Weekly Newsletter

Friday, July 18, 2025

Thank you for subscribing to Suncoast Searchlight's newsletter.

We’re here to keep you informed on the local issues that matter most. Each week, we share our latest in-depth reporting, along with the most important stories from around the region, so you stay connected and up to date with what’s happening in your community.


Enjoying this newsletter thanks to a friend? Subscribe here to get it in your inbox. 📬

NEW FROM SUNCOAST SEARCHLIGHT:

Donors pull planned gifts to Ringling Museum amid fears of political interference



When Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis proposed transferring The John and Mable Ringling Museum of Art from Florida State University to New College of Florida earlier this year, museum supporters warned the move would scare away donors.


Now, those fears have materialized.


Three donors told Suncoast Searchlight they have either pulled planned gifts from their estates or have reconsidered donations in light of the proposed takeover, even though the measure ultimately failed in this year’s state budget.


Together, those donors represent more than $750,000 in potential lost support, underscoring how deeply even the possibility of a takeover has shaken confidence in the museum’s future.


“The initial proposal to transfer The Ringling to New College gave me great pause about my planned future donations of works of art," one of the donors told Suncoast Searchlight. "I have enormous respect for what FSU has done with The Ringling and great fears for what would happen if it would be transferred to New College.”

NEW FROM SUNCOAST SEARCHLIGHT:

Florida gets spotlight for religious freedom from group reshaping church-state separation


Florida was declared the top state for religious freedom in the nation this week — not by a government agency or academic institution, but by a prominent legal group at the forefront of the Christian conservative movement.


The symbolic distinction was announced Monday during an event at New College of Florida, where DeSantis appeared onstage with New College President Richard Corcoran and Kelly Shackelford, president of First Liberty Institute.


Shackelford described Florida as a beacon for religious freedom, saying “every citizen and business in Florida can know that they have the most religious freedom protections.”


But the designation, billed as a broad endorsement of religious liberty, came from a group critics say has advanced a much narrower vision. First Liberty, a Texas-based nonprofit, has become one of the country’s most influential forces in reshaping First Amendment law — filing dozens of lawsuits eroding the wall separating church and state.

NEW FROM SUNCOAST SEARCHLIGHT:

Facing scrutiny, Sarasota city clerk's proposed $44K raise to be pulled from agenda



A surprise proposal to make Sarasota’s city auditor and clerk the highest-paid employee on the city’s payroll is expected to be shelved — at least for now.


The $44,000 raise, quietly added to Monday’s City Commission agenda, would boost Clerk Shayla Griggs’ salary by 25%, from $196,247 to $240,000. That figure exceeds the pay of the city manager, department heads and police chief, and would place Griggs among the highest-paid municipal clerks in Florida.


But after the item began circulating in City Hall and on social media, officials said Thursday it would be withdrawn to allow more time for discussion and additional information.


“There’s nothing in there — no information,” City Commissioner Jen Ahearn-Koch said of the agenda item. “You want to see it make sense, and that additional information will help us.”


National exhibit exploring journalism's past, present and future comes to Sarasota




A nationally touring exhibit celebrating the vital role of journalism in American life is coming to Sarasota next month.


“Moments of Truth: An Exploration of Journalism’s Past, Present and Future” is a hands-on, multimedia experience presented by the nonprofit Poynter Institute as part of its 50th anniversary. The traveling exhibit traces the evolution of the press in the United States and examines how journalism has influenced public life — including its role in supporting democratic institutions and countering false or misleading information.


