|
Member Columnist — Kim Scott, LMFT
Using the Parent, Adult, and Child Model in Couple’s Therapy
Wife: Honey, you are driving too close to that car! Slow down! Husband: Stop telling me what to do! I know how to drive! Damn, you get so hysterical! (He
hits the gas and swerves around the car in front of them.)
Wife: I am never going to drive with you again!
Husband: Fine! You drive if you think you are so much better! I’m done chauffeuring you
around!
The couple brings this flash temper tantrum into therapy. Each hopes I will side with them. But
instead of taking sides, I invite them to pause. I ask them to replay the interaction and reflect on
what was going on:
Remind clients that stress in times of uncertainty and change is a normal response. Simply
naming this can reduce shame and help them feel less alone.
Where were they coming from at that moment?
What could they have done differently?
How might the behavior of each have impacted their partner?
There are of course many ways to approach a dynamic like this in couple’s therapy. One of my
go-to frameworks is looking at interactions through the lens of Parent, Adult, and Child. This is a
core concept from Transactional Analysis developed by Eric Berne in the late 1950s and early
1960s.
Transactional Analysis is based on the idea that we all operate from three internal ego states: the
Parent, Adult, and Child. While it is not often emphasized in modern couples therapy, it remains
a powerful and accessible way to help couples recognize how they are showing up and how their
patterns impact one another.
What I appreciate most about this framework is how quickly it resonates. People tend to
recognize these parts within themselves almost immediately. It also pairs beautifully with other
approaches to relationship therapy. Whether we are using Gottman, EFT, or Imago, we are often
describing the same interactions, just in different language.
The Parent, Adult, and Child model helps us recognize how we are showing up, while these
other approaches help us understand what is happening underneath and between us. When we
put those together, we create real opportunities for change.
Let’s come back to our couple.
The wife is speaking from her Parent ego state, more specifically her Critical Parent. This part
can show up as controlling, correcting, or overly directive. It often carries a tone of urgency or
authority, and you might hear words like “should,” “always,” or “never.” While this part is often
rooted in care or concern, it can land as criticism or control. It is also important to remember that
the Parent can show up in nurturing and supportive ways.
Unlike the wife’s response, the husband’s response comes from the Child ego state, specifically
the Rebellious Adapted Child. Just as the Parent has different expressions, so does the Child. The
Child can be authentic, playful, curious, and connected, or adapted, which may show up as
people-pleasing or rebellious.
In this moment, the husband’s Rebellious Child shows up through defensiveness, dismissiveness,
and acting out. He disregards his wife’s concern and reacts impulsively, hitting the gas pedal and
speeding past the car in front of him.
And just like that, we have a familiar cycle: Critical Parent meets Rebellious Child.
I imagine this dynamic sounds as familiar to you as it does to me. Once couples get pulled into
this kind of cycle, each partner tends to trigger the other. When one partner speaks from a Parent
ego state, it often invites a Child response in the other, and the pattern reinforces itself.
So how do we help couples shift out of this dynamic?
The first step is awareness. When couples can begin to identify the roles they are stepping into,
and how those roles impact their partner, they create space for change.
Here’s a helpful hint. When a partner responds with defensiveness or anger, it is often a sign they
are experiencing the message as critical or blaming. In Transactional Analysis language, this is a
Critical Parent tone, which tends to activate the defensive Child in the other person.
While we cannot control our partner’s behavior, we can begin to notice these patterns in
ourselves and the reactions they receive from our partner. When we do, we gain valuable
feedback about how to shift toward a more respectful, Adult-to-Adult way of communicating,
which is far more likely to invite a positive response.
So what does that actually look like?
When we are speaking from our Adult, we:
Pause and regulate before responding so that we are responding rather than reacting
Use a gentle start-up instead of defending, for example: “I’m sorry my driving is
stressing you out. I’ll slow down.”
Use “I” statements rather than blame: “I feel anxious when we are driving this close to
the car in front of us. I know you are a good driver, and it would really help me relax if
we had a bit more space.”
Get curious instead of defensive: “I can see you are feeling anxious. How can I help you
feel more comfortable?”
Step back and take a meta view, almost like observing the interaction from the outside,
and asking: What dance are we in right now, and how can I shift it?
One of my favorite interventions came from a therapist my husband and I once worked with. He
suggested that in those heated moments, we ask ourselves: “What could I do right now that
would surprise my partner?” In other words, how can I surprise my partner by breaking this
pattern?
That simple question can interrupt old patterns and create space for something new.
While Transactional Analysis may feel a bit old school and is not always emphasized in an
evidence-based practice, its concepts can be thoughtfully integrated into modern treatment.
Sometimes a small shift in perspective can make a powerful difference.
Kim Scott, LMFT (MFT21184) is a licensed marriage, family, and child therapist who practices
in Granada Hills. Ms. Scott sees couples and individuals using an integrative approach and
EMDR. For more articles by Ms. Scott follow her on Substack at @therapeuticmusings or visit
her website at www.kimscottmft.com. Ms. Scott can be reached at 818-309-7780 or kimscottmft@gmail.com.
|