If you are reading this on a social media platform, feel free to subscribe and you'll automatically receive either a fascinating story or a boring one every week. I have no idea what happens when I press SEND.
|
|
Joe's Positive Post of the Week
|
|
“Every important change in our society, for the good, at least, has taken place because of popular pressure-pressure from below, from the great mass of people.”- Edward Abbey.
Edward Abbey was an American author and essayist remarkably known for his advocacy of environmental issues, public land policies and anarchist political views. Abbey was known for writing about the world and the effects of civilization on American land.
|
|
Leading Off: A Very Cincinnati Story
|
|
Advocacy means different things to different people, and today, equity and equality are in the news a great deal. Advocating for fairness, at least to me, supersedes all other kinds of advocacy, it is a crusade.
This story is about a time my son and I advocated for change, for a fair outcome, and left behind a benefit that hundreds or maybe even thousands of people in the past 20 years have enjoyed. It is also a story of mismanagement, but that is less important with more obvious lessons.
That's the thing about change, once it's changed, it's changed. As you will see, we started out simply wanting to go to a football game in a new stadium. We weren’t being treated fairly, so we did something about it with a lot of help from others who used their resources and commitment to fairness to make a difference.
The key lessons in the following narrative? I think it is that when it is 'only a job' motivation is not always enough, but when it is your life, motivation usually is more than enough. The object is to get to the goal line, to finish the drive.
|
|
In the summer of 2000, the Cincinnati Bengals were about to open a brand-new stadium, a gift from the taxpayers of Hamilton County in Ohio, as an incentive to stay in Cincinnati. Threatening to leave town was a pretty popular business model for NFL teams in the 1990’s.
As local residents, we followed the ballot measure, the funding, the construction, and eagerly awaited the first exhibition game so we could see inside the multi-million-dollar edifice. (Apologies, but I’ve always wanted to use the word ‘edifice’ in a sentence and now I can cross it off my bucket list.)
Because my son uses a wheelchair to get around, we have been in the habit of pre-scouting everywhere we go for the first time: restaurants, venues, and stadiums. We look first for parking and then for overall accessibility. Imagine our surprise when we learned that there was no handicapped parking for this brand-new stadium! See, you are surprised too, and you probably have half the knowledge of the Americans with Disabilities Act that we possess.
(The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, prohibit discrimination on the basis of disability in admission or access to, or in the administration of, programs, services, and activities for the public.)
|
|
The situation was that the stadium was built on public land and managed by the Bengals. The parking lots around the stadium were also on county land but managed separately. Following me so far?
The county (or the Bengals, I’m not sure which), sold Season Parking Passes with their Season Tickets and if there were 100 spaces in a lot, they sold 100 Season Parking Passes, without regard to handicapped parking. That’s right, the right number of handicapped spaces were painted on the asphalt, but not available to handicapped fans and used by fans without placards or license plates. 100 spaces = 100 season parking passes without regard to disability status.
The team’s theme was ‘Welcome to the Jungle’ but it appeared that those with disabilities were ‘Unwelcome in the Jungle.’
|
|
Having lots of experience at being underestimated, I went right to work
- I called the Bengals to describe the issue. They said they couldn’t help me the because the county controlled the parking. We could park in a downtown garage instead, I was told.
- I called the county commissioners office. They couldn’t help me, the parking passes had all been sold. I could park in a downtown garage instead, they told me.
- I called the Attorney General for the State of Ohio. His office couldn’t help me, in his mind it wasn’t an ADA issue. (They were incorrect).
- I called the National Football League Offices in New York City. They couldn’t help me, they said it was a local matter and referred me to the Bengals.
-
I called the Department of Justice in Washington DC, multiple offices. They couldn’t help me either, but I don't remember why, it might have been because no discrimination had taken place yet. I thought if I called them back after a few games I might be able to make a case.
- I called many people back, hoping to get a different voice and a different answer, all to no avail. (<--Great phrase 'to no avail' don't you think?)
- I called…you get the picture. Anyone and everyone I could think of. The more I called and was NOT helped, the more determined I became. Ok, the more angry I became as well.
And if you know me, you also know that I kept a meticulous log of the two-dozen people I spoke to: date, time, and response. The local ABC Television station really appreciated my recordkeeping when I provided my log to them, but I’m getting ahead of myself.
I called the Bengals one more time, because a friend had a contact there, and if you can’t come in through the front door, I a side door is good, before you knock the doors down.
I happened to be donating blood when the Bengals called me back. In the spirit of compromise, I suggested to this executive that if there were no more spaces, that perhaps a remote lot or a downtown garage with a shuttle to the stadium would work well, just like the University of Cincinnati used for their events to accommodate handicapped parkers.
When the he told me that they wouldn’t do that because we’d blame them if we missed the kick-off, little did he know the fuse he ignited or that the blood tech had to grab my arm to keep the needle in.
I told him he didn’t have a chance. When he asked what I meant, I simply said: “to you, it’s only a job, but to us, it’s our life. You’ll give up. We won’t.”