The exhibit will be on display August 4–11 at The John & Mable Ringling Museum of Art in Sarasota. The local stop, sponsored by Suncoast Searchlight, will include community events, panel discussions and interactive sessions aimed at building media literacy and trust. Programming includes:


  • Be MediaWise Workshop: Sorting Fact from Fiction Online — A hands-on session teaching practical strategies for identifying misinformation online. Aug. 5, 10:30–11:30 a.m., MakerSpace Classroom


  • Open Studio Youth Event — Interactive art sessions designed to introduce younger visitors to media literacy concepts. Aug. 6, sessions at 11 a.m., 12 p.m., and 1 p.m., Education Center MakerSpace


  • Community Conversation — A public forum discussing journalism’s future and its role in local communities. Aug. 7, doors open at 6 p.m., conversation from 6:30–7:30 p.m., Chao Lecture Hall


  • Trivia Night — Date and time to be announced.

NEW FROM SUNCOAST SEARCHLIGHT:


FACT BRIEFS


Suncoast Searchlight is partnering with Gigafact to produce weekly fact briefs — concise, 150-word news stories that take real claims circulating online and fact check them. Each brief offers a direct “yes” or “no” answer to the question or claim, followed by a clear explanation backed up by credible, high-quality sources.


READ THIS WEEK'S FACT BRIEFS:





Good journalism is better when shared. Pass it on.



Hey there, friend, click here to subscribe

HERE'S WHAT ELSE WE RECOMMEND READING THIS WEEK

FAMILY WHO STARTED SCHOLARSHIP SUES NEW COLLEGE FOUNDATION, ALLEGES MONEY ISN'T BEING AWARDED

FROM WUSF

A scholarship fund meant for students of color who demonstrate financial need is at the center of a lawsuit alleging New College of Florida hasn't given out the money in years and won't relinquish the funds as requested. John J. Lentini and his children, Julia K.L. Marquis and Jerald Lentini, are suing the New College Foundation, seeking a return of the money, which amounted to $156,000 when the family endowed the scholarship in 2021, plus interest and court costs.

READ THE STORY HERE



AFTER $67 MILLION IN GIVING, MANATEE COMMUNITY FOUNDATION LAUNCHES NEW CHAPTER

FROM BRADENTON HERALD

The Manatee Community Foundation is entering a landmark new chapter: After 27 years under the umbrella of the Community Foundation of Sarasota County, it is now officially operating as a fully independent organization. Since its founding in 1998, the Bradenton-based foundation has invested more than $67 million into the community through grants, scholarships and partnerships that support everything from emergency food and housing to education and the arts. Leaders say this step toward independence will give the foundation more flexibility to grow its impact and better serve the people of Manatee County.

READ THE STORY HERE



HOUSING REPORT: THOUSANDS OF AFFORDABLE UNITS NEEDED BY 2035

FROM VENICE GONDOLIER

A middle-income family of two earning $112,560 per year — 140% of the area median income — can’t afford to buy a moderately priced home in Sarasota County. That’s one of the findings in the Sarasota Housing Action Plan prepared by the Florida Housing Coalition. The plan was funded by Gulf Coast Community Foundation, the Charles & Margery Barancik Foundation, The Patterson Foundation and the Community Foundation of Sarasota County. The plan projected a need to add 6,800 affordable homes for sale by 2035 to “meaningfully” increase the supply, based on current statistics and estimated growth in the population of “cost-burdened” households — ones in which more than 30% of their income goes to housing expenses, including utilities, taxes and insurance.

READ THE STORY HERE



DESANTIS PICKS BLAISE INGOGLIA FOR CFO; SAYS HE NEVER WOULD HAVE CHOSEN JOE GRUTERS

FROM FLORIDA PHOENIX

According to Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis, even if George Washington rose from the dead and patted him on the shoulder and said he should appoint Gruters to the CFO spot, he wouldn’t be able to do it. “My response would be, ‘No, I can’t do that without betraying the voters that elected me to lead the state in a conservative direction,'” he said.

