|
Hello Client, there is too much to cover about Trademark Engine's trademark practices for just one post. Here is 2 of 3. Here's the first post if you missed it - https://tmexpress.com/trademarkengine-1of3-022224/
At the right is Shawn Plummer's credit card statement, as pertains to this post. See also at: https://www.annuityexpertadvice.com/trademark-engine-review/.
---------------
TRADEMARK ENGINE CLAIM OF "COMPREHENSIVE RESEARCH"
- IS NOT CLOSE.
For $399 Trademark Engine offers a "comprehensive research package" by their Swyft Legal subsidiary - not really Trademark Engine. Trademark Engine staff cannot answer questions about this package beyond reading their own web site to you. Yes, Swyft Legal has an attorney. No matter how hard we tried we could never reach anyone at Swyft Legal by phone. However, after much difficulty we reached a Trademark Engine top level manager. We were told they had seen 1 report, what they call comprehensive Federal, State and Common Law research. We were told it was 11 pages. They were proud it was "so many pages". For the record, a comprehensive research report should be hundreds AND hundreds of pages when enough databases and research strategies are exhausted. An experienced ethical trademark attorney would never sign off on a mere 11 page research report to advise a client to file a trademark. Imagine crossing a bridge before construction has been completed.
Swyft Legal seems to have just one trademark attorney. As of Feb 22, 2024, she had filed or worked on just 243 Federal trademarks over the past year. Almost all are newly filed trademarks, which have not reached a USPTO examining attorney yet. A survey of 50 of these 243 marks found 31, 62%), which have not reached an examining attorney yet. Too new to analyze. So, let's look at the remaining 19 trademarks - 14 (74%), drew office action refusals with attorney billable time fixable errors. These could have been filed correctly in the first place, but were not. The remaining 5 (26%), trademark filings drew damaging Office Action refusals. These were Likelihood-of-Confusion refusals for marks which should never had been filed - or at least arguable been filed with a better goods/services description to avoid refusal. The point is when you have a comprehensive legal search to look at, these kind of adventures can be avoided. Here those 5 Likelihood-of-Confusion refusals:
1) https://tsdr.uspto.gov/documentviewer?caseId=sn97817374&docId=NFIN20231206231350&linkId=4#docIndex=3&page=1
2) https://tsdr.uspto.gov/documentviewer?caseId=sn97869638&docId=NFIN20240103174125&linkId=4#docIndex=3&page=1
3) https://tsdr.uspto.gov/documentviewer?caseId=sn97756862&docId=NFIN20231024143323&linkId=6#docIndex=5&page=1
4) https://tsdr.uspto.gov/documentviewer?caseId=sn97802097&docId=NFIN20231122152923&linkId=3#docIndex=2&page=1
5) https://tsdr.uspto.gov/documentviewer?caseId=sn97844103&docId=NFIN20231214135138&linkId=6#docIndex=5&page=1
---------------
THE FUNDAMENTAL PROBLEM WITH TRADEMARK ENGINE'S
AUTOMATED TRADEMARK "SERVICES" IS REALITY.
Let's be real. Trademarks and trademark law are not well known by anyone outside the field. Even non-trademark attorneys are not well versed about trademark basics. Even most patent attorneys. Trademarks really are a very specialized area of the law. For something as valuable as a trademark, why not simply do it right the first time? Show the world you know what you are doing.
So, when hiring a non-trademark attorney associated firm like Trademark Engine - bad things are going to happen. When a firm is an AUTOMATED trademark company even worse things are going to happen. In reality, YOU are filing out your own trademark application - with NO OVERSIGHT. No help. No consultation. No advice. Why not just go to the USPTO? Time and time again I have seen Trademark Engine making NO EFFORT WHATSOEVER to screen applications to be filed out correctly to avoid sure fire Office Action USPTO refusals. If you write a ridiculous goods/services statement - it will go to the USPTO to be seen FOREVER! Same thing if you offer a bad specimen. Yes, these issues can be fixed, as Trademark Engine is happy to bump you up to their Swyft Legal branch that does have an attorney. Get ready for more fees that could have easily been avoided if your application had been screened first. This is a major issue, because many people understate their goods/services. In those cases a new application must be filed. Additions can never be made. Many trademarks are lost when the 3-month USPTO deadline to reply is missed. You are not just risking the low $49 and $99 Trademark Engine fee, but are also risking the USPTO $350/class fee and 9 months of time - at least. IF your desired trademark is not LEGALLY CLEAR, wouldn't you rather know it sooner?! Know it BEFORE you start the business? (PS: The USPTO only researches its own database of 3.5 million marks. Not all 30 million in the USA. So, IF infringing, the other company has 10 years to find you and enforce.)
