The Great Fall Debate: Pumpkin Spice—

Love It or Leave It?


Every year, while summer is still packing its bags, pumpkin spice makes its grand return.


Suddenly, it’s everywhere. It’s in coffee, muffins, candles, cereal and even products that no reasonable person ever expected to taste like pumpkin.


For some people, that first pumpkin-spice latte officially marks the beginning of fall. For others, it signals the start of several months spent avoiding cinnamon-scented everything.


So, where do you stand in the great fall debate?


Team Pumpkin Spice

Pumpkin-spice fans don’t simply enjoy the flavour—they celebrate its arrival. They’re ready the moment the first seasonal drink appears on a café menu, even if it’s still warm enough outside to wear shorts. They proudly order their latte, admire its whipped cream and pretend they aren’t sweating while drinking it.


For these devoted fans, pumpkin spice is more than a flavour. It’s a feeling. It brings to mind cozy sweaters, colourful leaves, cool evenings and the comforting smell of something baking in the oven. One sip can make an ordinary September morning feel like a scene from a perfect fall movie.


What Is Pumpkin Spice, Anyway?

Despite its name, pumpkin spice doesn’t necessarily contain pumpkin. It’s usually a mixture of warm spices such as cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger and cloves—the flavours commonly used in pumpkin pie.

That explains why it works so well in coffee, cookies, muffins and other sweet treats.


It does not necessarily explain pumpkin-spice air freshener, lip balm, pet treats or potato chips. Some mysteries are better left unsolved.


Team “It Has Gone Too Far”

Not everyone is excited when pumpkin spice season returns. Some people find the flavour too sweet, too strong or simply overused. They watch in disbelief as an ordinary grocery store transforms into a pumpkin-spice wonderland overnight.


One seasonal drink might be acceptable. Pumpkin-spice toothpaste would be a clear sign that society has lost its way.


Members of this team would rather enjoy apple cider, hot chocolate, maple treats or a regular cup of coffee that tastes exactly the same in October as it did in July.


Why Do We Love Seasonal Flavours?

Part of the appeal may be that pumpkin spice is only available for a limited time. Its return creates a sense of tradition and gives us something familiar to look forward to each year.


Seasonal flavours can also bring back happy memories—family dinners, autumn walks, Thanksgiving gatherings or cool afternoons spent baking.


Even people who don’t like pumpkin spice often have another flavour or tradition that makes fall feel official.


Is There a Middle Ground?

Of course. You can enjoy one pumpkin-spice treat without replacing everything in your kitchen with it.

Perhaps you like pumpkin pie but not pumpkin coffee. Maybe you enjoy the scent of a cinnamon candle but draw the line at pumpkin-spice cereal.


There are no rules. Fall is big enough for pumpkin-spice lovers, apple-cider drinkers, hot-chocolate fans and people who simply want their coffee left alone.


So, Love It or Leave It?

Whether you count down the days until pumpkin spice returns or avoid it until winter, there’s no denying that it has become one of fall’s biggest traditions.


The real question isn’t whether pumpkin spice belongs in autumn. It’s how far we’re willing to let it go.

Pumpkin-spice latte? Absolutely. Pumpkin-spice potato chips? Absolutely not.

Before You Begin Refilling

TREASURE TOWER BLOG

The Best Classic Pumpkin Pie Recipe 


Few desserts say fall quite like a homemade pumpkin pie. With its flaky crust, creamy filling and warm mixture of cinnamon, ginger and nutmeg, it’s the kind of dessert that makes the entire house smell wonderful.



Pumpkin pie may look impressive, but it’s surprisingly simple to prepare. This recipe uses canned pure pumpkin, which creates a smooth and consistent filling without the extra work of cooking and puréeing a fresh pumpkin.


How did you like this email?
Positive        Neutral        Negative

Treasure Tower Rewards Canada

3560 190 Street Unit 107

Surrey, BC V3Z 0P6

877-889-5439 ext. 87

Instagram  YouTube  Google My Business