|
Shortly you will receive your Brookhaven tax bills for 2025 and you will notice a substantial increase in the assessment for garbage collection. Beginning next year, the annual cost to the community for garbage collection will increase to $1,284,000 from the current year’s $807,007. That increase will be reflected in our tax bills.
The reasons for the major increase are numerous, including the absence of competition in bidding for the contract, an increase in refuse, and rising costs due to inflation.
We are extremely frustrated that we have been thrust into this position, despite our extensive efforts to mitigate the situation. It is exacerbated by the fact that the contract for garbage collection is between the Town of Brookhaven and the company to whom they award the contract. FIPPOA is not a party to the contract and has no control over the outcome.
Here is the background:
Over the years, the number of garbage collectors serving Fire Island has diminished from three down to one. For many decades, the Pines was served by Tommy Esposito and his family; however, he retired from the business approximately four years ago, which coincided with Brookhaven awarding the current contract to Brownie for the first time.
Though we have no statutory role in the contracting process, we have worked to increase competition. I met with the owner of Stang, the company Brookhaven contracted with in Cherry Grove, to establish a potential future relationship. However, Stang also recently retired, which resulted in Brownie taking over the Cherry Grove contract.
Due to these recent retirements, the only company that bid on the new Pines contract was Brownie, thereby giving them a de facto monopoly over garbage collection.
Davis Park was the first Brookhaven community to receive a new contract with a single bidder, and their costs increased dramatically. Other communities will renew contracts over the next couple of years, so the importance in creating other options will become even more pervasive on Fire Island.
We have urged Brookhaven to consider taking over garbage collection themselves. The answer has been that, while that is a possibility for the future, it is not currently an option. Encouragingly, in my conversations with Neil Foley, Brookhaven Town Deputy Supervisor and our Councilman, he has assured me that Brookhaven will put together a task force to look at bringing these services in-house.
We will continue to do all that we can to encourage healthy competition, but ultimately, we rely on Brookhaven to contract for our garbage collection.
On a positive note, over the past four years, we have been lobbying Brookhaven to provide glass recycling. We are pleased to share that beginning next year, containers designated for glass will be located in the harbor.
While we would prefer curbside pick-up on Wednesday recycling days, having containers in the harbor for drop-off is a beginning. If this new program is successful, we will be in a better position to receive curbside in the future. Information regarding the start date and process will follow once the details have been worked out. I would like to thank Brian Bonci, Matt Kaing and Jake Tinsley, who formed Pines Local Solutions, which will remain an option, for their terrific success highlighting the necessity and feasibility of glass recycling.
One final item: Since FIPPOA owns the freight dock from which Brownie operates, the contract stipulates an annual payment to FIPPOA for use of the dock. For many years, Brookhaven held the payment fixed between $90,000 and $100,000. This was during an extended period when operating expenses were increasing at a substantially higher rate than what was essentially a flat dockage fee. We were finally successful in getting Brookhaven to gradually increase the fee over the past four years to the current rate of $120,000, and the new contract further increases it to $150,000. FIPPOA is currently in the process of repairing damage done to the freight dock from frequent usage, so the timing of the increase is good considering the costs we incur to maintain and operate the facility.
Garbage collection in the Pines poses complex challenges to the community. We will continue to press for solutions in the months to come.
Best,
Henry
|