|
Navigating the Storm Front: A Look Back at Four Decades of Recession Recovery Policies and Their Effect on Long Island School District Funding
by
Dr. John Galligan, Miller Place UFSD BOE Trustee
&
Joseph Dragone, Retried Assistant Superintendent for Business and Operation
Abridged version originally published as a feature article in the Winter 2025 edition of the New York ASBO Reporter.
Historically, Long Island school districts have grappled with complex financial challenges tied to fluctuating economic conditions, fiscal constraints, and rising costs from state and federal mandates. The region's property-rich but income-poor dynamic leaves some communities with inflated tax liabilities, limiting access to adequate state aid. These challenges underscore the complex interplay between state and federal policy interventions, economic downturns, and the use of local taxes, which contribute to the region's notoriously high property taxes and overall cost of living. High property taxes challenge Long Island homeowners, particularly those on fixed incomes. The region's elevated property tax rates disproportionately burden individuals whose property values have increased without a corresponding rise in income. Currently, on average, 62% of the revenue sourced from Long Island School districts comes from property taxes, compared to 29% from state aid.
State and Federal Policy Impacts:
Long Island school districts face unique fiscal challenges due to their dependence on local revenue, restrictive tax caps, and reduced state aid. These issues are compounded during economic downturns, as evidenced by the Gulf War Recession and the Great Recession, which prompted significant budget cuts and long-lasting impacts on educational funding statewide.
For example, the 1990-1991 recession led to a $190 million state aid reduction, disproportionately affecting underfunded districts. Similarly, the 2008 Great Recession introduced the Gap Elimination Adjustment (GEA), which was introduced during the same timeframe as the 2011 New York State Property Tax Cap. This resulted in the slashing of billions from state aid between 2010 and 2015 without giving districts the option to offset these reductions by seeking additional local revenue.
A 2015 case study of twelve districts in the town of Islip, in Suffolk County, during the GEA and the 2011 Tax Cap implementation revealed a reliance on reserves, curbed instructional spending, and limited per-pupil expenditure growth to manage fiscal stress. It also showcased that rising healthcare and pension contributions further strained budgets. Since then, additional federal policies, such as the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), exacerbated the reliance on local revenue, as the $10,000 SALT deduction cap heightened resistance to proposing local tax increases to sustain critical funding needs.
Conclusion:
Long Island's schools require a balanced funding framework that accounts for rising educational costs and evolving standards. Collaboration among stakeholders is essential to drive legislative reform, ensuring sustainable and equitable funding that guarantees all students access to quality education. The current New York State Education Foundation Aid Formula was initially enacted in 2007 to address state-wide funding disparities. However, since its enactment, education standards have evolved, and the needs of the student population have changed significantly, requiring that school districts provide more services.
The authors recommend revising New York's funding model to address funding inequities and lessen dependence on local property wealth. Explore shifting toward funding systems that prioritize equity and adaptability to meet the evolving needs of students and communities. Review the state aid formula to reflect better income and community needs rather than property wealth. Explore the use of progressive property tax rates or income-based assessments. Consider exceptions in the Tax Cap for mandated expenses like pensions and healthcare to provide budget relief.
The authors recommend the use of comparative models from states such as New Jersey and Massachusetts, which account for specific cost drivers in tax cap calculations. Successful strategies from other states, such as New Jersey's tax cap adjustments and Massachusetts' Proposition 2½, offer a roadmap for New York to introduce exceptions for mandated costs like pensions and healthcare. Such adjustments could provide districts with fiscal relief while maintaining taxpayer protections.
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Dr. John Galligan is a Board of Education Trustee for the Miller Place Union Free School District and a longtime educator in the Sachem Central School District, serving as an administrator, teacher, and coach over the past 24 years. He holds a doctorate from St. John’s University, advanced degrees from Dowling College, and a BA from Wagner College. In 2017, he co-authored a study on education funding published by SCOPE Education Services.
Joseph Dragone has spent 54 years in public education on Long Island, most recently as Assistant Superintendent for Business and Operations in Roslyn. A former adjunct professor at Hofstra University, he has held leadership roles in NYSASPA and NYSASBO, and remains active in his community through library board service and founding several educational foundations.
|