Weekly Newsletter

Friday, Oct. 3, 2025

Thank you for subscribing to Suncoast Searchlight's newsletter.

We’re here to keep you informed on the local issues that matter most. Each week, we share our latest in-depth reporting, along with the most important stories from around the region, so you stay connected and up to date with what’s happening in your community.


Enjoying this newsletter thanks to a friend? Subscribe here to get it in your inbox. 📬

NEW FROM SUNCOAST SEARCHLIGHT:

PAM AMES TAKES ON ARCADIA'S TOUGHEST JOB: SAVING MAIN STREET


Pam Ames set out the donuts, stacked red clipboards in a neat pile and draped T-shirts across the tables, hoping at least half of the 100 volunteers she needed would appear that sunny Saturday in mid-September.


As executive director of the Arcadia Main Street Program, Ames had landed one of AARP’s coveted Community Challenge grants — $25,000 to help revive a downtown that has been fading for decades. But the grant was about more than money. To keep it, Ames had to prove she could rally her neighbors, show that Arcadia still had enough faith in itself.


That remains her hardest work.


Ultimately, about 30 volunteers showed up at the Main Street office downtown. Armed with the clipboards and Ames’ instructions, they fanned out for the “community walk audit” — marking cracked sidewalks, broken curbs and spots that could use benches — the next step for future improvements.


Though the turnout fell short of what she had hoped, Ames has learned to measure progress in steps. Next month, she’ll try again — more donuts, more clipboards, more T-shirts.


For the past two years, Ames, 57, has led Arcadia Main Street, a nonprofit tasked with marketing and revitalizing the 18-block historic district between Hickory and Magnolia streets. As part of that job, she has taken on the challenge of improving a downtown straining from aging infrastructure, limited resources and the repeated blows of hurricanes that have drained businesses and tested residents’ resolve.

NEW FROM SUNCOAST SEARCHLIGHT:

CHARTER EXPANSIONS JEOPARDIZE SARASOTA’S WILKINSON ELEMENTARY. OTHERS COULD BE NEXT.


Sarasota County Schools announced preliminary plans last month to shutter Wilkinson Elementary and shift students to other public schools to stave off a charter operator from moving in to fill empty space.


If approved, the closure of Wilkinson — currently a C-rated school and the only one in the county that’s nationally STEM-certified — would be Sarasota County’s first public school closure in half a century.


The proposal has sparked widespread outcry from Wilkinson parents who packed emergency meetings, petitioned lawmakers to unwind aggressive state charter expansions and lobbied the School Board of Sarasota County to find an alternative.


School board members now say the plan is not final, hinting that Wilkinson may survive after all.


But Wilkinson is not the only Sarasota County school in jeopardy.


Despite countywide population growth, a Suncoast Searchlight review of state enrollment data found that more than 20 other Sarasota schools have steadily lost students for more than a decade, including some of the district’s most prestigious and top-ranked campuses, like Pine View School for the Gifted.


Suncoast Searchlight partners with Gigafact to produce weekly fact briefs — concise, 150-word news stories that take real claims circulating online and fact check them. Each brief offers a direct “yes” or “no” answer to the question or claim, followed by a clear explanation backed up by credible, high-quality sources.


THIS WEEK'S FACT BRIEFS:



The Searchlight Series Launch


We’re thrilled to kick off The Searchlight Series, in partnership with Gulf Coast Community Foundation, with a special conversation featuring Dean Baquet, former Executive Editor of The New York Times.


Dean will reflect on the role of local journalism in protecting democracy, the challenges facing newsrooms, and the opportunities ahead for nonprofit news organizations like Suncoast Searchlight.


Thursday, Nov. 13, 2025 | 10:30 a.m.– Noon


Garden Club of Sarasota

Free and open to the public | Space is limited


Register here to save your seat today! 

HERE'S WHAT ELSE WE RECOMMEND READING THIS WEEK


MYAKKA CITY RESIDENTS ALARMED BY CREEPING DEVELOPMENT GETTING ‘OUT OF HAND’

FROM BRADENTON HERALD

Residents and officials who oversee the Myakka River are worried about the impacts of development inching closer to one of the region’s final frontiers. Some Myakka City residents are worried about growth threatening the rural way of life that many moved there to pursue, and the Myakka River Management Coordinating Council said increased buffers are warranted. However, with Senate Bill 180’s restrictive language, there isn’t much county officials can do to limit nearby development. Those who live closest to the Myakka River and the state park say it’s crucial that the county preserves the area from development impacts.

