Weekly Newsletter

Friday, Nov. 14, 2025

Thank you for subscribing to Suncoast Searchlight's newsletter.

We’re here to keep you informed on the local issues that matter most. Each week, we share our latest in-depth reporting, along with the most important stories from around the region, so you stay connected and up to date with what’s happening in your community.


Enjoying this newsletter thanks to a friend? Subscribe here to get it in your inbox. 📬

CONVERSATION WITH FORMER NYT EDITOR DEAN BAQUET


Our first community engagement event, held Thursday at the Sarasota Garden Club at The Bay, was a huge success!


Thank you to Gulf Coast Community Foundation for sponsoring this series of free events, to our wonderful volunteers for their hard work and to everyone who came to hear our executive editor-in-chief, Emily Le Coz, interview former New York Times executive editor Dean Baquet about the state of media industry, the rise of nonprofit newsrooms like ours and the ways in which our community can support a free press.


Check our website later today for the full story.

NEW FROM SUNCOAST SEARCHLIGHT:

TWO CHARTERS VIE FOR SAME SARASOTA CAMPUSES UNDER ‘SCHOOLS OF HOPE’



On the very first day they could, two different charter school operators filed notices Tuesday to compete for unused space on the same Sarasota County public campuses by taking advantage of controversial changes to state law.


Mater Academy and Somerset Academy notified the school district they both intend to “co-locate” at Brookside Middle School and Emma E. Booker Elementary under Florida’s Schools of Hope legislation.


That’s despite district plans approved by the school board Friday aimed to boost enrollment at a dozen public schools at risk of a charter takeover. That plan, which passed unanimously, followed a series of community meetings at local schools packed with angry parents where the district presented options to make its campuses less attractive to incoming charters.


The district has 20 calendar days to submit objections to the proposals on grounds of “material impracticability,” according to a Florida Department of Education rule amended on Sept. 24. The first charter school to send a notice would receive the space. Both notices were filed Tuesday. It’s unclear which came first.


Mater Academy prematurely filed three notices in October in Sarasota County amid dozens sent out statewide, including notices for Brookside Middle, Emma E. Booker and Oak Park School. Now, both Mater and a new charter operator, Somerset Academy, seek to occupy Emma E. Booker and Brookside.

NEW FROM SUNCOAST SEARCHLIGHT:

TAMPA GENERAL TO ASSUME OPERATIONS OF DESOTO COUNTY’S LONE HOSPITAL


Big changes are coming to the only hospital in rural DeSoto County. 


The public Desoto Memorial Hospital board voted unanimously on Monday to lease the 49-bed facility, based in Arcadia, to Tampa General Hospital for an investment of at least $45 million and rent of $10 per year. The lease will be for a period of 49 years.


The decision capped a day-long meeting in which directors heard presentations on three options for the hospital’s future. In accepting the TGH system’s plan, the board rejected proposals from AdventHealth, one of the nation’s 10 largest health care systems, and NorthStar Hospitals, a health care management and investment company based in Massachusetts.


Board member Robert Heine, who made the motion to proceed with TGH’s proposal, said he preferred a lease to a sale of the hospital. “For that reason, I think that Tampa General can help this community the most,” he said.


Representatives from AdventHealth and NorthStar said during their presentations they were open to a long-term lease but the organizations originally proposed a purchase and a management services agreement, respectively.



The decision comes as the hospital faces challenges common to many rural facilities: rising labor and equipment costs; difficulty recruiting specialists; the loss of expertise as aging employees retire; and Medicare and Medicaid reimbursements that fall short of covering actual costs.

Join us in powering local news all year long

We are in week two of our NewsMatch campaign — a national movement supporting local, nonprofit journalism like ours.


If you’ve ever thought about becoming a monthly supporter, now’s the perfect time. NewsMatch will match your full year of monthly gifts up front, doubling your impact right away and helping us plan ahead for the stories that matter most to our community.


Every contribution, large or small, helps us keep shining a light on the Suncoast.


👉 Donate here


Suncoast Searchlight partners with Gigafact to produce weekly fact briefs — concise, 150-word news stories that take real claims circulating online and fact check them. Each brief offers a direct “yes” or “no” answer to the question or claim, followed by a clear explanation backed up by credible, high-quality sources.


