|
Case updates this week:
Friday December 1st: Another challenge to Connecticut’s decision to repeal its religious exemption to its childhood vaccine mandate was dismissed by the Federal District Court for the District of Connecticut in Milford Christian Church v. Russell-Tucker. The plaintiffs included Milford Christian Church, two church employees, and a parishioner who wanted to send her child to the pre-school that the church operates. Plaintiffs argued that by disallowing religious exemptions, the state had infringed on their First Amendment Free Exercise rights by forcing them to either violate their religious beliefs and vaccinate their children, or not enroll them in school. Plaintiffs also argued that by forcing this choice on parents, the Fourteenth Amendment Equal Protection Clause as well as their childrearing liberty interest were violated. However, the court found that We The Patriots USA Inc. v. Connecticut Office of Early Childhood Development controlled the outcome, and held that the Connecticut law was neutral to religion and generally applicable, and therefore subject to rational basis review, rather than strict scrutiny.
Applying rational basis review, the court held that the plaintiffs’ First Amendment claims failed because the state has a compelling government interest in protecting public health, and increasing the number of vaccinated children is rationally related to that goal. The court also followed the reasoning of We The Patriots USA regarding the Equal Protection claims, holding that the mandate does not classify based on religion. Instead, it differentiates between children who need medical exemptions and those who do not. Finally, the court held that parents’ liberty interest in child-rearing is not an independent fundamental right. Instead, it falls under the Free Exercise Clause. Therefore, because the plaintiff’s Free Exercise claim was dismissed, the child-rearing claim must be as well.
Monday December 4th: The Federal District Court for the Southern District of New York dismissed a teacher’s claim of religious discrimination after she was fired for refusing to receive the COVID-19 vaccine. In Bonilla v. City of New York, the plaintiff teacher was terminated by the New York City Department of Education (DOE) after her request for a religious exemption to the DOE’s vaccine mandate was denied. The plaintiff then sued, alleging her First Amendment Free Exercise and Fourteenth Amendment Equal Protection rights had been violated. The court held that the DOE’s vaccination mandate for most employees was neutral to religion and generally applicable, and therefore only subject to rational review. While the plaintiff argued that the mandate was not generally applicable because DOE bus drivers were not included, the court held that Kane v. De Blasio, from the Second Circuit, had previously found the DOE vaccine mandate neutral and generally applicable, despite exempting categories of employees, including bus drivers, who did not spend as much time with students in enclosed spaces as teachers.
The plaintiff argued that the mandate failed rational review because the CDC conceded that the vaccine was ineffective at preventing COVID-19 infection and transmission. The court pointed out this simply wasn’t true. The CDC has stated that vaccination was the leading public health prevention strategy for COVID-19. Under rational basis review, the court held that the DOE’s vaccine mandate served a compelling purpose in providing a safe environment for students, and that allowing the plaintiff an exemption would have been an undue hardship by jeopardizing that safe environment.
Tuesday December 5th: The Federal District Court for the District of New Mexico further limited the New Mexico public health emergency-based ban on firearms in public in Springer v. Grisham. The ban, which has been attacked by numerous suits since first being implemented in September, initially used the governor’s power to declare public health emergencies to prohibit the carrying of firearms in all public spaces in certain cities in the state. However, after multiple preliminary injunctions won by gun rights activists shortly after passage, the ban only extended to playgrounds (and other places specifically meant for children) and public parks. However, the court here applied the Bruen test created by the Supreme Court in 2022 to find that there were no equivalent historical restrictions on firearms in public parks, and thus enjoined that aspect of the ban as well.
|