Weekly Newsletter

Friday, June 6, 2025

Thank you for subscribing to Suncoast Searchlight's newsletter. 

We’re here to keep you informed on the local issues that matter most. Each week, we share our latest in-depth reporting, along with the most important stories from around the region, so you stay connected and up to date with what’s happening in your community.


Enjoying this newsletter thanks to a friend? Subscribe here to get it in your inbox every week.

NEW FROM SUNCOAST SEARCHLIGHT:

Power and Profit: Developers build the dream, homeowners pay the debt




Tens of thousands of homeowners across Sarasota, Manatee and DeSoto counties are paying more in annual fees to developer-created government districts than in taxes to their actual local governments, a Suncoast Searchlight investigation found.


These independent districts, created during the early stages of new developments, issue bonds to fund roads, sewers, and amenities — costs later passed on to homebuyers through assessments that can last for decades.


By analyzing more than 300 homes across 85 districts, reporters uncovered that two-thirds of properties paid higher fees to their district than they did to fund essentials like police, fire and public transit.


In some neighborhoods, like Harrison Ranch and Forest Creek, homeowners paid nearly five times more. At Lakewood Ranch, district fees reached as high as $6,300 — and that’s before HOA dues are factored in.


The data, compiled from local tax rolls, offers a first-of-its-kind comparison of district fees versus city and county taxes. Read the full story and explore the database by clicking below.

NEW FROM SUNCOAST SEARCHLIGHT:


Inside New College’s unraveling financial oversight: Staff ousted, board critics removed





Two former top finance officers at the New College Foundation say they were ousted in 2023 after pushing back against college administrators who sought to use donor-restricted funds to cover President Richard Corcoran’s salary and benefits — a move they said would violate the terms of the donations.


Ron McDonough, the foundation’s former director of finance, and Declan Sheehy, former director of philanthropy, said they warned administrators not to misuse a major gift — the largest donation in the school’s history — which they said was not intended to fund administrative salaries.


Both said their contracts were terminated after they raised concerns internally.


“The college was trying to find the money to pay the president,” McDonough said. “And I kept on going back, saying, ‘We don't have this unrestricted money.’”


The accounts of their final days on the job, shared publicly for the first time with Suncoast Searchlight, come as former foundation board members and alumni demand greater transparency and accountability from New College amid rising costs and sweeping institutional change.


NEW FROM SUNCOAST SEARCHLIGHT:


FACT BRIEFS


Suncoast Searchlight is partnering with Gigafact to produce weekly fact briefs — concise, 150-word news stories that take real claims circulating online and fact check them. Each brief offers a direct “yes” or “no” answer to the question or claim, followed by a clear explanation backed up by credible, high-quality sources.


READ THIS WEEK'S FACT BRIEFS:


Floridians are preparing for a hot summer. Can pouring hot water down your AC drain line unclog it?


Did sea turtle nesting at Anna Maria Island set a 40-year record in 2024?


Do you have to “lease” an additional trash bin under Sarasota County’s new waste contract?


Florida state parks are protected under new law. Did Gov. DeSantis plan to develop on those lands?


HERE'S WHAT ELSE WE RECOMMEND READING THIS WEEK

COMMISSIONER SEEKS TO PROFIT FROM LAND DONATED TO COUNTY FOR CONSERVATION

FROM FLORIDA TRIDENT

Sarasota County Commissioner Ron Cutsinger sought to buy a strip of mangrove shoreline in Englewood that was donated to Sarasota County for conservation in 1998, pushing to declare it surplus and sell it to himself and neighbors despite its environmental value and his personal real estate dealings nearby. For more than a year, Cutsinger argued the donated land was a wild deed done in “spite” to block views of Lemon Bay and prevent the construction of docks across the mangroves. A wild deed is a legal term used to describe a recorded deed unconnected to the official chain of title. James Hiller Hardie — one of the family members who signed the deeds gifting the land to the county — disputes Cutsinger’s assertions. “Absolutely not,” said Hardie in response to Cutsinger’s claim that the land gifts were done out of spite.