THIS WEEK'S FACT BRIEFS:



HERE'S WHAT ELSE WE RECOMMEND READING THIS WEEK


SARASOTA’S HIGHEST-PAID CITY EMPLOYEES REVEALED IN TOP 10 SALARIES

FROM SARASOTA HERALD-TRIBUNE

Your roads are not maintained on their own, nor are your development ordinances enforced out of thin air or water quality inspected by artificial intelligence. It takes a busy, and often unappreciated, hive of public servants to keep the city of Sarasota buzzing. An itemized list of employee salaries was obtained by the Herald-Tribune via a public records request. The 934 people listed on the city’s payroll range from elected officials and senior department heads to landscapers, beat cops, and vacation rental compliance specialists.

READ THE STORY HERE



MIDNIGHT PASS A YEAR AFTER REOPENING: WHAT COMES NEXT?

FROM ABC7

Midnight Pass has been a life source for Little Sarasota Bay, allowing water to circulate and biodiversity to thrive. But that all changed in 1983 when the pass began to shift, threatening homes nearby. The homeowners got permission to close the pass with hopes of reopening it in new location. But those efforts were unsuccessful. “What I’ve noticed about Midnight Pass is that in the hopes of saving a few homes, the environment and all the things around it suffered along with the people who could use the area,” local resident Mike Smith said. With its natural reopening in 2024 after the hurricanes Helene and Milton, the health of the bay been improving significantly. The community wants to make sure the pass stays open and maintained. So what are the next steps?

READ/WATCH THE STORY HERE



DEPUTIES RAID ANOTHER BRADENTON ARCADE ACCUSED OF ILLEGAL GAMBLING

FROM BRADENTON HERALD

Detectives seized dozens of slot machines and thousands of dollars in cash after raiding New Winners Circle Arcade, where undercover visits had confirmed it was operating electronic slot and gaming machines in violation of state law. It is the latest storefront casino targeted in what law enforcement describes as an ongoing effort to curb illegal gambling operations across Manatee County. But as recent reporting by the Bradenton Herald and Suncoast Searchlight has shown, those closures don’t always last. A joint-newsroom investigation in July identified nearly 20 unlicensed gambling businesses from Bradenton to Englewood and found that many reopen under new names or management shortly after being shut down.

READ THE STORY HERE



FEAR OF IMMIGRATION ARRESTS NEAR SCHOOLS IN FLORIDA REDUCING ENROLLMENT, OFFICIALS SAY

FROM WUSF

Education leaders watching how immigration policies affect schools expect classrooms to get emptier every year, but this year, they were caught off guard by falling enrollment rates in some of Florida’s largest districts. In Orange County, the school district saw an enrollment decrease of around 6,600 students this year, more than double the 3,000 students the district predicted would leave for charter schools, said school board member Stephanie Vanos. She said the majority of the unexpected departures were children in immigrant families. The district’s total enrollment is just over 182,400.

READ THE STORY HERE



MANATEE COUNTY APPROVES TWO MORE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DISTRICTS

FROM WSLR

A fast-growing share of homeowners in the region are paying more assessments to their community development district than taxes to their county. That’s according to an investigative series by Suncoast Searchlight. These districts are often developer-controlled, and homeowners have little say. Even so, the Manatee County Commission just approved two more CDDs. A CDD is a special district that lets a neighborhood finance and maintain its own roads, landscaping and amenities through special assessments paid by residents. During the meeting, commissioners debated what these districts mean for homeowners and who’s responsible for maintaining their infrastructure.

READ THE STORY HERE



AFTER 34 YEARS AT THE SAME MCDONALD'S, A SPECIAL CAREER COMES TO AN END

FROM TAMPA BAY TIMES

This was a special day but a work day nonetheless, so Rich Wilber did the same thing he did after every shift. He ate chicken nuggets and sipped a strawberry smoothie. He wouldn’t turn his attention to the sheet cake and gifts until the meal was methodically consumed. Rich, 56, tugged his yellow McDonald’s hat signed by coworkers and adjusted a satin sash slung around his chest: Officially retired! Rich, who has Down syndrome, spent 34 years at the McDonald’s on 34th Street South. He clocked in five days a week from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m., mostly washing dishes but also meeting customers, throwing fist bumps at regulars.

