Emergency Room vs. Urgent Care: When to visit one versus the other
With the upcoming season, holidays, and increased engagement in outdoor activities, being prepared for potential injuries or illnesses becomes crucial. Understanding when to visit the Emergency Room (ER) or Urgent Care can not only save you time and money but also ensure that your medical needs are appropriately addressed.
Let's talk about a real-life scenario where one member made the right decision in seeking medical care for an injured family member, and the significance of his informed decision:
While enjoying a dinner outside in their backyard with friends, Oliver's daughter experienced a fall and potentially broke her arm. Unable to reach his Primary Care Provider after regular working hours, Oliver made a smart decision to drive to an in-network urgent care facility, despite the additional 20-minute drive. This choice resulted in a flat rate of $20 under his PPO plan, while a visit to the ER would have cost $150, plus 20% coinsurance after meeting the $500 deductible. (It's important to note that specific plan details may vary, but this experience highlights the relevance of making informed choices!)
What Oliver did for his family was smart, and his daughter was still able to get the proper treatment she needed at a very reasonable price. How do you make the smart choice in this situation? In those moments of emergency, there are three options for care to be received: your Primary Care Doctor, an Urgent Care, and the Emergency Room, with each option comes three drastically different costs.
So, what facility should you use? How do you know when to use each of them? It's easy to panic in these moments and make the more expensive choice without realizing how much it will cost you later.
There is a lot to consider when choosing a facility. Some key questions you should ask yourself are:
-
What time of day is it?
-
Is it a weekend or holiday?
-
How serious is the injury?
-
How fast is the bleeding?
-
Am I on a PPO or an HMO insurance plan?
-
What is the pain level of the injured/ill?
If an injury takes place during normal business hours and not on a holiday or weekend, you should contact your Primary Care Provider first. Your Primary Care Provider can cast a bone, prescribe antibiotics, run basic test, etc. and will charge you their normal visit rate which could be hundreds of dollars cheaper than going to an emergency room. When you call your Primary Care Provider, give them a description of what is going on. If they cannot assist you, they will refer you to an urgent care or emergency room that can. Whether you are on an HMO or PPO, this is an important step because it can help make sure that the urgent care or emergency room are in-network which helps keep cost down.
If there is an emergency on a weekend, a holiday, or the middle on the night, urgent cares are the next best places to go. It's good to know on hand what urgent cares are in-network around you. Our Advocacy Team is here to help if you need assistance in locating your nearest-in-network urgent care. But if you don’t know and it's late, you can always call the "Members Services" number on the back of your insurance ID card and they can provide a list. Another option is use your Medical Carrier's App to find in-network urgent cares near you. (For example, Anthem's Sydney Health App, is free to download and offers great resources for members.) Urgent cares can handle just about anything and if not, they can refer you to an emergency room. For most plans, urgent cares have a set copay amount this is a great way to keep costs down.
Emergency rooms should only be used in the most extreme situations. For most plans, emergency rooms have a set copay amount as well as coinsurance once your plans deductible is hit. This means that you pay a flat rate just for walking in the door and then, after meeting your deductible, are responsible for a set percentage of the bill. These can become very expensive very quickly. While they serve a vital role in communities, ERs should be reserved for the most desperate of medical cases.
If you have more questions about specific situations do not hesitate to contact your Primary Care Provider or our Advocacy Team by replying to this email or calling our office at 855-662-1029.
|