August 13, 2024

VHC Digest

Welcome to our first Fall Semester edition of the Vulnerability and the Human Condition Initiative Digest.

 

Today, we begin with a recent blog post written by our postdoc, Dr. Helena Moradi. We also highlight some of the exciting events that took place over the summer, as well as our latest “Voices in Vulnerability” podcast episode.



Please note the upcoming visiting scholar talk on "Re-Imagining International Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs) and Access to Vaccines in the Global South in the Aftermath of the COVID-19 Pandemic" by Chinwe 'Mary Joe' Maduabum.

 

Read below to learn more.

From Autonomy to Empathy (Redefining Legal Subjectivity through Vulnerability Theory and Empathetic Institution)

by Dr. Helena Moradi

Image via Pixabay

Our latest Vulnerability Blog post by Postdoctoral Fellow Dr. Helena Moradi gives us a sneak peek into her upcoming book chapter, "Empathy as Necessity: Challenging the Myth of Individual Autonomy through Vulnerability Theory."


"The concept of individual autonomy, central to modern legal and social frameworks since the Enlightenment, emphasizes personal liberty and minimal state interference. This mythical ideal, however, obscures a profound truth about human existence: our inherent vulnerabilities and dependencies. Recognizing this, Vulnerability Theory offers an alternative by emphasizing these vulnerabilities and the essential role of institutional structures and relationships throughout life.”


Read the blog post here.

Summer Happenings

“Feminist Reflections on Surrogacy: What I Learned at Emory”

Elisa Baiocco - Visiting Scholar Talk

Visiting Scholar, Elisa Baiocco, joined us from Sapienza University, Rome, to conduct research into the philosophical and juridical debate on surrogacy at Emory during the Spring Semester. Ms. Baiocco gave a talk on her research into feminist critiques of the application of the equality and autonomy principles to the philosophical and juridical debate on surrogacy, in particular referring to the surrogacy contract. She further shared how being at Emory helped her research, her experience dealing with the Archive texts consulted, and some stimulating questions discussed during Professor Fineman's classes and the vulnerability theory.


Watch the video here.

"The Ethics and Legality of AI Artwork: A Vulnerability Theory Analysis"

Gaya Rajamony and Paul Myers (Trinity University, San Antonio, TX)

Professor Paul Myers and Gaya Rajamony of Trinity University (San Antonio, TX), visited Emory Law in person on May 14th and presented Gaya's research into the Ethics and Legality of AI Artwork. Watch the video here.

“Disability Rights and Reproductive Rights” with Dhanishka Seneviratne (University of Birmingham), Visiting Scholar

Are disability rights and reproductive rights fundamentally opposed to one another?


Attorney Dhanishka Seneviratne joined the Vulnerability and the Human Condition Initiative and the Feminism and Legal Theory Project at Emory Law from the University of Birmingham to conduct research on “Vulnerability, Relationality, and Disability-Selective Abortions: Re-designing the Responsive State" during the spring 2024 semester. In this interview, she discusses her interest in disability rights, her career trajectory, and her research in the FLT archive. Listen to the podcast interview here. Dhanishka Seneviratne also gave a talk on her research on May 22, 2024, which is accessible here.

“The FLT Project and the history of feminist legal thought in the United States, 1984-2005” with Samuel Burry

 

On July 18, 2024, Samuel Burry, FLT visiting researcher from Oxford University, returned to continue his research into the FLT archive and update the VHC community on his findings. His abstract is below, and you may watch the video recording of his talk here.


"Abstract: This paper draws on previously unknown and unpublished materials from the FLT archive to offer the first sustained account of the development of (some of) the FLT workshops and their crucial role in the making of feminist legal thought. In doing so, the paper offers two central contentions: firstly, that standard accounts of the development of feminist legal thought, which emphasize its close connections to the Conference on Critical Legal Studies, occlude the crucial institutional venues provided by the FLT project and the hundreds of scholars who passed through its workshops. The second concerns a set of methodological interventions regarding how historians should study the history of feminist legal thought. I argue that this history can be helpfully explicated in terms of “communities of praxis” and by drawing on Duncan Bell’s notion of “world-making” and “world-taking,” whilst also contending that the FLT workshops, as sites of intergenerational and co-constitutive theorization, render the “waves” metaphor as unhelpful and even obfuscatory to the study of feminist legal thought."

 "Power, Choice, Exposure, and Fragility: Reframing Vulnerability and Resilience for the Corporate and Insolvency Sphere" by Jennifer Gant

Professor Jennifer Gant is a senior lecturer (assistant professor) in law and coordinator of the Centre for Justice Law and Society at University of Derby School of Law where she is the co-lead of the International Trade, Investment, and Commercial Law Cluster. She teaches employment law, independent studies on the LLB and LPC LLM, and legal and business skills focused on advancing commercial awareness for future legal professionals. Professor Gant joined us on August 1, 2024, to workshop her paper on "Power, Choice, Exposure, and Fragility: Reframing Vulnerability and Resilience for the Corporate and Insolvency Sphere.”


You may view the video of the talk here.

"Building up the Rainbow: Narratives, Legal Reasoning and Decision-making in Asylum Cases based on Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity"

Visiting Scholar Talk by Denise Venturi

Visiting scholar and PhD candidate, Denise Venturi, joined us from KU Leuven this summer to conduct research in the FLT Archives. On August 8, 2024, she gave a talk on her research titled "Building up the Rainbow: Narratives, Legal Reasoning and Decision-making in Asylum Cases based on Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity."


View the talk and discussion here.

Plans for the 2024-2025 Academic Year

"Re-Imagining International Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs) and Access to Vaccines in the Global South in the Aftermath of the COVID-19 Pandemic"

by Mary Joe Maduabum

Could Vulnerability theory explain the tension between IPRs (patents) and access to medicine and help the Global South achieve health equity?


VHC visiting scholar, Chinwe “Mary Joe” Maduabum (PhD Student, Birmingham Law School), will explore this question during her talk, "Re-Imagining International Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs) and Access to Vaccines in the Global South in the Aftermath of the COVID-19 Pandemic" next Thursday at 3pm. Join us in the CICL Suite on the third floor of Gambrell Hall, or email vhc-flt@emory.edu for the Zoom link.

Vulnerability Reading Group

Recently, we closed two vulnerability theory-related reading groups.

Please contact us at mlfinem@emory.edu or at vhc-flt@emory.edu to express interest in potential reading groups for the upcoming academic year.

Fall Workshops

Plans are being made for workshops in the fall. There are lots of exciting possibilities given the upending of precedent and stability. Please send suggestions to vhc-flt@emory.edu or to mlfinem@emory.edu.

Connect with us
Facebook  Twitter