Maria J. Stephan on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert

Image courtesy of Scott Kowalchyk Photography and The Late Show with Stephen Colbert

Dismas Reflections by Maria J. Stephan


Dignity, opportunity, and community. Accountability, grace, and reconciliation. Those are some of the lessons Dismas taught me. I lived at Rutland Dismas House during the summer of 1995, before starting at Boston College. I was a part-time resident and worked in the office with the director and associate director, organizing social outings, working on the newsletter, and visiting correctional facilities. My parents, Phil and Marianne, had been involved in Rutland Dismas House since its founding. They provided the spark, and Rita and Frank McCaffery were like extended family to me.


The Dismas model, bringing formerly incarcerated residents together with students and community volunteers, is unique. Community is at the heart of everything. I saw how community support structures helped residents get sober, find stable jobs, and rebuild relationships. Not perfectly, often with setbacks, but always with hope. The very human interactions between formerly incarcerated residents, volunteers, and staff at the dinner table, on the front porch, and during camping trips are the “secret sauce” of Dismas House.


Dismas centers the dignity and humanity of people. Formerly incarcerated residents are treated with respect. They aren’t defined by the worst decisions they’ve made but, rather, by the potential they possess. I remember celebrating many small victories, from residents getting their first job out of prison to obtaining a sobriety chip to reuniting with their kids. Listening to the residents’ stories taught me about resilience, redemption, and the importance of second (and third) chances. The meals with volunteer cooks were priceless.


I witnessed at Dismas that nonviolent change, at the individual and community levels, is possible and powerful. And that accountability and reconciliation go hand in hand. Telling the truth and addressing harms, whether as crimes committed against community members, or by carceral practices that prioritize punishment over transformation, is the basis of healing and repair. Of “reconciling former prisoners to society and society to former prisoners”. Weekly house meetings were spaces for mutual support and accountability, for addressing sometimes messy conflicts, and for laughing together.


I’m grateful for the Dismas experience, which has informed my research on nonviolent action and work to advance peace and justice in the US and globally. The power of community, of relationships that enable personal and social change, and the gift of fresh starts are Dismas lessons we can live by.



Maria, in addition to being a former volunteer-in-residence, is Co-lead & Chief Organizer at the Horizons Project, an initiative focused on strengthening connections and collective action among US pro-democracy movements and sectors.


Maria is an award-winning author and organizer whose work has focused on the role of nonviolent movements advancing human rights, democracy, and peace. 


Her parents, Phil and Marianne Stephan, have been long-standing, active Dismas donors and volunteers from 1989 to the present. Phil & Marianne (2005) and Maria (2013) are former Jack Hickey Award recipients.

Turn Your Volunteer Hours at Dismas into Cash


Did you know that thousands of companies have volunteer incentive programs that support employee volunteering? These programs could offer volunteer grants (which match your volunteer time with donations to Dismas) or volunteer PTO (which allows you to take paid time off to volunteer with our organization).


See if your hours are eligible!

undefined

Dismas in the News: 40 Years


Over 40 years, Dismas has provided 337,719 days of supportive housing to 2,350 people, most of whom are Vermonters returning home after incarceration. Rita McCaffrey says, “Our inspiration has always been about building community, which starts inside the walls of a Dismas house among staff and residents. Being in community is the secret sauce that has held us together.”


Read the full press release.

The Fall Print Newsletter is Here


If you don't receive the print newsletter by mail, you can catch up online with the Fall 2026 issue.


Get an overview of the Dismas timeline and hear from founder Rita McCaffrey and executive director Jim Curran. Catch up on resident and event updates. See the new Dismas faces.


Read the Fall 2026 Issue

rewind.png_p1.png

July 2019 Excerpt: Burlington Dismas House -- Filmed by volunteers Angela and Sophie

Celebrate 40 Years With Us

Join the 1986 Club


  1. Join the club and make the gift.
  2. Get all of Dismas of Vermont's programs off to a good start.
  3. Within a week of giving, get a rad holographic sticker.
  4. Be tickled by throwback Dismas photos and 80s-themed benefits delivered to your inbox.


Apple Gleaning with Willing Hands


Hartford Dismas House residents Jeremy, Justin, and Tyler recently teamed up with fellow volunteers to pick an incredible 2,227 pounds of apples at Riverview Farm in Plainfield, New Hampshire. The gleaning event supported Willing Hands, an organization dedicated to recovering fresh food to reduce waste and expand equitable, reliable access to nutritious food. Thanks to residents and the volunteer community, these apples will be distributed across the region to Willing Hands’ food access partners, helping feed neighbors in need.

Hat's Off to Dismas


On the shores of Keeler Bay in South Hero, new and old friends shared a high tea to celebrate 40 years of Dismas on a beautiful autumn afternoon in September.


Sue Collinson, a local council member and volunteer, hosted. Guests included friends, family, volunteer cooks, and members of the First Congregational Church of South Hero. Donna Hale, wearing a smart black outfit with a top hat, won the prize for the best hat!


Thank you to everyone who attended and donated generously to Dismas.

Dismas is Platinum


As of this month, Dismas of Vermont has satisfied Candid's requirements for a Platinum Transparency rating.


This team effort is the highest level of recognition that Candid, a major charity research and verification group (formerly GuideStar and Foundation Center), gives to nonprofits.

IKYMI Dismas is Certified


As of mid-June, all five of Dismas of Vermont's family-style homes are certified as Level II Recovery Residences by the Vermont Alliance of Recovery Residences (VTARR).


This certification reinforces the recovery programming that Dismas offers to people with substance use disorder and provides additional tools and resources to Dismas residents.