Click here for an online version that you can share on social media

Steve Sheffey's Pro-Israel Political Update

Calling balls and strikes for the pro-Israel community since 2006

November 8, 2026


Key Developments and What We're Discussing Today:


  • The next Congress will include a handful of Democrats whose views on Israel might concern us, but the next Congress will include a Democratic caucus with a larger majority of traditionally pro-Israel Democrats than the Democratic caucus in the current Congress.


  • The two biggest threats to the U.S.- Israel relationship will remain in office: Donald Trump and JD Vance. If the GOP elects Jim Jordan as House Minority Leader, they will have learned nothing.


  • 72% of Jewish voters voted Democratic in the last election. Maybe someone forgot to tell them that they are politically homeless.


  • Many polls of Jewish voters are methodologically unsound. It is important to understand how to distinguish reliable polls from unreliable polls.


  • The views of our friends and text groups, as well as what we see on social media and in the Jewish press, are not necessarily representative of the broader Jewish community. We do research because we cannot rely on anecdotal evidence and because the plural of "anecdote" is not "data."


  • Jewish representation in the next Congress will increase exclusively due to the election of more Jewish Democrats. Next year, we will have more Jewish governors, all Democrats.


  • Tuesday's election was a giant leap in the right direction. It is only a first step. We will finish the job in 729 days.


We're in this together. Please support my work by chipping in via credit card (you do not need a PayPal account), Zelle (contact me for info), Venmo @Steven-Sheffey (last four digits, 9479), or check.


Friends,


Well, it's been five days under socialism and Sharia law, and so far, I'm liking it! 


America came back last night, and in 729 days, we will finish the job. As Warren Buffett used to say, “Never bet against America.” Or as Winston Churchill is alleged to have said, “You can always count on Americans to do the right thing—after they've tried everything else."


I think that Susan Collins has learned her lesson. Whether those who wrongly predicted a Jewish exodus from the Democratic Party have learned their lesson might be another story. More on that in a moment.


What about Israel? The Democratic wave on Tuesday resulted not from Democrats replacing other Democrats in blue districts, but from Democrats winning previously Republican seats. The next Congress will include a handful of Democrats whose views on Israel might concern us, but the next Congress will include a Democratic caucus with a larger majority of traditionally pro-Israel Democrats than the Democratic caucus in the current Congress.


Amir Tibon's Three Facts That We Israelis Must Know About the U.S. Elections

are for us too.


The biggest threat to the U.S.- Israel relationship will be Trump's erratic behavior regarding Israel. His Election Day announcement that he would end aid to Israel at the end of the year caught even his own State Department by surprise. No one knows if he meant it, if it will actually happen, or if legally he can even do it– not that illegality has stopped him before.


Meanwhile, presidential hopeful JD Vance is catering to the isolationist wing of the Republican Party that views Israel as a liability, not as an asset, most recently by blaming Tuesday's GOP shellacking on our relationship with Israel.


The wild card will be Israel's next government. The biggest factor behind increased criticism of Israel from both parties is the policies of the current Israeli government. A new Israeli government that continues those policies, whether led by Netanyahu or someone else, will continue to fray our relationship with Israel.


Unless Israel takes meaningful steps to address the situation in Gaza, crack down hard on settler terrorism in the West Bank, and show a meaningful commitment to a two-state solution that includes dismantling illegal settlements and freezing settlement building going forward, there is not much we in the United States can do to rehabilitate Israel's standing among the American public.


The rhetoric of some Democrats is the symptom; the policies of Israel's government are the disease. Therefore, writes Daniel Bral, "if there is discomfort with where the [Democratic] party is moving, it should be redirected toward the catalyst — the Israeli government."


Who will lead the next Congress? Most likely Chuck Schumer in the Senate and Hakeem Jeffries in the House. Following Mike Johnson's announcement that he will step down as Republican leader, Rep. Jim Jordan (R-OH) announced his candidacy to lead the House Republican caucus. I asked Rep. Sean Casten (D-IL) about that, and he told me, "It's important to put someone in that job who's got a long history of protecting sexual abusers."


Reliable polling found that on Tuesday, 72% of Jewish voters voted Democratic, proving once again that the Democratic Party remains the home of the vast majority of Jewish Americans. The poll, conducted by GBAO Strategies for J Street, is methodologically sound. The poll also asked about Jewish voting priorities and Jewish attitudes on aid to Israel (Jews are evenly split on whether to end aid to Israel), arms sales to Israel (a plurality favors arms sales with conditions), AIPAC (not popular), Trump (not popular), the Israel-Palestinian conflict (39% say their sympathies are with Israel, 23% with the Palestinians, and 38% with both), the Trump administration's cutting funding to universities they say are not doing enough to combat antisemitism (a majority think that this policy will increase antisemitism), and more.


I encourage you to spend some time with it to the extent you want to understand the Jewish electorate. It's fascinating, and too much to summarize. Pay particular attention to the age differentials. For example, Jews under 50 sympathize more with the Palestinians than with Israelis, and 60% of those aged 18-34 believe that Israel has committed genocide and can no longer support military aid to Israel.


