leaving communities across Sarasota County at continued risk.

NEW FROM SUNCOAST SEARCHLIGHT:

Phillippi Creek won't be dredged this hurricane season, no emergency permit issued



For years, homeowners living near Phillippi Creek warned Sarasota County the sediment-choked waterway needed dredging, then demanded answers when its overflowing banks flooded them during Tropical Storm Debby.


Now, with hurricane season already underway, those same neighborhoods remain vulnerable. 


The county fumbled an emergency dredging request, filing paperwork at the last possible moment — and without key details — prompting the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to deny the expedited request and reclassify it as a standard application, according to interviews and documents obtained by Florida Trident and Suncoast Searchlight.


The move could delay permitting of the project by up to eight months, pushing it well beyond the original estimate of late July.

NEW FROM SUNCOAST SEARCHLIGHT:

As LGBTQ+ rights face setbacks, Suncoast elders reflect on pride and perseverance



As Pride Month unfolds in an increasingly hostile political climate, many older LGBTQ+ residents across Florida’s Suncoast are reflecting on past struggles and warning that hard-won progress is at risk.


In interviews with Suncoast Searchlight, elders described a growing sense of déjà vu as new state laws target LGBTQ+ rights in schools, healthcare and public life — reviving fears many thought they had left behind.


From anti-trans legislation to rising social stigma, the shift has left many LGBTQ+ seniors weighing how visible they can safely be, and whether to step forward once again to defend their rights. Some, like longtime activist India Miller, have doubled down on advocacy, while others have pulled back, fearing harassment or discrimination.


At the same time, community spaces like Silver Pride and affirming churches are offering connection, support, and visibility for LGBTQ+ elders — many of whom are navigating concerns about safe aging, housing and legal protections in a state that’s become a testing ground for rollbacks.

NEW FROM SUNCOAST SEARCHLIGHT:


FACT BRIEFS


Suncoast Searchlight is partnering with Gigafact to produce weekly fact briefs — concise, 150-word news stories that take real claims circulating online and fact check them. Each brief offers a direct “yes” or “no” answer to the question or claim, followed by a clear explanation backed up by credible, high-quality sources.


READ THIS WEEK'S FACT BRIEFS:




HERE'S WHAT ELSE WE RECOMMEND READING THIS WEEK

'PRECURSOR TO MURDER': MOST SARASOTA STRANGULATION CASES NOT PROSECUTED, INVESTIGATION FINDS

FROM SARASOTA HERALD-TRIBUNE

The Office of the State Attorney, 12th Judicial Circuit, has declined to prosecute an alarming number of non-fatal domestic battery by strangulation cases, a Sarasota Herald-Tribune investigation has found, raising questions as to why this complex crime of power and passion continues to silently fracture the familial structures within our community and squeeze the voice out of its victims, if not the life, all without penalty and punishment.

READ THE STORY HERE



PROPOSED POPE RANCH DEVELOPMENT DENIED IN FINAL BOCC VOTE

FROM THE BRADENTON TIMES

Manatee County Commissioners unanimously denied a controversial rezoning request for the proposed Pope Ranch development in Parrish, ending a drawn-out application process that included multiple continuances. Simply Dwell Homes, a subsidiary of Neal Communities, had sought to rezone 217.36 acres along CR 765 (Rutland Road) from general agriculture and coastal designations to planned development residential. The final vote came during a land use meeting and lasted less than ten minutes.

READ THE STORY HERE



MAJORITY OF PURPLE RIBBON COMMITTEE MEMBERS STRESS FOCUS ON POTENTIAL REUSES OF VAN WEZEL, IN SPITE OF CONCERNS ABOUT ITS VULNERABILITY TO FUTURE STORM DAMAGE

FROM SARASOTA NEWS LEADER

While two of the six members of the City of Sarasota’s Ad Hoc Van Wezel Purple Ribbon Committee believe the city’s 55-year-old performing arts hall is doomed and has no place in city’s 53-acre Bay Park on the waterfront, other committee members stressed the potential for future uses of the so-called “Purple Cow.” Jane Kirschner, mother of past Sarasota Mayor Kelly Kirschner, has urged city leaders, “Don’t even think of COWDOZING Sarasota’s icon,” as noted by city resident Kelly Franklin. Over the past few years, Franklin has secured the signatures of 3,000 Sarasotans who want to see the Van Wezel protected, Franklin has reported.