READ THE STORY HERE



HOW THE GOVERNMENT SHUTDOWN AFFECTS FLORIDA NATIONAL PARKS

FROM TAMPA BAY TIMES

The last time the government shut down, most national parks remained open. With the government officially shuttered starting Wednesday amid congressional squabbling over health care spending, President Donald Trump’s National Park Service is running back the same game plan. That means Florida’s 11 national parks, preserves, seashores, memorials and monuments will largely remain open, according to a National Park Service contingency plan published in September. “Staffing will be held to the amount needed for the protection of life, property, and public health and safety, and will be based on the assumption that the NPS (National Park Service) is conducting no park operations and providing no visitor services,” the memo reads. It stresses that “Park roads, lookouts, trails, and open-air memorials will generally remain accessible to visitors.”

READ THE STORY HERE



25 CITIES AND COUNTIES, INCLUDING MANATEE, ARE SUING THE STATE OVER A NEW GROWTH LAW

FROM WUSF

Twenty-five cities and counties filed a lawsuit Monday challenging a new state law that blocks local governments from approving "more restrictive or burdensome" changes to growth plans for the next two years. The challenge, filed in Leon County circuit court, contends that the law (SB 180) effectively freezes all local land-development regulations and comprehensive plans through Oct. 1, 2027, violates home-rule authority and, using “ambiguous and vague” preemption language, strips the ability of cities and counties to manage their growth. The changes took effect June 26, when Gov. Ron DeSantis signed the law, and are retroactive to Aug. 1, 2024.

READ THE STORY HERE



EROSION OF HOME RULE: 'WE CRY A LOT'

FROM VENICE GONDOLIER

As the state Legislature continues to take power away from local government, it’s having a negative impact on Venice and Sarasota County, according to the two day-to-day leaders of those municipalities. Venice City Manager James Clinch and Sarasota County Administrator Jonathan Lewis spoke Friday morning to attendees at Friday’s Coffee & Conversation at the Venice Area Chamber of Commerce. Asked how local governments react to the erosion of home rule power by the state Legislature, Lewis said, “We cry a lot.” Authority that cities and counties had as recently as 15 years ago has been taken away, he said. Just this year, Senate Bill 180 was passed and signed, extending a restriction on local governments that precludes them from adopting stricter land-use rules. Because of it, Lewis said, he delayed a county study of impact fees. That might not be what the Legislature intended, he said, “but it is the ramification.”

READ THE STORY HERE



SARASOTA COUNTY APPROVES $2.52B BUDGET, WITH BOOSTS FOR STORMWATER AND SHERIFF

FROM SARASOTA HERALD-TRIBUNE

Sarasota County Commissioners have approved a $2.52 billion total budget, a 73% increase in spending from just three years ago, as property tax revenues have soared. Commissioner Tom Knight was the only commissioner to oppose the budget in a roll call vote. County Commission Chair Joe Neunder and Commissioners Teresa Mark and Mark Smith voted in favor. Commissioner Ron Cutsinger was not in attendance. “The budget, to me, is increasing rapidly, and it has my concern,” Knight said. “The sheriff's office budget is increasing rapidly – again." The commissioner said his most important gripe was the $23 million being drawn from county reserves to supplement the annual budget.

READ THE STORY HERE



FLORIDA'S MID-CYCLE REDISTRICTING, EXPLAINED

FROM SARASOTA MAGAZINE

Sarasota Magazine sat down with New College political scientist Frank Alcock to discuss Florida’s unusual mid-decade redistricting effort, led by Governor Ron DeSantis and legislative allies, which he warns could erode public confidence in elections by allowing the party in power to redraw congressional boundaries whenever it chooses. Normally reserved for once-a-decade adjustments after the census, this round of redistricting lacks new population data and appears to conflict with the state’s 2010 Fair Districts amendments designed to prevent partisan gerrymandering. Alcock emphasized the broader risks to constitutional norms and voter trust, while groups such as the League of Women Voters of Sarasota County are already preparing legal opposition ahead of the next legislative session.

