We Have an Agreement! A Win for Maricopa County Voters
We have an agreement!
After months of lawsuits, court rulings, appeals, accusations, and uncertainty, the Maricopa County Recorder and the Board of Supervisors have reached a settlement.
This is a win for the voters of Maricopa County.
I am greatly appreciative of Recorder Justin Heap, Chairwoman Kate Brophy McGee, Supervisor Debbie Lesko, and Supervisor Thomas Galvin for helping bring this dispute to an end.
On Tuesday, July 14, 2026, the Maricopa County Board of Supervisors held a special meeting to consider the settlement agreement. Recorder Heap had signed the agreement prior to the meeting.
My thoughts
This is a win-win. The Maricopa County Board of Supervisors got much of what it wanted, the Recorder got much of what he wanted, but most importantly, the voters of Maricopa County received the best possible outcome. The costly litigation is over, uncertainty has been reduced, and both sides can finally move forward and focus on the important work of administering our elections.
I believe most people in Maricopa County breathed a collective sigh of relief when the settlement was announced. Well, almost everyone.
Sadly, a handful of social media agitators and influencers seem determined to keep the fight alive. They are already trying to spin the agreement as a victory for one side and a defeat for the other. Yet both Recorder Justin Heap and members of the Board of Supervisors have publicly described this agreement as a win-win and expressed appreciation for mediator Judge Christopher Coury and the more than 25 hours of work that went into reaching a resolution.
Some people simply are not happy unless they are attacking others, being petty, or creating chaos. That is unfortunate, because this should be a moment when we acknowledge that compromise worked.
As you read this article, I hope you understand that I am genuinely happy for everyone involved. I have given Recorder Heap plenty of grief in the past when I believed criticism was warranted. Today, however, I have nothing but praise for him and the Board members who worked to reach this agreement. They put the voters of Maricopa County first—and that deserves recognition.
How we got here
On July 14, Supervisor Debbie Lesko made the motion to approve the settlement, and the motion was seconded by Supervisor Thomas Galvin. Supervisor Steve Gallardo voted no. Supervisor Mark Stewart was not in attendance and did not call in to vote.
The agreement was reached after more than 25 hours of mediation and ends the litigation between the Recorder and the Board. The appeal will be dismissed, and the agreement sets aside the previous court rulings involved in the dispute.
Under the settlement, the Recorder will remain responsible for early voting, while the Board of Supervisors retains responsibility for same-day and emergency voting.
One of the largest changes involves election technology.
Approximately $15 million in one-time funding already within state and county budget resources will be moved to the Recorder's Office, allowing the Recorder to build a separate election IT system. The Board will retain the existing system. For now, the two offices will co-own the current system while the transition takes place.
This agreement provides something Maricopa County desperately needs: certainty.
Supervisor Lesko thanked Judge Christopher Coury, who served as mediator, and called on everyone involved to work together moving forward.
Supervisor Thomas Galvin also thanked Recorder Heap for signing the agreement and recognized the attorneys involved in reaching the settlement. Galvin pointed out that lawsuits are rarely good for government operations and expressed relief that everyone can now get back to work. He also called on the Arizona Legislature to clarify election laws so future disputes over responsibilities can hopefully be avoided.
Chairwoman Kate Brophy McGee said the settlement will allow Maricopa County elections to run smoothly moving forward. She expressed hope that the agreement will provide much-needed clarity for both the Recorder and the Board—but, most importantly, for voters. She also thanked Judge Coury for his work.
Supervisor Steve Gallardo was clearly unhappy with the settlement and the events leading up to it. Gallardo criticized the courts' involvement and the requirement that the Board follow the 12-point plan. He accused Heap of being willing to accept fewer election responsibilities and suggested the Recorder wanted to do the minimum.
Gallardo also criticized Heap's use of America First Legal and raised concerns about what he views as a "hyper-partisan" Recorder's Office. He specifically referenced partisan social media posts by Sam Stone during business hours. Gallardo, who began his career in the Recorder's Office, made it clear he continues to have serious concerns about the direction of the office.
All sides gave a little. All sides gained something.
Recorder Heap will have the resources and authority to build his own IT system and oversee early voting. The Board retains same-day and emergency voting responsibilities. The appeal is dismissed. The lawsuits end. Election officials can return their focus to administering elections.
That is what a settlement is supposed to do.
This is a win-win agreement, but the biggest winners are the voters of Maricopa County.
We should all be happy that this dispute has been resolved. Now it is time for the Recorder and the Board of Supervisors to work together, administer our elections, and rebuild confidence with the voters they serve.
We have an agreement. Let's move forward.
|