READ THE STORY HERE



TWO SARASOTA BROTHERS JUST PADDLED FROM THE BAHAMAS TO FLORIDA TO RAISE AWARENESS FOR CYSTIC FIBROSIS

FROM SARASOTA MAGAZINE

Four Sarasota paddlers — including local attorneys Brandon and Travis Taaffe — successfully completed “The Crossing,” an 80‑mile overnight relay from Bimini to Florida, to raise awareness and funds for Piper’s Angels Foundation, which supports families battling cystic fibrosis. What began at midnight on June 22 saw teams endure ocean currents, wind, waves — and limited rest — to highlight the therapeutic benefits of saltwater for CF patients, inspired by the experience of founder Travis Suit’s daughter, Piper.

READ THE STORY HERE



WHEREVER WINNIE GOES, A TRANSMITTER WILL FOLLOW THE LOGGERHEAD'S TRAVELS FOR TOUR DE TURTLES

FROM WUSF

A tiny satellite transmitter on a hulking loggerhead sea turtle named Winnie will provide information on the reptile's travels over the next three months and give those interested a way to track her. Research biologists with the Sea Turtle Conservancy and Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, along with Turtle Watch volunteers, on Monday took advantage of the nesting season by attaching the transmitter for Tour de Turtles, an educational and research project. A couple of hundred people observed the activity on Coquina Beach South in Bradenton. The crowd paraded past Winnie, who scientists caught shortly after she laid eggs, with multiple exclamations since seeing a sea turtle up close is an amazing experience for young and old.

READ THE STORY HERE



'NO HOLES' ORDINANCE MAY BE ADOPTED BY ANNA MARIA ISLAND

FROM ABC 7

The City of Anna Maria Island is looking to create a blank slate of sand for beachgoers and newly hatched turtles as they plan to pass a “no holes on the beach” ordinance. Holmes Beach has already passed a similar ordinance for safety reasons, said Police Chief William Tokajer. “We aren’t doing it to stop kids with a little play shovel, from going to the beach and making little holes,” he said. ”This is a safety thing. We are having people dig holes that are 6 feet deep. And a little kid walking along can fall into that, and then it could collapse on him, that’s a safety factor.” According to the ordinance, holes dug on the beach should not go deeper than one foot below the surrounding sand.

VIEW THE STORY HERE



MANATEE COUNTY IS BUYING FOREST LAND AROUND AN OLD CEMETERY. HERE'S WHY

FROM BRADENTON HERALD

Manatee County leaders have voted to buy two new pieces of land with the county’s voter-backed conservation fund. A purchase of several acres of forest land at the edge of Rye Preserve, a nature preserve in Parrish, will create a buffer between the conservation area and encroaching development, county staff say. The land buy is also meant to shield Rye Cemetery, a last remnant of the Rye community that once existed along the Manatee River.

READ THE STORY HERE




SRQ NAMES NEW PRESIDENT AND CEO TO SUCCEED RETIRING RICK PICCOLO

FROM THE OBSERVER

Beginning this fall, Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport will be under new leadership. On Tuesday, the Sarasota-Manatee Airport Authority Board of Directors announced the unanimous selection of Paul Hoback Jr. as the incoming president and CEO, succeeding Rick Piccolo who will retire this year. Tentatively scheduled to begin at SRQ on Oct. 19, Hoback is currently executive vice president and chief development officer of the Allegheny County Airport Authority (ACAA), operator of Pittsburgh International Airport (PIT). He has served in various leadership roles in aviation for 25 years.

READ THE STORY HERE



DID YOU MISS OUR PREVIOUS NEWSLETTER?

HERE'S WHAT WE SHARED:

Sarasota Ballet dancers leave in droves, citing toxic culture and instability



Nearly half of Sarasota Ballet’s dancers — including its top two female principals — have departed after a tumultuous season marked by what many describe as a toxic work environment. In interviews with Suncoast Searchlight, 13 of the 18 dancers who are leaving detailed a culture of fear, instability, and artistic control under longtime leaders Iain Webb and Margaret Barbieri.