As you read through it, try this thought experiment: If you did not know which party Jews supported in the midterms, and all you knew was how Jews felt about the issues surveyed in this poll, which party do you think most of them would vote for?


If you find these polling results hard to accept because that is not what you are seeing on the social media you follow or on the text chains you are part of, remember that many of us live in a bubble that includes a small but vocal minority of the Jewish community.


As pollster Jim Gerstein said on Thursday, "We do research because we can't rely on the insular bubbles we live in." Nor can we assume that the views and priorities of the Jewish media and certain influential Jewish legacy organizations are the views and priorities of Jewish voters as a whole, as much as they would like us to think that they represent those views and priorities.


David Schraub explains why Jews overwhelmingly vote Democratic, and his explanation is supported by this poll's findings:


  • First, on every issue aside from Israel, Jews prefer Democrats to Republicans.


  • Second, on the issue of Israel, Jews prefer Democrats to Republicans.


Jews have a political home. It's called the Democratic Party. The only problem the Democratic Party has with Jewish voters is that there are not enough of us.


Why is this poll more reliable than other polls showing different results? Maybe you've thrown up your hands wondering who to believe and think that people are just cherry-picking the polls that they want to believe.


The GBAO poll differs from exit polls that do not ask the range of critical Jewish demographic questions, such as denomination and synagogue membership, that are necessary to ensure a representative sample. The survey reflects the demographic composition of the Jewish population as extensively examined by the Pew Research Center--that's the gold standard.


You should disregard polls of the general population that just happen to pick up Jewish voters. Those polls make no effort to ask the appropriate screening questions to determine whether someone is Jewish, nor do they make any effort to properly weight results for denomination. The NBC exit poll falls into that category.


You should disregard polls that try to measure the Jewish vote by polling in what they call Jewish neighborhoods or Jewish precincts. Plenty of non-Jews live in Jewish neighborhoods and Jewish precincts. Also, Jews clustered together geographically are not necessarily representative of the broader Jewish community.


You should disregard polls of only early voters. Younger voters are more likely to vote on Election Day. If younger voters were part of a candidate's base (e.g., El-Sayed), the results would be skewed.


Learn more about how to evaluate polls of the Jewish community.


What about Michigan? I have not seen any methodologically sound polling of the Jewish vote in Michigan. When no methodologically sound polling is available, we should not default to unsound polling. If we don't know, we don't know.


Maybe the percentage of Jews who voted El-Sayed in Michigan is lower than the percentage of Jews across the country. We don't know. A loud segment of the Michigan Jewish community opposed El-Sayed. That does not mean other Michigan Jews felt the same way. Even if he underperformed relative to other candidates running in Michigan, it is likely that he won a majority of the Jewish vote, especially younger voters, and the polling tells us how younger Jews feel about Israel-related issues.


Which candidate would you think had the bigger problem with Jewish voters--the candidate who won a majority of the Jewish vote or the other one?


The vast majority of Jewish members of the next Congress will be Democrats. In the next Congress, 25 of the 28 Jewish House Members will be Democrats. None of the 10 Jewish Senators will be Republicans.


Next year, we will have seven Jewish governors. All seven will be Democrats.


The question is not whether the Democratic Party is the home of Jewish Americans. The question is what the small minority of Republican Jews are running away from.


In Case You Missed It:


  • Jacob Kornbluh cited my essay on how to evaluate polls of Jewish voters in his article for The Forward analyzing the election results.








Social Media of the Week. Emily Tamkin and Zohran Mamdani's response to JD Vance trying to take credit for improvements in NYC.


Thread of the Week. The Nexus Project on today's “Boycott Ride” in Philadelphia.


Video Clips of the Week. Dr. Annie Andrews, the Democrat who defeated Lindsey Graham's sister and will become the next senator from South Carolina, might become the funniest senator ever. Check out this and this and this.


Vintage Music Clip of the Week. We are all (or at least 72% of us) feeling Happy.


The Fine Print. Read the fine print before you reply or send me anything.


This is the newsletter even Republicans have to read. If someone forwarded this newsletter to you, your luck continues. You can subscribe and get it in your inbox every Sunday for free. Just click here.


I hope you enjoyed today's newsletter. It takes time to write and costs money to send. You are on this list because you are smart, good-looking, and generous. If you'd like to support my work, click here and fill in the amount of your choice. You don't need a PayPal account. If you see something that says "Save your info and create a PayPal account," click the button to the right and it will go away. Or you can use Zelle, (contact me for info), Venmo @Steven-Sheffey (last four digits, 9479), or send a check.


Unless stated otherwise, my views do not necessarily reflect the views of any candidates or organizations I support or am associated with.

Dedicated to my daughters: Ariel Sheffey, Ayelet Sheffey, and Orli Sheffey z''l. Copyright 2026 Steve Sheffey. All rights reserved. Read the fine print.

 
X Share This Email