Key Questions City Hall Must Answer
Affordable Housing
How will this plan guarantee affordable housing rather than simply incentivizing luxury and market-rate units that drive prices higher?
Speculation & Land Banking
What protections will prevent speculative development, parcel accumulation, and land banking that fuel displacement and rising costs?
Demolitions
How will the plan safeguard existing rent-controlled housing and protect tenants from eviction under Ellis Act loopholes? You can not upzone without first tearing down existing affordable housing.
Small Business Displacement
What measures will protect small businesses and entire merchant corridors from being wiped out by demolitions, high-rises, and years of construction disruption?
Infrastructure
How will schools, transit, utilities, and public safety keep pace with increased density, and who will pay for the necessary upgrades?
Historic & Cultural Resources
How will San Francisco’s landmarks, Category A buildings, and cultural districts be protected from irreversible damage?
Housing Element vs. Lurie’s Plan
Why does Mayor Lurie’s upzoning proposal create capacity for 800,000 new units, when the 2022 approved Housing Element and its certified Environmental Impact Report planned for 140,000? Why are residents now faced with six different maps that overhaul land-use policy citywide instead of the single original map?
State Bills
How will this plan interact with Scott Wiener’s SB-79 and other pending state legislation if signed into law? Will it strip away even more local control? If exemptions are promised, are they enforceable or merely conditional?
Accountability
What binding mechanisms will hold developers to their commitments for community benefits, not just vague promises?
Neighborhood Input
How will resident voices truly shape the plan? How will neighbors be notified when projects are proposed, and how can they have a real say in how those projects proceed?
Population Projections
How does the city justify massive upzoning when the State Department of Finance projects flat or minimal population growth through 2050? Why are elected officials saying “our hands are tied” instead of showing true leadership and fighting on behalf of San Franciscans?
Permanent Change
Once neighborhoods are upzoned, the change is permanent and irreversible. What guarantees exist that these decisions won’t worsen affordability and displacement? Why isn’t there a staged approach, or a safeguard clause, to stop or reverse the plans if developers abuse it?
|