The dancers described mercurial casting decisions, harsh public critiques and a leadership style that discouraged input and stifled artistic expression. They said even high-ranking soloists hid their job auditions from management out of fear.


Though Webb and Barbieri have been widely credited with elevating the company’s national profile through a focus on Sir Frederick Ashton’s ballets, former dancers say the directors’ failure to evolve has created an unhealthy environment. One former dancer called it a “mental game” that left company members insecure and questioning their value.


The exodus comes just weeks before the company is set to perform at the prestigious Jacob’s Pillow festival. While the ballet has announced a prominent guest principal for the event, it is also actively recruiting new principals and soloists — a sign of just how much change is ahead.



Power and Profit: Developers build the dream, homeowners pay the debt



Tens of thousands of homeowners across Sarasota, Manatee and DeSoto counties are paying more in annual fees to developer-created government districts than in taxes to their actual local governments, a Suncoast Searchlight investigation found.


These independent districts, created during the early stages of new developments, issue bonds to fund roads, sewers, and amenities — costs later passed on to homebuyers through assessments that can last for decades.


By analyzing more than 300 homes across 85 districts, reporters uncovered that two-thirds of properties paid higher fees to their district than they did to fund essentials like police, fire and public transit.


In some neighborhoods, like Harrison Ranch and Forest Creek, homeowners paid nearly five times more. At Lakewood Ranch, district fees reached as high as $6,300 — and that’s before HOA dues are factored in.


The data, compiled from local tax rolls, offers a first-of-its-kind comparison of district fees versus city and county taxes. Read the full story and explore the database by clicking below.



Florida troopers tapped surveillance network for immigration searches, raising alarm



Florida Highway Patrol conducted more than 250 immigration-related, license-plate searches using a private network of plate readers run by Flock Safety, newly obtained search logs show. The searches spiked this spring during Operation Tidal Wave — a mass enforcement sweep that led to over 1,100 arrests statewide.


While more than 100 Florida law enforcement agencies use Flock’s cameras for criminal investigations and traffic cases, FHP stood out for using the system to aid immigration enforcement. Civil rights advocates warn the practice fuels fear in immigrant communities. It also appears to violate Flock’s own policies, which prohibit use of its technology for immigration enforcement.


The effort coincides with Gov. Ron DeSantis’ push to crack down on undocumented immigrants. Though ICE has no contract with Flock, Florida law enforcement agencies — including FHP — have signed agreements to assist with immigration enforcement. Records show troopers tagging searches with terms like “immigration overstay” and “assist ICE.”


Some within law enforcement are sounding the alarm, too. With troopers already stretched thin, critics say immigration duties are pulling officers away from core public safety responsibilities, increasing response times and straining morale.

College’s unraveling financial oversight: Staff ousted, board critics removed



Two former top finance officers at the New College Foundation say they were ousted in 2023 after pushing back against college administrators who sought to use donor-restricted funds to cover President Richard Corcoran’s salary and benefits — a move they said would violate the terms of the donations.


Ron McDonough, the foundation’s former director of finance, and Declan Sheehy, former director of philanthropy, said they warned administrators not to misuse a major gift — the largest donation in the school’s history — which they said was not intended to fund administrative salaries.



“The college was trying to find the money to pay the president,” McDonough said. “And I kept on going back, saying, ‘We don't have this unrestricted money.’”


The accounts of their final days on the job, shared publicly for the first time with Suncoast Searchlight, come as former foundation board members and alumni demand greater transparency and accountability from New College amid rising costs and sweeping institutional change.

GOT A TIP OR STORY IDEA?


Share your tips and story ideas using our online form. Your name and contact info will be kept confidential.

Suncoast Searchlight is a 501c3 nonprofit news organization whose mission is to produce investigative and explanatory journalism that serves and empowers the residents of Florida’s Suncoast region (Sarasota, Manatee, and DeSoto counties). We shine a light on critical issues affecting our community. Through independent reporting and collaboration with diverse media partners, we foster transparency, accountability and an informed citizenry, ensuring that all voices are heard and that the public has access to the information they need to drive meaningful change.


CONTACT US:

Suncoast Searchlight

PO Box 99 Sarasota, FL 34230

(941) 724-4450

Facebook  X  Instagram