Remember, news of the stadium opening was THE big news in Cincinnati, and everyone talked about it all the time: at lunch, at social events, on sports talk radio, it was everywhere. I personally had three rather innocent conversations that turned out to have a big impact.
|
|
First, I was talking to the General Manager of a local radio station. He knew my son used a wheelchair and when I told him what I had been up to he volunteered to have the station rent a parking lot and provide a shuttle to the games as a public service. Of course, I agreed, and of course, I went on the radio and talked about the issue and thanked them for their generosity. WARM-98. Dan Swenson. A great guy who created the first domino.
|
|
Second, I was having lunch with one of my company’s vendors, who happened to be a heavy advertiser on the market’s premier sports talk radio station, including the afternoon drive-time program, hosted by Andy Furman. He gave me the station’s private call-in number and told me to reach out to Andy (currently heard nationally on Fox Sports Radio), and arrange a time to come on his show and tell the story. JTM FoodGroup. Tony Maas. A great guy who set up the next domino.
|
|
Third, the President and General Manager of the ABC station, Channel 9, was on a non-profit board with me, and in casual conversation I mentioned the situation and he thought it would be a good topic for his investigative group, the I-Team, to take on as a project. When I told him about my documentation, that sealed the deal. WCPO. Bill Fee. A very big domino was set up.
|
|
Here’s how the dominos were knocked down:
The parking lot that the radio station donated went into effect for the second game. It was used and reported on. People seemed happy with the solution, and I think the Hamilton County commissioners and the Bengals may have crossed this ‘issue’ off their list of problems as ‘solved.’ Not so fast.
Next, I was booked on drive time sports talk radio show on WLW to call in for a 10-minute segment. I had the private number that guests use to call in: it was very cool.
|
|
Much to my surprise, the host started taking calls and before I knew it, my ten-minute segment turned into a 90-minute talk-fest with callers, ranging from wounded veterans, to senior citizens, to other disabled families, checking in, and of course supporting the cause. You could feel the momentum building. Lots of people who knew me, heard me and reached out. Shortly after that, Channel 9 did an introductory piece to their investigative ‘series.' It outlined the issue, the problem, and some of my efforts.
8-Days in October
Sunday
That next Sunday, I met a videographer at the television station, he hopped in the passenger seat of my van, and during the game, when the lots were packed, I talked my way into every single parking lot around the stadium and he captured on video either empty handicapped spaces that could have been used, or even better/worse (take your pick) video clips of cars in handicapped spaces that didn’t have a placard or a plate authorizing the use of such a space.
|
|
Monday
When that story ran on Monday night during the 6 and 11 newscasts, the fan started spinning, if you know what I mean, and I knew it was just a matter of time.
Tuesday
On Tuesday, a Cincinnati newspaper called me and wanted us to come to the stadium for an interview and photo for a story to run later that week.
|
|
Wednesday
Wednesday, a high county official called me after the whirlwind of publicity: it continued to be a hot topic on sports talk radio every day and the TV station was promoting the 'I-Team' Investigation around the clock.
I remember our conversation like it was yesterday because I was a little over the line on the belligerence scale. Remember: it was our life, and just his job.
-
Important Official: "We are trying to work with you, but all the publicity is causing a problem."
-
Me-Just a Dad: "Problem? You’ll soon be spelling problem: C-N-N."
-
Important Official: "C-N-N?"
-
Me-Just a Dad: "Yes, if this isn’t resolved, I will arrange for hundreds of wheelchairs to ring the stadium at the next home game. That will be on CNN, and then you will really have a problem."
I don't really know why I said that, or where it came from. What I knew was that it was time to fix the problem.
|
|
Thursday
The next day, I got a call from the same official who wanted to share with me that the Suite Holder lot on Second Street at Pete Rose Way, the one closest to the stadium, would be converted to a Handicapped Parking Lot before the next game. With 100 spaces. It was the next to the last domino. (Penultimate? Is that the right word?)
Friday
The newspaper story ran on Friday, and instead of more advocacy, it was more of a victory or celebration article.
Saturday
I had a lot of email appreciation, and of course the topic was still buzzing on sports talk radio.
Sunday
On game-day, we loaded up our van, and brought friends and family to tailgate in the new lot. Dan Swenson from WARM 98 stopped by, and I think Bill Fee from Channel 9 visited as well. The TV station may even have done a recap story.
While tailgating I called the pre-game show, hosted by Andy Furman, thanked him live on the air and shared the good news. He said they should name the lot the Ed Doherty Memorial Lot. I told him I was still alive but thanked him again for his help. WLW. Andy Furman, advocate for fairness.
Today
To this day, that lot remains in use for those in wheelchairs, disabled men, women, and children, and those who just can’t walk that far, and the phrase ‘Welcome to the Jungle’ continues to apply to all fans.
|
|
Surprise Clipping at the End:
|
|
Thanks for reading and thanks for referring.
The honor roll now stands at 39 Members and my wife is still impressed: Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Massachusetts, Michigan, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Puerto Rico, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Vermont, Virginia, Washington and Washington DC, plus Canada, Spain, Conch Republic, Australia and the United Kingdom
|
|
|
Ed Doherty
774-479-8831
www.ambroselanden.com
ed-doherty@outlook.com
Forgive any typos please.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|