In 32 years, I have never seen the USPTO do a DEFERRED SEARCH refusal, because the goods/services were so indefinite:
https://tsdr.uspto.gov/documentviewer?caseId=sn97763292&docId=NFIN20231019111247&linkId=5#docIndex=4&page=1
*IDENTIFICATION Method for learning using links embedded in a physical or electronic document that are used to access audio or video recordings or other material relating to the actions to be learned
---------------
PRESSURE TO ORDER A COPYRIGHT.
NO ADVICE TO UPGRADE FOR COMPREHENSIVE RESEARCH.
A former TradeMark Express client hired Trademark Engine to save $ on a new trademark. They immediately began to pressure him over the phone to buy extra copyright services. (Copyrights are for creative works, like literary works, web site content, songs, poems - NOT business names, logos or slogans - which are all trademark issues.) Then after 2 days, when he started getting more fees added to his credit card and he realized they were not "doing the job" he cancelled his $49 Trademark Engine order, plus the new $99 and $59 charges. They tried to charge him $350 too, apparently for the USPTO filing fee, but luckily his prepaid credit card was declined because he had just enough for the $49 plus the USPTO $350 filing fee. The subsequent $99 and $59 charges made the USPTO $350 charge decline. What was amazing to me, despite all the conversations, he was never advised by Trademark Engine staff to upgrade his order for comprehensive legal research to make sure his new name was legally clear before filing. Trademark Engine just wanted a copyright order which he did NOT NEED.
---------------
FOREIGN BUSINESSES TRADEMARK ORDERS - UNDULY DELAYED.
There is one mystery we could not figure out. Foreign based businesses must have an attorney for the USPTO to accept their trademark applications. Trademark Engine does not have trademark attorneys. But, Swyft Legal does. It takes Trademark Engine a while to figure out a new automated foreign order needs an attorney. Instead of bumping these new clients to their Swyft Legal subsidiary, they just refund their fees. If anyone has an insight on this practice, I am curious!
---------------
THE USPTO: MANY TRADEMARK ENGINE FAILURES.
1) $350 USPTO fee collection and handling,
2) Improper trademark application signing on your behalf and
3) Ongoing management.
ALL RISK USPTO UNILATERAL TRADEMARK TERMINATION FOR ALL CLIENTS.
FACT - The USPTO demands their trademark application filing fees can ONLY be paid and signed by the trademark applicant themselves, in their own keystrokes, -or- may be filed by a retained attorney for the trademark owner. Trademark Engine takes great pains to say they are NOT attorneys. See their web site, call them - it is stressed to everyone. Right up front. Your Federal trademark application can ONLY be handled by YOU or by your retained trademark attorney. That is it.
1) Two years ago the USPTO terminated over 21,000 trademarks because the services who handled those trademarks were deemed to be fraudulent. Those "trademark services" collected USPTO fees like Trademark Engine does, into their own accounts. Then, days/weeks later, they spend those funds at the USPTO when a trademark is filed. Attorneys must have an IOLTA for client's outside fees to be held. They cannot co-mingle funds. Neither can Trademark Engine who does not have attorneys. Trademark Engine is usurping USPTO fees into their own account for a few days, instead of paying the USPTO directly with client funds - which also isn't something they are not allowed to do. Again, please see proof of this in Shawn Plummer's credit card statement, above, to see the USPTO fee of $350 being charged, (actually charged $350 twice for 1 class), on the same day he first hired Trademark Engine. This is a practice noted in client reviews too, but frankly it is a murky practice. Some USPTO fees are charged by Trademark Engine a few days later, but still before the actual USPTO trademark application filing.
