Stone Soup Theatre Company's Production
of The Crucible Is Powerful and Compelling

"A compelling production and the haunting atmosphere of Chapel Hill's historic
Forest Theatre, brings a chilling relevance to this American masterpiece."

We like to believe that human beings are reasonable creatures, that facts will ultimately prevail over falsehoods, and that justice is blind. We want to believe that when confronted with the truth, reasonable people will recognize it and act accordingly. Unfortunately, history tells us otherwise; and Arthur Miller's The Crucible reminds us just how readily we abandon reason when truth threatens our ambitions, our prejudices, or our carefully constructed notions of ourselves.

Stone Soup Theatre Company's ambitious production of this American classic, performed in the atmospheric surroundings of Chapel Hill's historic Forest Theatre, is a powerful reminder that the forces behind the Salem Witch Trials of 1692 are very much alive today. Greed, jealousy, corruption, the hunger for power, and the desperate need to conceal our guilt remain potent human motivators. We simply become more sophisticated at disguising them beneath the modern banners of patriotism, religious conviction, moral outrage, and partisan politics.

Written in 1953, during the height of U.S. Sen. Joseph McCarthy's anti-communist crusade, The Crucible uses the Salem Witch Trials as an allegory for the political persecution and public hysteria of Miller's own time. But the play's extraordinary endurance comes from its understanding of something far more fundamental than any particular political movement: the human capacity to manipulate the truth and, perhaps, more dangerously, to convince ourselves that our own manufactured version of reality is the truth.

In Salem, accusations become evidence, rumor becomes fact, and the mere suggestion of wrongdoing is enough to destroy a reputation or take a life. Once the machinery of public hysteria begins to operate, it becomes almost impossible to stop. Those who question the accusations become suspects themselves, while those who acknowledge their errors risk losing their authority, their reputations, and their power.

Does any of this sound familiar?

Our modern world may seem far removed from 17th century Puritan Massachusetts, but our 24-hour news cycle, social media, and increasingly polarized political culture have created an environment in which rumors, misinformation, and accusations can travel around the world before anyone pauses to examine the facts. Outrage becomes entertainment, allegations become convictions in the court of public opinion; and entire careers, reputations, and causes can be consumed by the flames of a modern witch hunt. Too often, the search for truth becomes secondary to the satisfaction of seeing an enemy destroyed.

Director Lindsey Womack has assembled an exceptionally large cast for this production, and one of her most impressive achievements is the way these many performers work together as a cohesive ensemble. Miller's play is populated by a community of ordinary individuals, not heroes and villains, but people we recognize with competing loyalties, grievances, fears, and ambitions. Her decision to have the audience seated on the Forest Theatre stage with the actors was inventive and intimate. It draws the audience in as fellow members of the Salem community, surrounded by the dark forest of atmospheric fear.

Among the production's most compelling performances is Alyssa Krasovich's Abigail Williams, whose personal deceptions set the tragedy in motion. Krasovich takes us on a fascinating journey as Abigail evolves from an apparently vulnerable servant girl into something approaching a local celebrity, intoxicated by the extraordinary power that her accusations have given her. Initially motivated by jealousy and self-preservation, Abigail discovers that she can control the behavior of adults, manipulate powerful men, and command the attention of an entire community. As her influence grows, so does her appetite for it.

What makes Krasovich's performance especially chilling is the suggestion that Abigail eventually begins to believe her own mythology. What starts as a deliberate lie becomes a kind of self-created madness in which she loses the ability or, perhaps, the desire, to distinguish between deception and reality. It is an unsettling portrait of what can happen when attention, adulation, and unchecked influence transform a manipulator into a true believer in her own manufactured importance.

And where do we see this today?

Eric Bates creates a wonderfully loathsome Rev. Samuel Parris, a minister whose supposed devotion to God is somewhat less that his devotion to himself. His vanity, insecurity, and desperate concern for his own position make him particularly susceptible to supporting whatever version of events best protects his reputation. Bates portrays a man who wraps self-interest in the language of religious duty, revealing how easily faith can become a convenient shield for ambition and moral cowardice.