READ THE STORY HERE



CUTSINGER FLIPS ON SURPLUSSING COUNTY LAND ON LEMON BAY

FROM VENICE GONDOLIER

Sarasota County Commission Vice Chair Ron Cutsinger asked his colleagues Tuesday to kill a proposal to declare more than a mile of land along Lemon Bay surplus following a news report about how he might benefit from the action. Referring to the Trident as a “so-called news blog,” Cutsinger said that its report contained “several factual inaccuracies” and its accusation he was acting out of self-interest “could not be further from the truth.” His interest was solely to see that the water rights of the people who own along Bay Shore Drive are restored, he said, and declaring it surplus was staff’s recommendation to clear up any title issues.

READ THE STORY HERE



NEW COLLEGE HAS A STUDENT RETENTION PROBLEM

FROM WLSR

More than two years after the takeover by the governor, it admits that New College of Florida has a retention problem. The 2025 Accountability Report was the first instance the new New College administrators publicly admitted they are facing retention challenges, while promising improvement and presenting fixes. The current graduation rate is at 40% – an all-time low – but administrators promise that figure will jump to 60% for the class that enrolled last year – which would be an all-time high.

READ THE STORY HERE



IS DEVELOPMENT 'OUT OF CONTROL?' MANATEE WANTS DEVELOPERS TO PAY FOR MORE FOR IT

FROM THE BRADENTON HERALD

As development booms in Manatee County, leaders want to start charging builders millions more to pay for issues caused by growth. At a recent meeting, commissioners reviewed a plan to raise impact fee rates for local development to the maximum allowed by state law. The one-time fees collected from developers help pay for infrastructure like new roads, water and sewer utilities, schools, parks, libraries and emergency services. Manatee County’s past handling of impact fees has drawn criticism from some residents and officials, who say that developers are not paying their fair share for problems caused by rapid building.

READ THE STORY HERE



WITH A NEW TERMINAL, NEW BUSINESS AND LOTS OF WEALTHY TRAVELERS, SARASOTA BRADENTON INTERNATIONAL AIRPORT IS SOARING

FROM SARASOTA MAGAZINE

Sarasota Magazine's in-depth series on Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport (SRQ) chronicles its transformation from a modest regional hub into a bustling gateway for travelers nationwide. The airport's rapid growth is highlighted by the addition of a new terminal, an influx of new businesses and a surge in affluent travelers. Outgoing President and CEO Rick Piccolo reflects on his 30-year tenure, during which SRQ diversified its revenue streams, bringing in $3.5 million and enabling the airport to weather economic downturns and fund future improvements. The series also delves into the airport's history, its impact on the local economy, and the lifestyle of private jet owners like Jesse Biter, who likens his Embraer Phenom 100 to a "Suburban in the sky."

READ THE SERIES HERE



SARASOTA COUNTY WANTS TO CREATE A NEW STORMWATER DEPARTMENT, BUT THE DETAILS ARE MURKY

FROM SARASOTA HERALD-TRIBUNE

The Sarasota County Commission is considering creating a new department whose sole focus would be managing stormwater, after public trust in their ability to prevent flooding has cratered entering the 2025 hurricane season. County Administrator Jonathan Lewis has been tasked to find out how the new department would work logistically and financially. He said in a statement that he would eventually present the commission with scenarios involved with “staffing, funding, functions, assets, and logistics of eliminating the Public Works Department and creating two departments − one a Stormwater Department, and most likely, the other would be a revamped Transportation Department.” Lewis’ goal is to have all this ready to present to commissioners by July's budget workshops.

READ THE STORY HERE



COMMISSIONERS APPROVE MEASURE THAT RESTRICTS NEW RETAILS PET STORES FROM OPERATING IN MANATEE COUNTY

FROM THE BRADENTON TIMES

During a BOCC meeting on Tuesday, commissioners voted to approve the adoption of a county ordinance that will prohibit the opening of any new retail pet stores within Manatee County. Ordinance 25-33 came before the commissioners after a 6-0 vote in February instructed staff to draft such a provision, modeling a similar ordinance adopted by commissioners in Pinellas County.

READ THE STORY HERE



DID YOU MISS LAST WEEK'S NEWSLETTER?

HERE'S WHAT WE SHARED:

Power and Profit: How special district bonds divided a Sarasota-area neighborhood


A Sarasota-area community’s effort to save its golf course by forming a special-purpose government district and issuing $24 million in public bonds has devolved into a bitter, years-long feud over cost, governance and transparency.