2) My conversation with the USPTO head of OED Office of Enrollment and Discipline 4.5 years ago could be summarized by the word KEYSTROKES. He emphasized to me that non-attorney filed trademarks HAD to be SIGNED by the ACTUAL PERSON ONLY. It was the person's keystrokes, from their computer keyboard that mattered. No cut & paste of a signature is allowed. No other party, allowance, third-party signature was allowed - otherwise it was FRAUD. Every Trademark Engine automated trademark application has this entry. Yes, the USPTO is not enforcing this issue. I do not know why. But, I do know the USPTO moves slowly and may not even be aware Trademark Engine does not have attorneys, where this practice would be acceptable. It is obvious their 1 attorney at Swyft Legal is not even glancing at any of the numerous Trademark Engine trademark filings. If she did, that would open another can of worms.
SIGNATURE METHOD Sent to third party for signature
3) The USPTO will only communicate with applicants directly or with their assigned attorneys. That is why IF you have an attorney manage your trademark, they will list their contact information, i.e. name, address, phone # and email), so people who wish to reach you, legally can. Attorneys accept that responsibility and are considered by the courts to be the contact concerning your trademark. IF you are the contact for your trademark, then only your information will be listed for anyone to contact you. There is NO PLACE for a trademark service, who may be assisting you, to be PART of YOUR trademark. Just you or your attorney. Naturally, by you there could be your LLC, S-Corp, Trust, etc - any other entity involved. But, still YOU or an officer MUST be the one doing the signatory KEYSTROKES and providing full contact information. Other people/businesses must have a way to reach you. No contact info, then no trademark. You will be refused. (Another reason not to use an automated service. Consultations and access to trademark attorney help!)
PRIMARY EMAIL ADDRESS FOR CORRESPONDENCE 168041ozx0pjidlz@relay.trademarkengine.com
SECONDARY EMAIL ADDRESS(ES) (COURTESY COPIES) notifications@trademarkengine.com
PRIMARY EMAIL ADDRESS FOR CORRESPONDENCE 226417lJQZAYcmZV@relay.trademarkengine.com
SECONDARY EMAIL ADDRESS(ES) (COURTESY COPIES) notifications@trademarkengine.com
Trademark Engine direct filing practices are NOT allowed by the USPTO!
---------
Thank you, Chris 650-948-0530
Email - staff@tmexpress.com
Zoom Anytime - https://bit.ly/TradeMarkZoomMeeting
Calendly Meeting - https://calendly.com/tmexpress/15min
Crash Course Trademark Video - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3gWaAJR5L18
===================================================
===================================================
===================================================
Recent Blog Posts on the subject of Trademark Scams
Sent December 30, 2023.
TradeMark Express vs. Trademark Pearl - Another Trademark Scam - Preying on Unwitting Small Businesses. See: https://tmexpress.com/trademark-pearl-123023/
Sent December 14, 2023.
LegalZoom - Deceptive, Bait & Switch & Outright Dangerous Trademark Practices. See: https://tmexpress.com/legal-zoom-121423/
Sent October 28, 2023.
The Hidden Menace:
How Poor Trademark Practices Damage Small Businesses and Capitalism.
In the ever changing wild world of business, trademarks are more than just symbols or logos; they're the embodiment of a brand's identity, reputation and success.
Protecting these valuable assets is crucial for the continued growth of small businesses and the health of capitalism as a whole. Small business is the foundation of capitalism. It encourages innovation and generates substantial wealth. When small business works, capitalism thrives. Everyone wins.
However, trademark predatory practices, perpetuated by negligent attorneys, non-attorneys, and trademark mill services that fail to conduct comprehensive legal research and file subpar trademark applications, are undermining the very foundations of small business and capitalism itself.
When a small business is damaged from the very outset with bad advice, bad services to launch their very company name, then they are less likely to ever start another small business. Their friends and family will be intimidated from ever taking the risk of starting a new business. The cost to existing businesses to enforce their intellectual property against willfully ignorant infringers increases their costs to do business. It is all about trust.
My Zoom call with USPTO Commissioner David Gooder reiterated what I am writing about today. Recent USPTO practices over the last few years to fight fraud are continuing. I cite the USPTO demand for foreign based businesses to have a USA based attorney file their trademark, (as we provide our clients with our 6 of our 10 trademark attorneys from the USA), because of fraud from China. Also, the USPTO unilateral termination of over 21,000 trademarks in 2022, filed by trademark mill scam services because of fraud. I'd wager most of these business owners still do not know their trademark filings are dead. Additionally, ever increasing USPTO efforts to audit seemingly exaggerated trademark filings.
