A View from Abroad

Once a month, In Other News features a short op-ed heavily informed by the European perspective. We hope that these special monthly pieces will offer our readers an enriched understanding of global events and allow for a more robust international risk calculus.


In Africa, China trades aid and investment for political and economic gains -- without the limitations of the West. In early September, Chinese President Xi warmly welcomed more than 50 African leaders at the China-Africa Summit in Beijing. As during previous Summits, China announced a substantial package of aid and investment for Africa, especially for infrastructure, as well as trade agreements totaling more than $50 billion. Although the realization of these packages is difficult to grasp from the outside, in Africa these investments are readily visible -- even if not always successful. Indeed, for decades China has demonstrated a dedicated and strategic interest in Africa while the West has been more conditional in its approach.


However, this year China’s economic package was lower than before, reflecting both the current Chinese economic challenges and the reluctance of African countries to accrue more Chinese debt. China has also been unwilling to forego debt and interest payments on earlier loans, adding further hesitation. Many African nations also want to move up the production value chain, shifting from solely exporting raw materials to adding more value in production and processing of raw materials.


But while China’s financial offering decreased, its latest package was accompanied by greater soft power and governance-related elements. China is offering scholarships for African students in Chinese universities and education and training in (one) party politics and state administration. Security cooperation was also included: aid and training for military and police, joint exercises, and mine clearance, all in the context of China’s Global Security Strategy. And these Chinese investments and cooperation projects come without human rights or government-related conditions-- in contrast to the demands of European initiatives.


Further, as China continues to promote the sale of hi-tech equipment that allows a state to monitor and control its citizens, greater anti-democratic tendencies in African countries can also be expected. Indeed, dictators and autocracies replicate techniques and reinforce one other through copycat policies. At the Summit, for example, a friendly meeting between Xi Jinping and Assimi Goita – the junta leader of Mali who is boycotted by most international leaders – exemplified this trend. While African countries continue to hedge their bets on the global playing field, if Chinese conditions are limited to paying lip service to Chinese desiderata at the UN in New York, for African leaders the equation is simple.

 

Meanwhile in the EU, the newly elected European Commission will likely strive to become more of a global player once operational later this fall. This means a greater focus on Africa, which was detailed in a recent report by former European Central Bank President Draghi where he recommends that Europe diversify the origin of its raw materials to become less dependent on countries like China and Russia.  

 

For a large part, however, it will be up to African countries whether Chinese and Western investments will be competitive or complementary. The Lobito railway corridor is an example of the latter, where US and EU investments in hardware aim to connect Angolan ports with mineral extracting industries in the DRC and Zambia while China is simultaneously making similar and connected investments. The key question is where the exports of crucial raw materials will meet their destiny -- East or West.

 

Indeed, as interest in Africa expands on a global scale, the EU will be confronted with the question of whether the human rights requirements it demands should continue or if European national interests should supersede conditional investments. In the meantime, it makes sense to enhance the US-EU dialogue on this issue as China forges ahead with a reach that not only ignores the autocratic-leaning domestic policies of some African nations but encourages them to closely resemble its own.


The Arkin Group is a strategic intelligence firm offering investigative research, due diligence, international risk and crisis consulting, and security & preparedness services. We can be contacted at 212-333-0280.

590 Madison Avenue, 21st Floor | New York, New York 10022 | 212-333-0280

© 2022 The Arkin Group