Joseph Perdue delivers another standout performance as the Rev. John Hale, perhaps the most tragic of the play's authority figures. Hale arrives in Salem as an earnest, confident expert, convinced that his education and religious knowledge will help him identify and eradicate evil. Instead, he becomes an unwitting catalyst for the unfolding terror. Perdue beautifully captures Hale's gradual realization that the very authority that he trusted, and his own unquestioning participation in it, have helped to unleash a catastrophe.

As the enormity of his mistakes becomes clear, Hale experiences profound remorse and desperately attempts to stop the forces that he has helped set in motion. Unlike the other authorities, Hale eventually possesses the humility and courage to confront the evidence, acknowledge his errors, and attempt to correct them. But by then, the machinery of persecution has acquired a momentum of its own. Hale's transformation offers one of the production's most moving demonstrations of the difference between genuine moral conviction and blind certainty.

Art Jolin gives an equally fascinating performance as Deputy-Governor Thomas Danforth, the man who ultimately bears the greatest responsibility for the judicial atrocities. Rather than portraying Danforth as a conventional villain, Jolin initially presents him as reasonable, composed, and even somewhat likable. He appears to be a man genuinely committed to the orderly administration of justice.

And that is precisely what makes him so frightening.

Danforth does not recognize himself as corrupt. He sees himself as the embodiment of justice, and his faith in the righteousness of the court is absolute. When evidence begins to reveal that innocent people have been condemned, he cannot acknowledge the possibility that the proceedings have been fundamentally wrong. To do so would undermine not only the authority of the court but his own identity as a righteous man.

His solution is to preserve the institution, regardless of the human cost. The evidence must conform to the verdicts, rather than the verdicts to the evidence. Jolin's carefully measured performance reveals how a seemingly reasonable individual can become the instrument of terrible injustice, when the preservation of authority becomes more important than the pursuit of truth. With the support of the sycophantic Judge John Hathorne, played with a comic touch by Gerald Rubin, Danforth's self-righteousness becomes far more dangerous than Abigail's original lies, because it gives those lies the full force of the law.

At the emotional center of the story is John Proctor, convincingly portrayed by Matthew Hurley, a respected farmer whose earlier affair with Abigail has left him burdened by guilt and struggling to reclaim his integrity. His wife, Elizabeth, in a strong performance by Blythe Meyer, must confront her own pain and loss in the struggle for forgiveness. Their troubled marriage gives Miller's larger political drama a deeply personal foundation. Proctor's eventual refusal to sign a false confession provides the play with its defining moral confrontation: whether preserving one's life is worth surrendering one's name and one's truth. This is a concept that almost seems quixotic and absurd in today's world.

The substantial supporting cast, including Udaya Vakati as Mary Warren, Dave Durham as Giles Corey, and Linda Shillito as Rebecca Nurse, contributes greatly to the production's convincing portrait of an entire community unraveling under the weight of suspicion and fear.

One of Miller's greatest achievements is his refusal to suggest that evil always announces itself in an easily recognizable form. His characters rarely think of themselves as wicked. They believe that they are defending their community, protecting their faith, preserving public order, or acting in the service of justice. Their professed motives may be noble; but beneath them lie the familiar human frailties of ambition, fear, jealousy, prejudice, and self-preservation.

And therein lies the great danger, both in Salem and in our own society.

We frequently assume that injustice results from a failure to discover the truth. But The Crucible demonstrates something far more disturbing: Sometimes, the truth is available, yet those with the power to act upon it find it inconvenient, threatening, or intolerable. They manipulate it, suppress it, or construct elaborate explanations for why it cannot possibly be true.

The modern machinery of public outrage makes this tendency even more dangerous. We have become extraordinarily efficient at spreading accusations and creating villains, but not necessarily any better at distinguishing fact from fiction. Political leaders, media personalities, religious authorities, and ordinary citizens alike can find themselves rewarded for reinforcing convenient narratives rather than challenging them. And once we have publicly committed ourselves to a particular version of events, admitting that we were wrong can feel more threatening than perpetuating the falsehood.

Stone Soup Theatre Company has given us a compelling production of a demanding American masterpiece. More than 70 years after Miller wrote it, The Crucible remains painfully relevant. We may congratulate ourselves on having progressed beyond the superstitions of Salem; but our susceptibility to fear, our appetite for scandal, and our willingness to sacrifice reason in defense of cherished beliefs suggest otherwise.

