May 15, 2025


Update on Billy and Tina

&

Reminder:

Call to Action for Four Bills!

Today, a Los Angeles County judge denied an emergency motion to halt the transfer of Billy and Tina, the last two elephants at the Los Angeles Zoo, to the Tulsa Zoo in Oklahoma. The motion was part of a lawsuit filed by an L.A. resident advocating for the elephants to be relocated to an animal sanctuary instead. The judge determined that the matter should be addressed by city officials rather than the court, encouraging concerned parties to engage with the City Council and the mayor's office.


CALL TO ACTION FOR LA RESIDENTS:


Please call and/or email the Mayor & your City Councilmember as soon as possible and tell them to send the elephants to a sanctuary! The elephants could be shipped out at any moment!


Find their contact information : https://lacity.gov/directory#elected-officials


Angelenos have long criticized the L.A. Zoo's elephant enclosure, citing its limited space and potential health implications for the animals. The zoo decided to transfer Billy and Tina following the death of another elephant, Shaunzi, which left the zoo below the Association of Zoos and Aquariums' (AZA) requirement of housing at least three Asian elephants. The Tulsa Zoo, their intended destination, offers a larger habitat and a social group of five other Asian elephants, but it's just another zoo. (Los Angeles Times)


The lawsuit, supported by declarations from public figures like singer Cher, argues that the decision to transfer the elephants lacked public input and transparency. Despite the legal setback, the plaintiff's legal team plans to continue pursuing the case.


“Billy and Tina have served their time in confinement,” Cher said in the declaration. “They deserve the chance to live out their lives in peace and dignity.”


L.A. Zoo officials maintain that the relocation is in the best interest of the elephants' welfare, but have thus far failed to give any reasoning behind their opinion, which is concerning considering a sanctuary is available to take both elephants.


Many civil rights and civic-minded groups that have nothing to do with animal rights are speaking out in support of sending the elephants to a sanctuary. The Congress of Racial Equality of California, the Multicultural Bar Alliance of Southern California, and the Italian-American Lawyers Association to name just a few.


Also, below is a fantastic letter just submitted by the Los Angeles Bar Association's Animal Law Section in support of sending the elephants to a sanctuary, not a zoo. Click on the picture below to read the entire document. The letter reflects the various non-animal rights groups and individuals who can clearly see that the best place for elephants is either in the wild, or at a sanctuary where they can act out their natural behavior as much as possible.

And finally, if you have not seen the interaction between the LA Zoo Director and Councilmember Blumenfield where she tells him it is not the purview of the City Council whether to send Billy to a zoo or not, please click the video below.


Today's ruling by the judge contradicted the Zoo Director by indicating that the City Council is exactly where the decision should be made.

REMINDER: CALL TO ACTION!


The fate of four SCIL-sponsored bills are being decided in their respective Appropriations Committees.


Please call the Chairs, Vice Chairs, and if you have time, all of the Committee Members below!


We have three bills in the Assembly Appropriations Committee. When you call, please ask them to support the following:


  1. AB 347 (Kalra) The CLASS Act, a bill to strengthen students' rights to opt-out of animal dissection.
  2. AB 478 (Zbur), The FOUND Act, a bill to ensure cities/counties have plans and procedures for pet evacuation.
  3. AB 1482 (Castillo), Bowie's Law, a bill to expand breeder regulations and ensure shelters post adoptable animals online.


Assembly Appropriations Committee Members:


Buffy Wicks (Chair)

(916) 319-2014

 

Kate Sanchez (Vice Chair)

(916) 319-2071

 

Dr. Joaquin Arambula

(916) 319-2031

 

Lisa Calderon

(916) 319-2056

 

Jessica Caloza

(916) 319-2052

 

Diane Dixon

(916) 319-2072

 

Sade Elhawary

(916) 319-2057


Mike Fong

(916) 319-2049


Mark Gonzalez

(916) 319-2054

 

Gregg Hart

(916) 319-2037

 

Blanca Pacheco

(916) 319-2064

 

Gail Pellerin

(916) 319-2028


José Luis Solache Jr.

(916) 319-2062


Tri Ta

(916) 319-2070

 

David J. Tangipa

(916) 319-2008

For our Senate bill, SB 221 (Ochoa Bogh), which will include threats to pets, emotional support and service animals, and horses in our state's stalking law, please call the Senators below and urge their support.


Senate Appropriations Committee Members:


Anna Caballero (Chair)

(916) 651-4014

 

Kelly Seyarto (Vice Chair)

(916) 651-4032


Christopher Cabaldon

(916) 651-4003

 

Megan Dahle

(916) 651-4001


Tim Grayson

(916) 651-4009

 

Laura Richardson

(916) 651-4035


Aisha Wahab

(916) 651-4410

Your support is vital to our mission. Your contribution plays a significant role in driving meaningful change and advancing our cause. We are deeply grateful for your ongoing support and together, we can make a lasting impact for the animals who need us most. Thank you for being a part of our community!

Judie Mancuso, founder/CEO/president

Social Compassion, 501(c)(3)

Social Compassion in Legislation, 501(c)(4)

Other ways to support our group: Buy our book and shop our store!

See what's happening on our social sites

Facebook  Instagram  LinkedIn