It is a fact the USPTO denies 39% of the trademark applications they receive.
TradeMark Express has not had a final trademark refusal since 2008.
Trademark Predatory Practices Unveiled
Trademark attorneys and services are vital for helping small businesses protect their intellectual property. They navigate the complex legal landscape of trademarks, where similarities in sound, appearance and meaning must be investigated because they do very much matter, ensuring that businesses can continue to grow and innovate without the fear of being refused by the USPTO or CIPO, ever receiving a cease and desist over the next 10 years and being able to easily enforce against others exploiting their brand.
However, there exists a darker side to this industry, where predatory practices thrive.
1. Inadequate Legal Research: Some attorneys and non-attorneys fail to conduct the thorough legal research necessary to confirm the availability of a trademark. This negligence often results in filing applications for trademarks that are confusingly similar to existing ones.
2. Trademark Mills: Some trademark services operate as "mills," processing applications en masse without due diligence, potentially leading to trademark disputes and legal actions for the businesses they are supposed to protect.
The Toll on Small Businesses
Small businesses are especially vulnerable to trademark predatory practices due to limited financial and time resources. When trademark applications are poorly prepared or trademarks are filed without proper legal research, the consequences can be devastating:
1. Legal Battles: Small businesses may become entangled in costly trademark disputes, with little financial room to wage these battles effectively.
2. Reputation Damage: A small business's reputation can be tarnished when it is perceived as the aggressor in a trademark dispute or as the negligent party when its trademark rights are violated.
3. Stifled Growth: Poorly filed trademark applications can result in delayed or denied trademark protection, hindering a small business's expansion.
Capitalism at Risk
The core of capitalism is built on competition, innovation, and the protection of property rights. Trademark predatory practices undermine this foundation:
1. Inhibiting Innovation: Small businesses are less likely to innovate and invest in their brands if they fear their efforts will be in vain due to predatory trademark practices.
2. Reducing Market Access: When predatory practices harm small businesses, it reduces competition, limiting consumers' choices and the overall health of the market.
3. Weakening Confidence: If the public perceives trademark disputes as commonplace and unfair, it erodes trust in the market system, undermining the very essence of capitalism.
Seeking a Solution
To protect small businesses and the principles of capitalism, we must address trademark predatory practices. Businesses, lawmakers, and consumers all play a role:
1. Businesses: Due diligence is crucial when seeking trademark protection. Small businesses should carefully choose reputable attorneys and trademark services with a proven track record of success.
2. Regulators: Legal authorities and trademark offices should enforce stricter standards for trademark applications, penalizing those who engage in predatory practices.
3. Consumer Awareness: By supporting businesses that value ethics and transparency, consumers can encourage responsible trademark practices and discourage predatory ones.
In a world where trademarks are integral to branding and success, protecting these assets is essential. Trademark predatory practices pose a real threat to small businesses and capitalism. By acknowledging this issue, taking proactive steps, and demanding accountability, we can preserve the integrity of the market and secure a fair and competitive business landscape for all.
Small businesses are the backbone of capitalism, and protecting them from predatory practices is essential for the system's continued vitality.
At TradeMark Express, we specialize in helping start-ups protect their intellectual property rights. Our team of skilled attorneys understands the intricacies of trademark law and can provide you with expert advice tailored to your business needs. We offer a range of services, including trademark registration, monitoring, and enforcement.
Don't risk leaving your brand unprotected. Start your new business venture with legal clarity by securing a trademark. Contact us today for a free expert trademark consultation. Together, let's build a strong foundation for your business's success.
Thank you!
===============================================================
Trademarks are company and product names, logos and slogans. They are way broader in coverage than a domain name search, a corporate name search or a web search on Google, Yahoo or Bing.
Rights go to those who use a mark first under Common Law and/or apply for a Federal or State trademark first.
Things that matter include SIMILARITIES in sound, appearance or meaning. Related goods/services. Channel of distribution. Customers. Famous names/marks. Over reaching litigious companies.
A legal comprehensive legal clearance Trademark and Common Law search can take 3 hours each. Trademark attorney review is needed.