READ THE STORY HERE



IN MANATEE COUNTY, A WOMAN BATTLING HEALTH ISSUES PLEADS FOR HUSBAND'S RELEASE FROM ICE

FROM WUSF

Community organizers and church members gathered at the Church of the Trinity MCC in Manatee County last week to call for the release of Eddy Macario. The husband and father of two was stopped by police on May 27 and later transferred to Immigration and Customs Enforcement, according to his wife, Benita Cantero. He's now being held at the Broward Transitional Center in Pompano Beach. Cantero said her husband has no criminal record in the U.S. and made a living painting houses. He was on his way to work in Port Charlotte when police stopped him for a minor traffic infraction, Cantero said. "They asked for bail, but they said that after paying the bail, they would call immigration to pick him up," she said in Spanish through a translator.

READ THE STORY HERE



FLORIDA BUYS 2,500 ACRES TO PROTECT MANATEE DRINKING WATER FROM DEVELOPMENT

FROM BRADENTON HERALD

A 2,500-acre land purchase approved by state leaders on Tuesday will help protect an important drinking water source for Manatee County and Southwest Florida, conservationists say. The ranchlands sit on over six miles of Oak Creek, a tributary of the Peace River and a major drinking water source for Southwest Florida, providing around 26 million gallons per day to nearly 1 million people, according to the Peace River Manasota Regional Water Supply Authority. The state agriculture department’s Rural and Family Lands Program will pay $9.4 million for a conservation easement on 2,559 acres of Bentley Ranch in southeastern Hardee County, according to public records. In a conservation easement, a landowner continues to live and work on the land but permanently gives up the right to develop it, leaving it in a semi-natural state. The purchase will also add a missing piece to the Florida Wildlife Corridor.

READ THE STORY HERE



STATE TROOPER VS HOA: TUSSLE OVER PARKING PATROL CAR OVERNIGHT TESTS STATE LAW

FROM ORLANDO SENTINEL

A heated confrontation in Orlando over an FHP patrol car’s parking space has moved beyond the usual tension between residents and homeowner associations — it’s become a test case for a state law giving first responders a sweeping exemption from HOA rules. Florida Highway Patrol trooper Eduardo Hernandez said he was told when he rented his home that he could park his cruiser in the guest parking at the Carter Glen neighborhood clubhouse. But then the homeowners association disagreed, saying the rules prohibited him from parking it there overnight. Hernandez countered that a state law signed by Gov. Ron DeSantis in 2020 says HOAs may not prohibit first responders from parking their clearly marked vehicle wherever parking is allowed within the community. That exemption includes owners, tenants, and guests.

READ THE STORY HERE



MAIN STREET VISION PITS WALKABILITY AGAINST PARKING

FROM SARASOTA OBSERVER

Visioning for a reimagined Main Street is now complete, and thanks to a 4-1 vote of the Sarasota City Commission on Sept. 2, design and engineering can begin. Citing concerns expressed by downtown merchants over sacrificing perhaps upwards of 100 angle parking spaces in order to enhance the downtown pedestrian experience, Commissioner Jen Ahearn-Koch was the lone dissenting vote to send the community vision for Main Street to the planning and design phase with land use firm Kimley-Horn. The presentation of the visioning phase for the 1.2-mile project between U.S. 41 and School Avenue was the culmination of a year of public engagement to gather feedback via the project website, door-to-door canvassing of businesses, mapping, surveys, social media, tables at public events, workshops, open houses, stakeholder meetings and two surveys.

READ THE STORY HERE





AN UNINSURED FLORIDA MOM FELL FROM THE 4TH FLOOR. WILL SHE EVER WALK AGAIN?

FROM TAMPA BAY TIMES

A paramedic found Kristina Andrews face down on the sidewalk. The screen on the fourth floor balcony above her was torn. The fall slammed her body into the concrete at about 50 mph, cracking ribs, snapping her shoulder, hip and pelvis bones, twisting her spine and neck. The last thing Andrews recalled was standing on an end table to hang a lantern. She came to at Tampa General Hospital days later, a hospital chaplain by her bed. Your chances aren’t very good, he told her. This might be a good time to reach out to loved ones.

READ THE STORY HERE


DID YOU MISS OUR PREVIOUS NEWSLETTER?