READ THE STORY HERE



TURTLE NEST DISTURBANCE REPORTED IN BRADENTON BEACH

FROM THE ANNA MARIA ISLANDER

The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission confirmed it's investigating an alleged disturbance of a sea turtle nest July 9 by a family in Bradenton Beach. The investigation was prompted by witness reports that a group of adults and children dug into a marked sea turtle nest, removed hatchlings and carried them toward the Gulf. Lisa Harrison of Plant City spoke to The Islander July 11, saying she witnessed the incident. “We watched them. We took some photos,” Harrison said. She said at one point one of the girls in her party called authorities. “They carried some (hatchlings) out to the water … .They carried some out to knee-deep (water). Then, when it got dark, that’s when they started digging, like really digging… .It was awful.”

READ THE STORY HERE



COUNTY MISTAKE FORCES URGENT REQUEST FOR NEW TRAIL PLAZA DEVELOPMENT

FROM SARASOTA OBSERVER

Construction is already underway on North Trail Plaza, a 96-unit affordable housing project on Sarasota’s North Trail — but a last-minute land mix-up nearly derailed it. The developer, Blue Sky Communities, recently discovered that a strip of land it was set to donate to the state for road improvements didn’t actually belong to the seller, which was Sarasota County, as previously believed. It was already owned by the state. By the time the error came to light, foundation work and exterior walls were already in place. The Sarasota Planning Board approved a key setback adjustment on July 9 to keep the project on track.

READ THE STORY HERE



'I WAS THERE REPRESENTING EVERYBODY FROM SARASOTA COUNTY.' SUNCOAST MEN ASSIST WITH TEXAS FLOOD RECOVERY EFFORTS

FROM ABC7

When Kerr County, TX, called for help, two Suncoast men immediately jumped in to help. “When I was out there, it wasn’t about myself, I was there representing everybody from Sarasota County,” former Fire Captain Sergio Curvelo said. Curvelo says when the phone rang on Four of July weekend asking for his help in Kerr County, Texas, his immediate answer was yes. He later made the 12-hour drive with his cadaver dog to assist with search and rescue efforts.

VIEW THE STORY HERE



INVESTORS SNAPPED UP TAMPA BY HOMES DAMAGED BY HURRICANES HELENE AND MILTON

FROM TAMPA BAY TIMES

A Tampa Bay Times analysis found LLCs bought more than a quarter of the 3,300 properties that sold in areas inundated by significant storm surge. The share of homes in those areas that sold to a company instead of to an individual more than doubled over the six months after Hurricane Helene. In areas with minimal or no surge at all, the share stayed about the same. It’s a familiar trend after natural disasters, experts say, as residents buckle under the financial strain of repairs and the emotional toll of living in a high-risk area.

READ THE STORY HERE



SARASOTA COUNTY AWARDS $17 MILLION IN ARTS, HURRICANE RECOVERY GRANTS

FROM SARASOTA HERALD-TRIBUNE

The Sarasota County Commission awarded numerous grants for Hurricane Ian recovery as well as to arts programs last week, as part of the county's summer meetings on next year's budget. The arts funding was a much smoother process than last year’s budget meetings, when then-commissioners Mike Moran and Neil Rainford held up funding for for three popular programs – Embracing Our Differences, the Chalk Festival and WSLR/Fogartyville Community Media and Arts Center. Moran is now the Sarasota County Tax Collector; Rainford was unseated by Commissioner Tom Knight last August.

READ THE STORY HERE


DID YOU MISS OUR PREVIOUS NEWSLETTER?

HERE'S WHAT WE SHARED:

Bright lights, no rules: Florida's illegal gambling dens are hiding in plain sight



They light up U.S. 41 north of the airport with neon promises — flashing 7-7-7 and mounds of gold — on storefronts wrapped in dark tint.


Up and down 14th Street in Bradenton, along the Manatee Avenue corridor and tucked in southern stretches of Sarasota County, places like Diamond City and Spin Fun operate in plain sight. They call themselves arcades, but there are no claw machines or prizes for kids inside.


Instead, these adult playrooms boast illegal slot machines that have eluded law enforcement for years, closing down on one street only to reopen on another.