Some people say - "I don't want a trademark!" Great, most companies do not need one. But to avoid a "failure to communicate", one must understand the 2 parts to a trademark. 1) Being LEGALLY CLEAR, under trademark law, and 2) Getting a Federal or State trademark. #1 every business needs - at least. #2 is advantageous as a mark gains ownership and broadens rights in sound, appearance and meaning.
Please note - The USPTO and CIPO expect this work done before filing any trademark, as by statute, they cannot for you. If another company has rights, then they have 10 years to enforce against you.
Trademark enforcement can be executed against infringers in a lot of ways, in addition to direct contact. Complaining where the infringer advertises - i.e. how they sell, where they sell - i.e. channels of distribution and where they manufacture. If their distribution crosses country borders, then a complaint to customs is effective for goods to be blocked or seized. If they have a trademark, a cancellation of their mark is an option. Where a complaint is disregarded, an attorney cease and desist has more power.
Being 100% sure your mark has rights over any infringer either under first use Common Law or your own registered or pending trademark is common sense. Being certain when they started using the mark is key. Competitive checks to ascertain reality are needed. The Internet Archive Wayback Machine is unparalleled. See: https://archive.org/web/.
Trademarks need to be enforced evenly. So, if you find one infringer, then you should run a comprehensive research to find if any more infringers exist in sound, appearance or meaning under trademark law. IF so, then your mark's rights need to be enforced against those companies as well. This is our 5-6 hour $400 Start-Up Package, including attorney research review and consultation. Remember, we have 10 trademark attorneys in our network included in our low fees. Attorney work to enforce is not included in our Start-Up Package.
The point is your trademarks have great value to your company. When you have a trademark you are accepting the duties and obligations of enforcement. If you neglect, then you slowly lose rights against infringers. This is called acquiescence. If you allow too many company's to infringe, then you make it harder to enforce. When you ever buy or sell a business, a strong trademark shores up its goodwill.
==============================================================
==============================================================
==============================================================
July 31, 2023 was our 31 Year Anniversary!
FACT - TradeMark Express has not had a final refusal at the USPTO in 16 years. We have never had a refusal in Canada, or any other country ever - in 30 years. Our work, and your heeding the advice of our network of 10 trademark attorneys has added up to ZERO trademark filing refusals at CIPO and the USPTO since 2008.
We wouldn't be the oldest, most successful trademarking service in North America without your business.
We also seem to be the last trademark service including some inexperienced trademark attorneys, who believe in ACTUAL COMPREHENSIVE legal research to determine if your trademark is LEGALLY CLEAR, before use and before filing any trademark application - just like the USPTO expects. Yes, this legal research work is needed - even if not trademarking. Trademarking is advantageous, but every mark must be LEGALLY CLEAR, based on trademark law.
IF a comprehensive clearance legal research report isn't 600-800 pages, then it simply is not done. When enough research strategies are done correctly, and enough databases are correctly accessed, then and only then will there be a sizable enough report to prove If any given mark is LEGALLY CLEAR or not.
The problem for most firms is that they rely way too heavily upon an exact name search on the Internet, and maybe a direct hit search on the CIPO or USPTO web sites.
They may have been infringing upon some other firms rights in the first place because comprehensive clearance legal research wasn't run before first use, or business start-up. I believe a vast majority of small businesses are totally unaware of the risk they take when they do not do a full legal search.
At a time when MANY competitors and attorneys are shying away from doing comprehensive clearance research, from what used to be a 100% practice in 2010, TradeMark Express has chosen to increase its talent in this critical area.
Additionally, we will continue to call out the negligent competitors who sell trademark "application only" services, based on light Google and direct hit TESS searches, including unethical attorneys who do not keep the promise to their clients to protect their best interests. Former USPTO Commissioner David Gooder called these people "trademark mills", who "damage" their clients.
It is wonderful to come to work without fear of an angry phone call when a trademark is refused, like our competitors tolerate every day just for their quick application only sales. BEWARE of "TRADEMARK MILLS", as described by USPTO Commissioner David Gooder, on a conference call with me on June 11, 2021.
Thank you! Chris DeMassa 650-948-0530 / Marcela & Erica 202-496-1600 / Heather 714-401-3030
|