Perhaps, the most frightening lesson of The Crucible is not that people can be persuaded to believe lies. It is that once those lies serve their interests, reinforce their prejudices, or protect their power, they may no longer care whether they are true.

And that is when the witch hunt begins.

Arthur Miller's THE CRUCIBLE (In Person at 7:30 p.m. Friday and Saturday and 2:30 p.m. Sunday, Oct. 11 and 16-18), directed by Lindsey Womack and starring Matthew Hurley as John Proctor, Alyssa Krasovich as Abigail Williams, Blythe Meyer as Elizabeth Proctor, Joseph Perdue as the Rev. John Hale, Eric Bates as the Rev. Samuel Parris, Art Jolin as Deputy-Governor Thomas Danforth, Udaya Vakati as Mary Warren, Dave Durham as Giles Corey, Linda Shillito as Rebecca Nurse, Gianluca Corinaldesi as Francis Nurse, John Shelton as Thomas Putnam, Susan Clarke as Ann Putnam, Layla Zeferino as Tituba, Katie McRae as Susanna Walcott, Lauren Rymer as Betty Parris, Loren Wait as Mercy Lewis, Elijah Wilde as Ezekiel Cheever, Greg Wait as Marshal John Willard, Gerald Rubin as Judge John Hathorne, Katie McRae as Sarah Good, Susan Clarke as Ruth Putnam, and Wren Brun as a Youth of Salem, (Stone Soup Theatre Company in UNC-Chapel Hill's Forest Theatre at 123 S. Boundary St.). PRESENTER: https://www.stonesouptheatreco.com/, https://www.facebook.com/StoneSoupTheatreCo/, https://www.instagram.com/stonesouptheatreco/, and https://www.tiktok.com/@stonesouptheatre. 2026-27 SEASON: https://www.stonesouptheatreco.com/current-season/. VENUE: https://ncbg.unc.edu/venue/forest-theatre/ and https://ncbg.unc.edu/visit/battle-park-forest-theatre/. DIRECTIONS: https://www.google.com/maps/. PARKING: https://maps.unc.edu/parking/forest-theatre-parking-lot/. THE CRUCIBLE (1953 Broadway drama): http://www.ibiblio.org/miller/works.html, https://www.ibdb.com/broadway-show/the-crucible-2847, https://www.britannica.com/topic/The-Crucible, and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Crucible. THE SCRIPT: http://books.google.com/. STUDY GUIDE: http://www.us.penguingroup.com/static/pdf/teachersguides/crucible.pdf (Penguin Group). ARTHUR MILLER (American dramatist, screenwriter, and essayist, nee Arthur Asher Miller, 1915-2005): https://www.arthurmiller.org/, https://arthurmillersociety.net/, https://arthurmillerfoundation.org/, https://www.ibdb.com/broadway-cast-staff/arthur-miller-4316, http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0007186/, https://www.britannica.com/biography/Arthur-Miller-American-playwright, and http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arthur_Miller. TICKETS: $32.30 ($27.05 students), plus taxes. Click here to buy tickets. INFORMATION: info@stonesouptheatreco.com. PLEASE DONATE TO: Stone Soup Theatre Company.

WHAT: Triangle Review is a FREE weekly e-mail performing-arts and film newsletter, edited and published by Robert W. McDowell since August 2001.

TO SUBSCRIBE: To start your FREE subscription today, sign up in the subscription box at the beginning of this e-mail; or e-mail RobertM748@aol.com and type SUBSCRIBE-TR in the Subject: line. TO UNSUBSCRIBE: E-mail RobertM748@aol.com and type UNSUBSCRIBE-TR in the Subject: line.

QUESTIONS OR COMMENTS? E-mail all questions, comments, and Letters to the Editor to RobertM748@aol.com. For Letters to the Editor, please include a daytime telephone number in your e-mail.

COPYRIGHT: Editorial content in all formats © 2026 Triangle Review and the author of each article. Reproduction in any form without authorization of Triangle Review and the respective authors is prohibited. Triangle Review maintains an archive of past issues. To request copies of past articles and/or issues, e-mail RobertM748@aol.com.