While some University Park residents saw the recreation district as a way to preserve their neighborhood and gain independence from the developer, others now claim they were misled into overpaying and burdened with soaring fees — sparking lawsuits, a second $21 million bond and a pending appeal before the Florida Supreme Court.


What began as a grassroots effort to take control of local amenities has raised broader questions about how these little-known districts operate. Critics argue that the governing board ignored key financial safeguards, violated bond agreements and kept residents in the dark while pushing through expensive renovations and long-term debt.


The story also reveals deeper concerns about the use — and potential misuse — of special-purpose government districts, which have spread rapidly across the Suncoast as tools for developers and homeowners alike.


This is the latest installment in Suncoast Searchlight’s ongoing investigation into special districts, which have issued nearly $3 billion in bonds across Sarasota, Manatee and DeSoto counties in just the past five years. We’re examining how these obscure public entities shape communities — and who’s left footing the bill.

NOAA cuts could harm Southwest Florida fishing economy, threaten red tide research


Sweeping cuts to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration could imperil Florida’s multibillion-dollar fishing industry and coastal economy, industry leaders and scientists warn — a dire prospect for a region built on tourism, seafood and the health of its waters.


Beyond running the national weather monitoring and alert systems — its most visible role — NOAA also works to prevent overfishing, monitor the coastal environment and support local ocean research. 


For Florida’s Gulf Coast, that means researching red tide, addressing habitat loss and restoring overfished species. Since 2020 alone, NOAA has supported these efforts with more than $35 million in grants and contracts for Suncoast governments and nonprofits, including Mote Marine Laboratory and Aquarium in Sarasota.


But after U.S. President Donald Trump took office in January, more than 2,000 employees have left NOAA. And internal documents show plans for deep funding cuts — including slashing coastal conservation programs in half, shutting down climate research, and gutting the budget for fisheries management.

State attorney upgrades charges against Fred Piccolo Jr. to felonies



Fred Piccolo Jr., the former communications director at New College of Florida and longtime political operative, now faces two additional felony charges of indecent exposure — this time in Sarasota County — after State Attorney Ed Brodsky upgraded the charges from misdemeanors.


The new felony counts stem from two incidents in September 2024 at the University Town Center Mall, where Piccolo allegedly exposed himself to female store employees on multiple occasions. Initially charged as misdemeanors, the offenses were reclassified due to their repeat nature. Under Florida law, a second or subsequent exposure offense can be treated as a felony.


The upgraded charges were filed on Tuesday, court records show, and an arrest warrant was issued for Piccolo’s arrest on the new charges. Piccolo was arrested by the Sarasota County Sheriff’s Office on Wednesday. He was still in custody as of Thursday morning.


The charges are separate from two felony charges Piccolo already faces in Manatee County, where he was arrested in April after allegedly exposing himself to a woman in Lakewood Ranch while naked from the waist down and a second incident near New College. Both incidents occurred in March 2025 and led to his firing from New College.




Nearly half of Suncoast families can't afford the basics, new report finds



Across the Suncoast, almost half of all households struggle to make ends meet, according to a new report by the United Way Suncoast and its research partner United for ALICE.


The report, released Monday, evaluated the basic household budget required for different types of families to sustain themselves in their respective county. Researchers calculated the minimum income to meet that budget — known as the ALICE threshold, which stands for asset limited, income constrained, employed.


The ALICE concept reflects a reality that, while 10% of households in DeSoto, Manatee and Sarasota counties fall below the federal poverty level, an additional third of households aren’t earning enough to afford the essentials.


READ THE STORY TO EXPLORE OUR INTERACTIVE DATA CHARTS

GOT A TIP OR STORY IDEA?


Share your tips and story ideas using our online form. Your name and contact info will be kept confidential.

Suncoast Searchlight is a 501c3 nonprofit news organization whose mission is to produce investigative and explanatory journalism that serves and empowers the residents of Florida’s Suncoast region (Sarasota, Manatee, and DeSoto counties). We shine a light on critical issues affecting our community. Through independent reporting and collaboration with diverse media partners, we foster transparency, accountability and an informed citizenry, ensuring that all voices are heard and that the public has access to the information they need to drive meaningful change.


CONTACT US:

Suncoast Searchlight

PO Box 99 Sarasota, FL 34230

(941) 724-4450

Facebook  X  Instagram