|
Every year at the Passover Seder, when Jewish families around the world sit around the table and read the story of the Exodus from the Haggadah, they come across a surprising line: "Go and learn what Laban the Aramean sought to do to our father Jacob. Pharaoh decreed only against the males, but Laban sought to uproot everything."
It's a puzzling statement. The whole Haggadah tells the story of Pharaoh, who enslaved the Israelites and ordered their baby boys thrown into the Nile. Yet right there it says Laban was worse. On top of that, in this week's Torah portion Laban never actually tries to kill anyone. He deceives, exploits and pursues, but he doesn't murder.
To make sense of it, we need to recall the story. Jacob is running from his brother Esau, who has vowed to kill him, and finds refuge with his uncle Laban. At first Laban seems a generous host. But it soon turns out that his generosity is really a calculation. Jacob works seven years to marry Rachel, and on the wedding night Laban swaps in her sister Leah. To win Rachel, Jacob has to work another seven years, and then six more. Laban changes his wages ten times and treats him as an unpaid labourer, almost a slave. Even Laban's own daughters complain: "Does he not regard us as strangers? He has sold us."
Yet Jacob doesn't break. Thanks to his skill as a shepherd, he manages to build flocks of his own and support a large family. And it is precisely this success that enrages Laban and his sons, who claim Jacob has grown rich at their expense. In the end Jacob has no choice but to flee, and Laban chases after him, declaring: "The daughters are my daughters, the children are my children, the flocks are my flocks. All that you see is mine!" Whatever he seemed to have given, in his own eyes he had never really given at all.
Here lies the answer to the riddle. Pharaoh was a one-time enemy. Laban is a pattern that repeats itself again and again. Jewish history has seen this story many times: Jews fled persecution and found refuge among other nations. Their hosts welcomed them at first because they saw them as useful, and Jews did indeed contribute greatly to the prosperity of the places they lived. But they refused to give up their identity and their freedom. And when they succeeded, their success stirred envy, the envy turned to anger, and the anger turned to hatred. The exploited were accused of being the exploiters. It happened in Egypt after the days of Joseph, in Greece and Rome, in the empires of the Middle Ages, in 19th-century Europe and after the Russian Revolution.
The American scholar Amy Chua, in her book *World on Fire*, describes the same phenomenon all over the world, and not only among Jews. Hatred is usually directed at a group that meets three conditions. It is a minority, so people aren't afraid to attack it. It is successful, so people envy it. And it is conspicuous, so people notice it. Jacob in Laban's house met all three: he was alone against an entire family, he prospered, and his success was there for all to see in his flocks. In her view, the State of Israel, a small and successful country in a much larger neighbourhood, provokes a similar reaction today.
And yet this is not only a story about hatred. Above all, it is a story about Jacob. In a situation that seemed hopeless, Jacob held on to his dignity and his independence. He didn't despair, didn't give in and didn't agree to become someone else's property. He contributed to the prosperity of others but refused to be exploited. In this way he became a symbol for every minority, every small nation, every refugee, and every person who says: I too am human. I too have rights. I too am free.
If Laban is the eternal pattern of hatred, Jacob is the eternal pattern of the ability to survive it. And that is his message to all of us: hatred does not have the final word. Freedom does.
|