logo-wide2.png
 

Another Message from the Leadership of FIPPOA and Trailblazers Park

There has been a great deal of discussion in the community since last weekend’s events at Trailblazers Park. We would like to address the issue and outline the steps we plan to take.

 

The event was held to honor 16 trailblazing members of the Fire Island Pines and larger LGBTQ+ communities, with honorees such as Pines residents Richard Burns, Kevin Cathcart, and Jim Pepper, and national LGBTQ+ icons such as Urvashi Vaid and Andrea Jenkins. However, both the ceremony and the events that followed saw the focus turn unexpectedly to the war in the Mideast.

 

On Sunday morning, some members of ACT UP NY tore down the flag honoring Ritchie Torres, the first gay Afro-Latino member of Congress and a high-profile defender of Israel. They replaced it with a flag for Cecilia Gentili, a celebrated leader in the trans rights movement who passed away this February.

 

The ACT UP members also hung a second flag, featuring the group’s logo and a watermelon, a symbol that has been widely displayed in this year’s protests as symbolizing support for Palestinians. Later that day, that flag was torn down by a community member.

 

Many in the Pines considered ACT UP’s action an act of vandalism requiring police intervention. Some expressed alarm that it was a threatening gesture to the Jewish community. Others saw it as a legitimate act of activist theater, consistent with the principles that marked the work of many of the trailblazers being honored. It was not the first time, and will not be the last, that different segments of the LGBTQ+ community have been at odds with one another. What was unfortunate was that this took place in the Pines, a haven of freedom for LGBTQ+ people dating back over a half century.

 

While we honor the tradition of activism ingrained into the DNA of the LGBTQ+ rights movement, almost a year of work was put into the effort to honor our 16 trailblazers, and we believe it was wrong for anyone to mar that work because they didn’t agree with the selection of trailblazers. Our goal as the planning body for the event was to celebrate the trailblazers and their storied histories, not to see it used to divide the community.

 

In fact, a moment reflecting true cultural change took place at the Pines Harbor ceremony. It was when Andrea Jenkins, the first Black transgender woman elected to public office in the country (representing Ward 8, where George Floyd was murdered, in the Minneapolis City Council) took the microphone and read an author’s poem about love and his fight for respect as an LGBTQ+ person of color. That would have been unthinkable even 10 years ago.

 

We chose not to involve the police. Little physical damage was done to the structure, and we believed that doing so would have inflamed the situation.

 

In order to move forward together as a community, the Trailblazers Task Force is taking the following actions:

 

  • Realizing that replacing Ritchie Torres’ flag would likely result in its being torn down repeatedly, we are going to find another way to honor his contributions as an LGBTQ+ trailblazer.


  • The ACT UP Cecilia Gentili flag will be taken down. In recognition of her contributions to the LGBTQ+ cause, we will celebrate her and two other giants who recently passed away, David Mixner and Frank Stark, in the FIPPOA display case as an exhibit in the harbor for Gay Pride month.


  • In addition, Cecilia Gentili will be one of the 16 trailblazers to be honored in the next cycle (new trailblazers are honored every other year). We note that the task force had already decided to do so several months ago.


  • The Task Force will re-evaluate its selection criteria in order to, with hope, avoid this kind of situation in the future.

 

We understand that these steps may not satisfy everyone, but we hope they are received in the spirit of reconciliation in which they were taken. Advocacy, protest, and even conflict are all part of LGBTQ+ history, but even amid our disagreements we can continue to build a brighter future together. It is not surprising that the issues of free speech and the Mideast war are being debated in the Pines as they are across America. What is surprising is that the same incivility and personal attacks that mar civil discourse in the rest of the country have also invaded the Pines. We can do better.

 

To that end, we once again honor the LGBTQ+ trailblazers whose achievements were briefly eclipsed by last week’s events. They are:

 

Richard Burns

Kevin Cathcart

Dan Choi

Stormé DeLarverie

Andrea Jenkins

Rachel Levine

Jim Pepper

Paul Popham

Megan Rapinoe

Bamby Salcedo

Wanda Sykes

Ritchie Torres

Urvashi Vaid

Phill Wilson

 

  

Sincerely,

 

Henry Robin, FIPPOA president

Doug Harris, Co-chair, Honoring Trailblazers Task Force 




 

Click here to renew or join FIPPOA Today!

Screen Shot 2022-02-10 at 4.27.54 PM.png
 
 

Henry Robin, President

Allan Baum, Vice President

Alan Brodherson, Secretary

Eric Sawyer, Treasurer

 

Gary Clinton, Greg Henniger, Bill Hildebrandt, Andrew Kirtzman,

Chris Mai, Charles Montorio-Archer, Anthony Pietrangolare, Nate Pinsley, Leland Rechis, Russell Saray, and Ed Schulhafer

 

Building our community together.