READ THE STORY HERE



SARASOTA'S STEUBE AMONG ONLY REPUBLICANS TO VOTE AGAINST ENDING THE SHUTDOWN

FROM SARASOTA HERALD-TRIBUNE

As the U.S. House of Representatives voted to end the longest shutdown in the nation’s history on Wednesday, Nov. 13, there were only two Republican holdouts who joined Democrats in voting nay. One of them was Sarasota’s own Congressman Greg Steube. Matt Fisher, a spokesman for Steube, told the Herald-Tribune that the congressman’s vote hinged on a provision inserted into the bill by his Republican colleagues in the Senate, which would have given senators a $500,000 payment for every instance in which federal law enforcement obtained their electronic data without their knowledge.

READ THE STORY HERE



EXPERTS DEBATE POTENTIAL PROPERTY TAX MEASURE AT USF: ‘THIS IS POLICY MALPRACTICE’

FROM FLORIDA PHOENIX

Gov. Ron DeSantis and CFO Blaise Ingoglia’s campaign to scale back or eliminate homesteaded property taxes drew a rebuke from a former Republican state lawmaker Wednesday night during a discussion with Ingoglia and tax policy experts. “It’s not really a proposal, it’s a bumper sticker, right?” said Jeff Brandes, who served in the Florida Legislature representing parts of Pinellas County from 2010-2022. During the event at the University of South Florida in Tampa, Ingoglia called that “a false premise.” “I think there is more than enough room to cut local budgets, probably by the amount of 15%, and not even worry about taking away any money for essential services,” he said.

READ THE STORY HERE



SARASOTA FALLS FROM U.S. NEWS & WORLD REPORT RETIREMENT RANKINGS AS NORTH PORT CLIMBS

FROM SARASOTA MAGAZINE

Sarasota, long the toast of the retirement world, just got upstaged by its own neighbors. In U.S. News & World Report’s list of the 2026 Best Places to Retire, the city dropped out of the national list of top 250 cities altogether, while North Port, the quiet inland counterpart in the same county, landed at No. 135. On U.S News’ statewide list of best places to retire, the irony runs even deeper: North Port ranks 36th, Bradenton 46th and Sarasota—wedged right between them on the map—comes in at 57th.

READ THE STORY HERE



NEW AIRPORT CEO FINDS 'PARADISE' IN FIRST MONTH IN SARASOTA

FROM SARASOTA OBSERVER

As a visit to Sarasota after becoming the new president and CEO of Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport came to an end, Paul Hoback and his wife, Amy, were at the gate awaiting a return flight to Pittsburgh. That's when an epiphany offered confirmation of their career move choice. “I’m a big fan of yacht rock,” said Hoback, ironically, the genre often heard from the airport’s audio system. That’s when the song Almost Paradise from the movie Footloose broadcast over the terminal’s speakers. “Almost” is descriptive of Hoback’s philosophical approach to his profession. No endeavor is ever complete. There is always room for improvement. And after an entire life and career spent in the Pittsburgh area, moving to the Sun Coast is surely paradise.

READ THE STORY HERE


DID YOU MISS OUR PREVIOUS NEWSLETTER?

HERE'S WHAT WE SHARED:

‘HOME RULE’ FIGHT OVER FLORIDA’S SB 180 EXPOSES GROWING RIFT INSIDE REPUBLICAN RANKS



During an October meeting of Sarasota MAGA Patriots — a rightwing coalition pursuing a range of issues, from anti-vaccine activism to emergency preparedness — attendees railed against a new state law curbing local oversight of development and the Republican lawmakers who backed it.


Their ire reflects tensions inside Florida’s dominant party, between Tallahassee’s power brokers and the populist base that helped put them there.


Passed this spring with near-unanimous support in both the Senate and the House, SB 180 limits counties and cities from imposing new limits on building — a measure framed as a way to help homeowners rebuild after major storms, but whose reach extends statewide and far beyond coastal areas still recovering from 2024 storms.


The backlash to SB180 highlights a growing divide within the GOP, between state leaders consolidating control in Tallahassee and grassroots conservatives demanding decisions stay local. It has also united a broad range of political groups — libertarians, MAGA activists, conservationists, blue-leaning municipalities and good-government groups who say the law favors developers over communities.


Already, chapters of the Republican Liberty Caucus — a national group with roots in the Tea Party movement — have condemned the bill as “a giveaway to developers at the expense of Florida’s families, farms and future.” They’ve found unexpected allies in organizations such as Audubon Florida, League of Women Voters of Florida and neighborhood coalitions like Sarasota’s Phillippi Creek Coalition, whose members warn that unchecked growth could worsen flooding.