Despite more than a decade of legislative crackdowns on illegal gambling, a joint investigation between Suncoast Searchlight and the Bradenton Herald found unlicensed casinos operating out of strip malls and storefronts have continued to proliferate across the region, offering unregulated slots and cash payouts in open defiance of state laws.


For years, state and local authorities have struggled to police these operations, hampered by limited resources and weak criminal punishments that allow arcade owners to brush off law-enforcement interference, the news organizations found.



Sarasota assistant county administrator resigns amid stormwater fallout


Sarasota Assistant County Administrator Mark Cunningham resigned on Wednesday, becoming the highest-ranking official to step down in the wake of revelations about widespread failures in the county’s stormwater management system.


County officials did not disclose the reason for Cunningham’s resignation but said in an emailed statement that County Administrator Jonathan Lewis had accepted it.


His departure, effective at the end of the month, follows mounting public scrutiny sparked by a joint investigation from the Florida Trident and Suncoast Searchlight, which found the county ignored repeated warnings, failed to maintain key flood-control infrastructure and allowed critical staff vacancies to go unfilled — all contributing to catastrophic flooding during the 2024 storm season.


Cunningham, 60, recently was reassigned by Lewis to oversee stormwater operations alongside Public Works Director Spencer Anderson, who reports directly to Cunningham. Together, Cunningham and Anderson were the two top officials overseeing stormwater operations during the period when many of the failures occurred.

Meet the Sarasota pastor rallying for a spiritual war against America's 'enemies'



At a recent Saturday evening service, Pastor Brian Gibbs issued a startling pronouncement to his Sarasota congregation: Nefarious entities had embedded themselves in America. 


“Warring angels,” he prayed, would assist the U.S. military in snuffing them out.


“I pray, Lord, that you would reveal to us exactly where enemies are, enemies that came in, weapons that have come in, that could potentially be used against us for terror and for death.”


This is standard talk for Gibbs, the lead pastor of Victory: A Church of His Presence in Sarasota and a political activist who casts the American church as a crusading light against shadowy forces of evil.


Though his congregation is modest — a service last month drew roughly 100 people — Gibbs has quietly expanded his reach. He currently holds services in another church’s space but has raised more than $670,000 to build a 500-seat sanctuary of his own in the Sarasota suburbs.


In the last decade, Gibbs has worked to advance his political vision in Sarasota and beyond — speaking at school board meetings against LGBTQ+ inclusion, traveling the country to challenge the 2020 election results and maintaining a friendship with Republican U.S. Rep. Greg Steube.



Uncomfortable but necessary: Sarasota County reconsiders budget amid warnings


Sarasota County commissioners are tapping the brakes on their record-breaking $2.5 billion budget, voting this week to add another workshop and reopen debate over key spending decisions. The move follows concern about the long-term sustainability of ballooning costs.


The surprise decision comes after weeks of budget meetings where commissioners heard requests for major funding increases across departments — including major hikes proposed by the tax collector's and sheriff's offices. But some now say they’ve moved too fast and want to take a closer look before locking anything in.


County staff projected that expenses are on track to outpace revenue by tens of millions of dollars within just a few years. With signs of a cooling housing market, the financial outlook is looking shakier.


Officials insist they’re still committed to critical investments in public safety, infrastructure and operations. But with pressure mounting and time running short, the next few weeks could reshape the most expensive budget in county history.



GOT A TIP OR STORY IDEA?


Share your tips and story ideas using our online form. Your name and contact info will be kept confidential.

Suncoast Searchlight is a 501c3 nonprofit news organization whose mission is to produce investigative and explanatory journalism that serves and empowers the residents of Florida’s Suncoast region (Sarasota, Manatee, and DeSoto counties). We shine a light on critical issues affecting our community. Through independent reporting and collaboration with diverse media partners, we foster transparency, accountability and an informed citizenry, ensuring that all voices are heard and that the public has access to the information they need to drive meaningful change.


CONTACT US:

Suncoast Searchlight

PO Box 99 Sarasota, FL 34230

(941) 724-4450

Facebook  X  Instagram