Plexus News Banner
Thursday Complexity Post    
March 19,  2015

Algorithms for Mastering Math


In a Brooklyn, N.Y. middle school, three walls have been knocked down to create one giant classroom where four seventh grade math teachers circulate among 120 students. Four different learning areas are signified by shelving and different colored carpets and chairs. An airport style monitor just outside the door tells kids where to go.


The program, Teach to One, is designed to let each student learn at his or her own level, and master each skill before moving on to a next step. Tina Rosenberg, in her New York Times column "Fixes," notes that kids who have missed an essential math skill or concept in an early grade are likely to keep falling further behind in successive grades, eventually joining a permanent math underclass of students who find math incomprehensible.


This classroom combines many learning methods and activities with a range of sophistication. . Some children work at computers, some use work sheets in groups, and some solve equations. The subjects include manipulating fractions and negative numbers, graphing expressions on a number line, and working out a multi-day probability project. Some worksheets show wrong answers and ask students to identify the mistakes that led to them.


At the end of each session, student take a short quiz testing their mastery of the subject, letting student and teacher know the successes and deficits of the moment. Rosenberg says the next step is the real innovation. Each student's quiz is fed into an algorithm, which produces the next day's lesson for that student based on individual mastery, and even on what has been shown to be the best learning modality for the student-such as learning best with games, or liking to learn alone. (Teachers get a preview and can override the computerized schedule if they think it necessary). The program identifies 77 math skills, and has a library of 12,000 lessons to teach them. Some lessons are created by staff, others bought from education companies.


Teach to One evolved from School of One, a math teaching program created by Joel Rose, an education expert, and Chris Rush, an educational consultant, both of whom had worked for the New York City Department of Education. The two formed Classroom Innovation Partners, and Rosenberg reports the model is being used in 30 schools in New York, New Jersey, Washington DC, Georgia and North Carolina. Early results have been very promising some schools and less so in others. The initiative has not been without controversy.


New Classrooms funded a study by scholars at Teachers College of Columbia University, to measure results. In the first year, math progress for Teach for One kids was about at the national average. The New York Daily News blasted the program as a pricy reject, and it was expensive. One school spent $140,000 on computers for every child. Second year results were much more encouraging, with progress of the kids ranging from 47 percent to 60 percent above the national average. In a thoughtful piece in Forbes, Michael Horn wrote that innovations are rarely instant successes. Instead, he said, they tend to require messy experimentation with many modifications and iterations. Further, Horn wrote, formative evaluation that measures grade level achievement doesn't identify nuanced individual progress of youngsters who have come from behind and those who have soared.


Horn suggests the second year improvements indicate that earlier gaps in math knowledge may have been filled during that first year. A middle school in Charlotte Mecklenburg reports with enthusiasm on its program. Rosenberg calls it a work in progress worthy of continued use and experimentation. "School of One takes comprehensive advantage of technology in ways that let teachers concentrate on teaching," she said. "That's worth getting right."



Remember PlexusCalls!
Friday, March 27, 2015
1-2 PM Eastern Time
Action Networks: Global to Local Structures for Change
Guests: Steve Waddell and Tom Bigda-Peyton



This is the second of two calls on system change.  (This call is rescheduled from the original date of March 6, when we had to cancel for technical reasons.) While change always requires local action, change efforts are almost always heavily influenced by large contexts such as national conditions and-with increasing globalization-global ones. New approaches to organizing change move beyond traditions of hierarchy and build on multi-stakeholder strategies and inter-organizational networks. This discussion will build on 20 years of work with such strategies, highlighted in the book Global Action Networks, and will provide examples from U.S. healthcare reform.


Steven Waddell, PhD, focuses on collaboration and networks among organizations and institutions in business, government and civil society to produce innovation, enhance impact and build new capacity.His clients and project partners have included The Global Knowledge Partnership, the UN Global Compact, the World Bank, Global Reporting Initiative, the Ford Foundation, Humanity United, Civicus, International Youth Foundation, USAID, International Research and Development Centre, and the Forest Stewardship Council. He is a principal of Networking Action and lead steward for the Ecosystem Labs, which develop large change systems. He has a PhD in sociology and a master's in business administration. He is author of several articles and other publications, including the books Societal Learning and Change: Innovation with Multi-Stakeholder Strategies and Global Action Networks: Creating Our Future Together.


Thomas Bigda-Peyton, EdD, is a system coach and consultant working to catalyze innovation and whole-system engagement in large organizations and networks striving for collective impact. Tom uses methods such as collaborative problem-solving, action learning, and positive deviance to promote culture change in industries such as healthcare, government, and forestry. As a practitioner-researcher for 25 years, and currently as a Partner at Second Curve Systems in Boston, his clients have included multiple healthcare systems, the Federal Aviation Administration, Fidelity Investments, the government of Ontario, and the Forest Safety Council of British Columbia. He is co-author of the books From Innovation to Transformation: Moving Up the Curve in Ontario's Healthcare System and Safety Culture: Building and Sustaining a Cultural Change in Aviation and Healthcare. Tom holds a doctorate in Organizational Behavior and Intervention from the Harvard Graduate School of Education, where he worked with two pioneers in the field of organizational learning and system dynamics, Chris Argyris and Don Schon. He also holds master's and bachelor's degrees from Harvard.


Anyone interested is welcome to participate in these calls. Use the social share links at the top of this email to share with your Facebook, Twitter, or other networks or to others.
Please use the forward link in this email to avoid the recipient unsubscribing you. You will not subscribe them. The feature only sends this individual message. For information about Plexus Institute and more details about this  call series and others, visit

See all upcoming PlexusCalls on the Plexus Calendar. Subscribe to the PlexusCalls or Healthcare PlexusCalls podcasts. Or, visit the Community section of for the audio archive.    



Plexus Institute

1025 Connecticut Ave, NW Ste 1000 

Washington, DC  20036

Phone: 888-466-4884

...fostering the health of individuals,

families, communities, organizations,

and our natural environment by helping people

use concepts emerging from the new

science of complexity


Join Plexus 

  Find us on Facebook  Follow us on Twitter