SARASOTA SCHOOL BOARD PRAISES PLAN TO CURB CHARTER TAKEOVERS, BUT QUESTIONS REMAIN

Faced with a state law that opens the door for charter schools to claim unused public classrooms, Sarasota County School Board members on Tuesday gave cautious support to the district’s strategic plan to reduce vacant space — while pressing for answers about its cost and whether it will be enough to keep charters out.


Superintendent Terry Connor presented the proposal, which was first reported by Suncoast Searchlight last week, during a special work session at the district’s headquarters at The Landings. 



Board members said they’ve heard strong community support for the plan since its release and called it an innovative way to get ahead of the state’s newly expanded “Schools of Hope” law, which allows charter-school operators to move into underused public campuses regardless of their own academic performance.


School Board member Karen Rose said the plan allowed for increased flexibility and put Sarasota ahead of other districts across the state.


Board member Bridget Ziegler said it was exciting to see the community’s enthusiastic response after Suncoast Searchlight’s story brought the plan to light: “This is something we wanted for our community.”



SARASOTA SCHOOLS DRAFTED A PLAN TO PREVENT ‘SCHOOLS OF HOPE’ TAKEOVERS. HERE’S WHAT’S IN IT.



Sarasota County Schools has drawn up a sweeping plan to shrink its empty classroom space — and, in the process, try to shield itself from a new state law that allows charter schools to move into underused public campuses.


The strategic plan, which Superintendent Terry Connor is set to present to the school board Tuesday, calls for selling the district’s headquarters at The Landings and relocating those offices into existing schools, razing or reconfiguring some campus buildings and expanding programs in schools with the most vacant seats, among a host of other strategies.


Among the schools affected are Alta Vista Elementary, Fruitville Elementary, McIntosh Middle and Venice Middle. District officials crafted the proposal as state education leaders toured 12 Sarasota schools in mid-October to review the district’s current usage and provide guidance on the viability of its plan to maximize it.


The resulting proposal achieves a reduction of 3,100 “student stations” — the state’s term for classroom seats — boosting utilization rates at several campuses and reducing the number of openings that could be claimed by charter schools under the controversial “Schools of Hope” law.


Suncoast Searchlight, with help from the Florida Center for Government Accountability, obtained the PowerPoint presentation Friday through a public records request. Connor asked that publication of the story be delayed until he could present the plan publicly first, citing its level of detail and his desire for residents to hear it directly from those who developed it. Suncoast Searchlight declined, noting that the proposal is a public record and that early access allows residents to review it in advance.

AFTER NEAR-DEATH ATTACK, SARASOTA STYLIST HELPS OTHER DOMESTIC VIOLENCE SURVIVORS



The buzz of blow dryers and hum of small talk fill Rhonda Calahan’s Sarasota salon most days — until her phone rings. She doesn’t hesitate. She sets down her scissors, wipes her hands and answers, her tone soft but urgent. 


On the other end might be a woman whispering from a locked bathroom, a mother searching for a safe place to sleep or a survivor trying to decide if it’s finally time to leave.


“I am the hotline,” Calahan said. “My phone can ring anytime, day or night. I always answer.”


Calahan runs Queens of Domestic Violence Awareness, a small nonprofit organization she launched to help survivors find safety, counseling and support. For Calahan, the mission is personal. Fifteen years ago, an ex-boyfriend nearly killed her after she tried to end their relationship. The scars — physical and emotional — still drive her to pick up the phone today.


Her work meets a pressing need in Sarasota and Manatee counties, where law enforcement recorded an average of nearly 2,600 domestic violence cases annually over the past decade. Experts say the real number is far higher, since many incidents are never reported to the police.

GOT A TIP OR STORY IDEA?


Share your tips and story ideas using our online form. Your name and contact info will be kept confidential.

Suncoast Searchlight is a 501c3 nonprofit news organization whose mission is to produce investigative and explanatory journalism that serves and empowers the residents of Florida’s Suncoast region (Sarasota, Manatee, and DeSoto counties). We shine a light on critical issues affecting our community. Through independent reporting and collaboration with diverse media partners, we foster transparency, accountability and an informed citizenry, ensuring that all voices are heard and that the public has access to the information they need to drive meaningful change.


CONTACT US:

Suncoast Searchlight

PO Box 99 Sarasota, FL 34230

(941) 724-4450