Balance Needed in the Changes to Accessory Living Unit Regulations | |
On November 17th at 4:30pm, the Board of Supervisors will consider changes to the Fairfax County Zoning Ordinance (ZO) addressing accessory living units (ALUs), commonly understood as a separate living area or home addition, whether interior or detached. ALUs can serve legitimate and valuable purposes. If done correctly, they can accommodate aging parents, adult children and caregivers, provide modest rental income, provide better opportunities for our military families, make better use of existing housing and create additional housing units to address our housing affordability issues with minimal impact on our existing suburban communities. If done incorrectly, ALUs can cause issues from parking challenges, to crowding schools and parks, to detracting from neighboring properties or the established character of the street or neighborhood and have the unintended impact of essentially changing the zoning for the neighborhood.
To balance these needs, I believe we need an ordinance that allows additional housing that is similar to and compatible with the principal dwelling and the neighborhood it joins, and that does not detract from neighboring properties or the established character of the street. Interior and basement conversions typically meet these objectives with relatively little impact to the surrounding neighborhood. Exterior or detached alterations can threaten this balance. They can also be a challenge for our environmental goals by increasing impervious space and land coverage, especially in the Occoquan Watershed.
In Fairfax County, ALUs are defined as:
A secondary dwelling unit established in conjunction with and clearly subordinate to a single-family detached dwelling unit. These living spaces include areas for eating, cooking, sleeping, living, and sanitation, and the space is occupied as a permanent residence.
ALUs are attractive to many residents, and we have heard from those who wish to create ALUs on their properties over the last several years. Concurrently, the Board has also received accounts of some ALUs that have become a nuisance in their communities. Some of the cited issues have been looming heights, overcrowded parking, reduced privacy from dwellings constructed close to property lines, and diminished property value from additions that look out of place. In Springfield District, I’ve seen firsthand how some exterior additions can dramatically impact a neighborhood’s quality of life.
| | |
The key problems with the current regulation of ALUs are:
1. The regulations do not account for the vastly different characteristics of homes and neighborhoods throughout the County. Current requirements primarily depend on square footage restrictions while failing to account for factors like the size of a given lot, location of the ALU on the lot, or height of the addition. We need modifications to the ZO that more clearly outline what is allowable for different types of lots. I’m happy to see that possible changes to the ZO as approved by the Planning Commission include restrictions on maximum height of an ALU according to lot size and prohibiting ALUs for townhouse lots.
2. The bureaucracy surrounding ALU approvals is costly for taxpayers and burdensome for staff. Our zoning process is very important and protects our community from haphazard development. However, when ALUs are reasonably situated in a community, not impacting the privacy of neighbors, property values, or parking, then we should streamline the process for residents to pursue this affordable housing solution. Under the current regulations, a homeowner is required to renew their ALU permit initially for two years, then for successive periods of up to five years, regardless of conditions. Under the proposed changes, if the homeowner meets several requirements, their ALU is allowed by-right, with no renewal process. Staff carefully considered the by-right conditions based on community feedback and by evaluating ALU regulations in other jurisdictions.
Key Decision Points on the Proposed New Regulations – On Tuesday, after the public hearing, the Board will be making critical decisions on the ALU ZO amendment including the following key decisions. I welcome your feedback on these key areas:
-
What Lot Size to Allow Detached ALUs By Right (no Special Permit required) – Detached ALUs are separate or semi-detached housing units on the same property. Staff advertised a broad range of lot sizes and the Planning Commission recommended by right for lots over 15,000 square feet. I am looking for input but believe lots less than 36,000 square feet probably should require a Special Permit because the lots keep in line with Comprehensive Plan Recommendations for 1-2 dwelling units per acre.
-
Requiring Owner Occupancy – I believe we should keep the current requirement that one of the living units be occupied by the property owner to prevent companies or individuals from buying lots, doubling the density and renting both units.
-
Limit on Occupancy of the ALU – The Planning Commission recommended a limit of 4 persons in the ALU. This would be in conjunction with the main residence occupancy that has a limit of no more than four unrelated persons. I believe that we should increase the ALU occupancy from the current 2 to 3 adults but not to four adults. This would allow for a small family to occupy the ALU unit or grandparents with a caregiver.
-
Parking – The Planning Commission voted to not include a requirement for an additional parking space for an ALU. I believe that there needs to be a requirement for adequate parking before ALUs are approved.
-
ALUs in Townhome Communities – I support staff and the Planning Commission’s recommendations to not allow ALUs in townhomes.
