Village Council Votes "No" on Bridge and PB Looks for Members to Join Connectivity Committee

Village Council Votes "No" on Bridge

February 9, 2021

Village of Palmetto Bay

Following an unprecedented number of comments and public outcry from Palmetto Bay residents, the Village Council reiterated its long-standing position on the construction of a bridge on SW 87th Avenue from SW 164th Street to SW 163rd Terrace.

Palmetto Bay residents have been fighting against the county's plan to increase capacity on SW 87th Avenue since the Village incorporated. In 2003, the Council adopted Resolution No. 03-22 opposing the widening of SW 87th Avenue. When the issue resurfaced in 2016, the Council passed Resolution No. 2016-89 rejecting any modifications to SW 87th Avenue and SW 77th Avenue, including bridges.

During last night's hybrid Special Council Meeting, hundreds of concerned Village residents flooded the virtual meeting lobby, sent hundreds of electronic comments, came to speak in person, and commented on the Village's Facebook page where the meeting was being shown live to speak on the issue. The overwhelming majority, 80.3%, spoke in opposition of the bridge citing concerns over additional traffic congestion, cut-through traffic on neighborhood streets, neighborhood safety, and an overall decline in quality of life if the bridge were to be built. 19.6% of the speakers commented in favor.

The bridge controversy resurfaced after District 8 County Commissioner Danielle Cohen Higgins, who represents the Village of Palmetto Bay and the Town of Cutler Bay, presented an item before the Board of County Commissioners (BCC) last Tuesday, February 2nd directing the County Mayor to "take all actions necessary to construct a bridge" over the C-100 canal, extending SW 87th Avenue from SW 164th Street to SW 163rd Terrace. The County's resolution also called for the appropriation of $3,100,0000 in funds from unencumbered road impact fees and to identify other funding sources as necessary to implement the project.

The move came without any prior warning to Palmetto Bay officials. As a result, the item was heard by the BCC and passed without any feedback from the Palmetto Bay community. Mayor Cunningham, who called the Special Council meeting and sponsored the two resolutions on the agenda opposing the county's action on the bridge, provided her reasons for calling the Special Meeting, indicating that the most important component to her is "the public outreach and giving the community the opportunity to speak." Mayor Cunningham clarified that although the Village Council cannot vote on any action regarding the construction of the bridge, the resolutions solidify the Village's position on the matter.

After hearing public comments for almost 3 hours, the Village Council unanimously moved to adopt the resolutions on the meeting agenda requesting that the Board of County Commissioners reconsider their action and postpone the meeting of the Transportation Planning Organization to consider the BCC's action. The resolution also urges County Mayor Daniella Levine Cava to veto the resolution passed by the BCC on February 2, 2021. A second resolution was also adopted requesting deferral of the item from the TPO to a later date to "allow the Village Council, Village Manager and Village Residents to voice their concerns over an issue that dramatically affects the safety and quality of life of the neighborhood residents." In addition, the Council introduced an add on item seeking to initiate Florida's Conflict Resolution Procedure as provided in Section 164.1052 of the Florida Statutes for the following reasons:

(i) The [County] Resolution violates Section 1.02 of the Charter of Miami- Dade County which requires the appropriation of funds shall be by Ordinance. The Resolution at Section 3 specifically states that the Board is appropriating $3.1 million for the design and construction of the Bridge.

(ii) By not adopting the measure by Ordinance, it violates the County’s notice requirements for the adoption of Ordinances.

(iii) The County’s reliance on Ordinance 20-38 authorizing the waiver of procedural requirements, including but not limited to the 3 and 4 day rules, is inapplicable as the Ordinance applies to emergency measures, and the bridging of 87^th does not “meet a public emergency affecting life, health, property or public safety”.

(iv) As stated in the Memorandum of May 5, 2020, which is also relied upon for what is an improper Resolution, it specifically states that Ordinance 20-38 is meant to “expedite certain processes and procedures that directly affect the acquisition of goods and services”. The construction of a bridge is no such thing.

Village Attorney John Dellagloria explained that by Florida Statute, a conflict resolution proceeding is required to resolve governmental conflict before any litigation action is taken. The next step is for representatives of both the County and the Village to meet and reach an agreement on the issue. If that option does not work, a public meeting is held to discuss the options.

The Mayor & Council voted to hold the meeting on Wednesday, February 24, 2021 at Village Hall.

Mayor to Appoint 4 Members to the Community Connectivity Committee

At the onset of the Special Council Meeting, Mayor Cunningham read a letter sent to her and to the Cutler Bay Mayor by County Commissioner Cohen Higgins. In the letter, Commissioner Cohen Higgins explains her plan to organize a Community Connectivity Committee composed of eight members, with the municipal Mayors of Palmetto Bay and Cutler Bay appointing four members each. The purpose of the committee is to engage in meaningful discussion and provide insight on the opposing viewpoints for the TPO's consideration. Appointee names must be provided to the Commissioner by February 10, 2021.

The committee will meet virtually on February 11th, February 18th, February 25th, and March 4th at 7 pm. At the conclusion of said meetings, the committee is to prepare a report outlining its position. Said report is to be presented to the Transportation Planning Organization (TPO) for consideration before the item is heard by the TPO Board.

During the Special Council Meeting last night, Mayor Cunningham announced her first appointee to be Village Manager Nick Marano who is well versed on the facts surrounding the bridge issue. If you are interested in being part of the Community Connectivity Committee, please click below to apply online no later than noon, Wednesday, February 10, 2021.

Apply Online

If you missed the Special Council meeting last night, you may watch it online or on our Facebook page. Please stay tuned for any further developments. Encourage your friends and neighbors to subscribe to our newsletter to receive updates, news and other information from the Village.

#PalmettoBayProud #Protect PB

Visit our website

You are receiving this email because you have expressed an interest in Village of Palmetto Bay. Please add [email protected] to your address book to be sure that we land in your inbox.

Public Records Disclosure: Florida has very broad public records laws. Most written communications to or from local officials regarding official business are public records available to the public and media upon request. Your e-mail may therefore be subject to public disclosure, if requested.