|
We’ve been here before.
Financial markets work because people have different beliefs. Every trade needs a buyer who expects a stock to rise and a seller who expects it to fall. That tension doesn’t hurt the system. It is the system. Democracy works the same way. While a lot of Americans believe our country has never been more divided than it is now, history tells a different story.
The founders argued constantly.
The founders of the United States didn’t agree on much. Documentary filmmaker Ken Burns noted that the 13 colonies were so different, they were like separate countries. There was little trust between the leaders. At the time, the word “democracy” had a negative connotation because people associated it with mob rule.
“You begin to see that democracy is the unintended consequence rather than the intention of the [American] revolution. [Film Producer Sarah] Botstein said the concept that all men are created equal set up this ‘brilliant, totally new idea of what a government should be.’ And it changed the world forever,” according to Burns.
The first contentious campaign
Following the Revolution, the founders’ quarrels remained on hold. A reluctant George Washington won the first two presidential elections, receiving every electoral vote each time. When he declined a third term, the country held its first race for the presidency.
In that election, the Federalist Party branded Thomas Jefferson an anarchist. Jefferson’s party, the Democratic-Republicans, cast John Adams as a monarchist. Since the Constitution didn’t require separate votes for president and vice president, the runner-up in the race became vice president. Adams won by three electoral votes, and Jefferson was his vice president.
The 1800 rematch tested the young republic again. Jefferson and Aaron Burr tied with 73 electoral votes each, and the House of Representatives had to decide the election. After 35 ballots, Jefferson prevailed, and Burr became VP. The election marked the first peaceful transfer of power from one party to another. It also led to the ratification of the Twelfth Amendment, creating separate votes for the president and the vice president.
Division is nothing new
The reality is that throughout history, Americans have disagreed with one another. Ken Burns argues that Americans stood further apart during the Civil War, Reconstruction, the Great Depression, and the Vietnam War era than they do today. Battles over women’s suffrage and civil rights split the country, too.
The United States has endured throughout it all, and we continue to participate in the great experiment known as Democracy. It is an aspiration pursued by each generation. Ken Burns said it simply, “You don’t have to agree...You just have to be involved.”
As the midterm elections approach, that may be one of the most important lessons history offers. Learn about the candidates and the issues, talk with friends and neighbors who see things your way and who see things differently, then cast your ballot. The founders argued their way into a republic. Our part is to keep it going.
Last week, as earnings season began, major U.S. stock indexes gained. The Standard & Poor’s 500 and Nasdaq Composite Indexes both hit record highs during the week, according to Alex Rosenberg of Barron’s. Yields on many maturities of U.S. Treasuries moved lower over the week.
|