HERE'S WHAT WE SHARED:

ICE detainers erode constitutional rights in Florida’s justice system, advocates warn


As the federal government mines local jails for undocumented people, immigrants increasingly face the reality that paying a bond does not guarantee their freedom.


Instead of walking free, many who post bail are held beyond their scheduled release and transferred to Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) custody for possible deportation — leaving families out hundreds of dollars, attorneys unable to reach their clients and local courts with unresolved cases. 


Attorneys and advocates have long raised questions about the legality of the controversial practice.


During U.S. President Donald Trump’s second term, ICE has increasingly relied on Florida jails to arrest undocumented immigrants, according to a Suncoast Searchlight investigation published earlier this month. That report detailed the case of a Manatee County resident who was turned over to ICE shortly after his wife paid his bonds on two misdemeanor charges stemming from an alleged traffic violation. His deportation left the local case unresolved, and the family remains in legal limbo.


What happened to him reflects a broader pattern. As ICE ramps up its use of local jails, attorneys describe both new obstacles in representing clients and a broader erosion of due process.



She paid his bond. ICE took him. Bradenton family’s saga shows how Florida jails fuel deportations


In the early morning hours on July 12, Oscar Romero Santos drove his red Ram truck toward the Bradenton home he shared with his wife. When he turned onto his block, a Manatee County Sheriff’s deputy followed. 


As Romero Santos pulled into the driveway, the deputy flashed his emergency lights.


Romero Santos parked, got out of the truck and walked quickly towards the house. “That’s when [the deputy] came running from the other side of the car and put handcuffs on me,” he said. 


Inside, his wife Sheysa Romero Santos slept, unaware of what was transpiring on her doorstep — or that it would be the last time she’d be that close to her husband for the foreseeable future.


Only when Romero Santos called from the jail did his wife learn what had happened. She paid $650 to cover his bonds believing it would bring him home. 


Instead, Immigration and Customs Enforcement detained him and deported him to Honduras within weeks. He's not alone.

Manatee County to weigh crackdown on illegal adult arcades after media investigation


Manatee County soon will consider a plan to crack down on the illegal strip-mall casinos that have flourished in plain sight in defiance of a state ban — and to the frustration of local law enforcement.


Commissioner Tal Siddique, after meeting with sheriff’s office officials and the county attorney, said he will introduce a proposal at the Oct. 7 board of commissioners meeting to define the arcades more clearly under county law and create a licensing system to root out violators.


“It’s to differentiate the Dave and Busters of the world from Spin Fun Arcade,” Siddique said. “I think we all know the difference between the two. We need to make sure the law can differentiate — and specifically [weed] out the slot-style machines.”


The move comes on the heels of a joint investigation by Suncoast Searchlight and Bradenton Herald in July that revealed how these so-called “adult arcades” have evaded area law enforcement for years, closing down on one block just to reopen on another. Authorities say that’s because of the lengthy legal and financial hassle of dismantling these operations — and the minimal return, since arrests often result in just a misdemeanor.


Manatee County Sheriff Rick Wells has signaled agreement with stricter local rules, with an agency spokesperson saying the sheriff “supports the idea of increased regulation on the operation of these businesses.”

How we analyzed the data on ICE detainers, arrests and deportations in Florida



To examine how local jails are fueling an immigration crackdown in Florida, we analyzed hundreds of thousands of federal immigration arrest, detainer and deportation records.


Local jail records also informed our reporting; however, because of differences in how county sheriff’s offices maintain that data, we did not use those records to produce statistics for the story.


Click below to read about the methodology behind our findings.



 

GOT A TIP OR STORY IDEA?


Share your tips and story ideas using our online form. Your name and contact info will be kept confidential.

Suncoast Searchlight is a 501c3 nonprofit news organization whose mission is to produce investigative and explanatory journalism that serves and empowers the residents of Florida’s Suncoast region (Sarasota, Manatee, and DeSoto counties). We shine a light on critical issues affecting our community. Through independent reporting and collaboration with diverse media partners, we foster transparency, accountability and an informed citizenry, ensuring that all voices are heard and that the public has access to the information they need to drive meaningful change.


CONTACT US:

Suncoast Searchlight

PO Box 99 Sarasota, FL 34230

(941) 724-4450