-
Compatibility and Subordination should be Distinct Requirements - The compatibility and subordination requirements must be enforceable.
More Information and Provide Feedback
To view the current ALU regulations and some of the proposed changes, you can see more details here. If you want to share feedback on ALUs, please reach out to my office by replying to this email or calling us at 703-451-8873. If you would like to sign up to testify at the public hearing, you can do so here.
| | |
Good Scout Awards
Attended the Mike Daniel’s Technology Good Scout Awards, hosted by the National Capital Area Council and Scouting America, to recognize and honor leaders in the technology community. This year they honored current Amentum CEO, John Heller, for his leadership in the technology industry and his Scout Oath values.
| |
ArtsFairfax Awards
Great turnout for the ArtsFairfax 2026 Arts Awards. Arts of all kinds play a vital role in our community. Congratulations to all of the honorees for the work you do in our community.
| | |
Community Leader Luncheon
Joined Garrison Commander Col. Samuel R. Allen, Fort Belvoir Garrison Commander and community leaders for the annual Fort Belvoir Community Leaders Luncheon to promote collaboration between Fort Belvoir and the community.
| |
Chicago Honor Flight
Had the honor of presenting long time Chicago Honor Flight volunteer, Arnie Daxe, with a Fairfax County Board of Supervisor' Resolution recognizing and thanking him for his years of volunteer service.
| | Other News and Information | | |
Other News and Information
- FACETS Holiday Hope
- Coffee and Conversation with Caregivers (November 13)
- NOVA Dementia Caregivers Conference (November 14)
- Fairfax Recycles Day (November 14)
- Dam Siren Test (November 18
- Fairfax City Holiday Craft Show (November 21 & 22)
| | |
FACETS Holiday Hope
FACETS is now holding their Holiday Hope Food Drive where they hope to fill 1,200 grocery bags with grocery store gift cards and non-perishable unopened items to help families in need this holiday season. Facet will be accepting drop off donations at their main office located at 10700 Page Avenue, Suite 160 Fairfax, VA 22030. For more information on the great work FACETS does in our community, please see here.
| | |
Coffee and Conversation with Caregivers Conference (November 13)
AARP is hosting its Free Coffee Friday giving members of the community the opportunity to connect with fellow caregivers while exploring resources to support their mental health and well-being. All are welcome, but you must register beforehand. For more information and to register please see here.
| |
NOVA Dementia Caregivers Conference (November 14)
Join caregivers for educational sessions on dementia treatment, research, and local support services designed to enhance well-being for caregivers and their loved ones on November 14th from 8 am until 4 pm at the Inova Conference Center. To learn more and to register, please see here.
| |
Fairfax Recycles Day (November 14)
Fairfax County’s Solid Waste Management Program and Stormwater Management will be celebrating Fairfax Recycles Day on Saturday, November 14, 2026 from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m., at Glen Forest Elementary School. This celebration event will have various giveaways and will also be collecting electronic and battery donations, which are typically challenging to dispose of. For more information on the event, please see here.
| |
Dam Siren Test (November 18)
On November 18th at 10 am, an audible test of the siren system along the banks of the Occoquan River between the Town of Occoquan and Belmont Bay will occur. The test will last roughly 5 minutes, no action is needed during the test, it is simply a safety measure to ensure the siren is functioning properly.
| |
Fairfax City Holiday Craft Show (November 21 & 22)
Fairfax City will be hosting their annual Holiday Craft Show on November 21st and 22nd. This premium arts and crafts festival will have artisans from all over the country selling a wide variety of items just in time for the holiday season. For more information, please see here.
| | |
Crash is a friendly, energetic boy who approaches life with enthusiasm and a big personality. He loves attention, enjoys playtime, and is always ready for pets, belly rubs, and fun adventures with his people. Crash can get a little excited when he's feeling playful, but his affectionate nature shines through. He's looking for an active home that will help him channel his energy and continue building his confidence. If you're searching for a fun-loving companion who's eager to be part of the action, Crash might be your perfect match!
This pet is eligible for an Adoption Audition! What is an Adoption Audition? It's a 5-day, no-strings-attached, trial adoption period. You can take this pet home to try it out! Interested? Come to the shelter any time during open hours and talk to one of our Customer Care staff!
If you'd like to schedule a visit to meet Crash, please see here: Adopt a Dog | Animal Shelter
| | | |
Supervisor Pat Herrity
6140 Rolling Road,
Springfield, VA 22152
(703) 451-8873
| | | | | |