Renter Wins Retaliation Case Against Landlord

Law Center staff attorney Madison Gray with Kadi Ashby.



Kadi Ashby, president of the Alden Park Tenant Association, has always paid her rent on time and in full. Yet in September 2025, her landlord issued an eviction notice to her, claiming that she violated her lease when she posted a public Zillow link in a tenant association group chat regarding the “multi-million dollar houses” occupied by the companies that own and manage Alden Park – a conglomeration of LLCs connected to out-of-state corporate real estate and private equity firms RAM Partners and L3C Capital. 


Ashby and her neighbors had formed the Alden Park Tenants Association in response to growing concerns about landlord neglect and mismanagement at the massive, historic East Falls apartment complex, which has been repeatedly cited by the city’s Department of Licenses and Inspections over the past year for falling concrete and crumbling balconies. 


After receiving the eviction notice, Ashby filed a complaint with the Philadelphia Fair Housing Commission, and the Law Center represented her at a two-day evidentiary hearing. At the hearing, we presented evidence that the lease termination notice was sent one day after the president of the landlord company instructed his lawyer to evict the “2-3 ringleaders” of the association. We argued that this was blatant retaliation, and that the notices were invalid and unenforceable under the city’s anti-retaliation ordinance. 


The commission agreed, ruling that the landlord’s “primary reason” for seeking to evict Ms. Ashby was because it was “unhappy with Tenant’s role in the Tenant Association” and that the stated reason for the non-renewal was a “convenient excuse to terminate Tenant without seeming to target Tenant as a member of the Tenant Association.” 


“Tenants like Kadi make us all safer when they speak up about the unsafe living conditions at their apartment complexes. But they can only do that when the city’s protections work as intended,” said Law Center staff attorney Madison Gray. 


Read more about the Law Center’s win here. 

A Win for a West Philly Garden!

In 2005, Elizabeth Waring, along with her friend Winnie Harris and a group of neighbors from their West Powelton block, led an effort to transform abandoned lots into Holly Street Neighbors Community Garden. In July 2025, Waring learned that another organization was seeking ownership of the garden through Orphans’ Court, which handles estate cases in Pennsylvania.  


The Law Center acted quickly, filing for adverse possession of the parcel on Waring’s behalf. At the same, the Law Center moved to intervene in the Orphans’ Court case, which the court granted.  


As a result of our advocacy and the pending litigation, an agreement was reached in April 2026 whereby the garden parcel will be transferred to Neighborhood Gardens Trust to maintain the community garden in perpetuity. The transaction closed on May 28, preserving the garden. 



"This garden is essential,” said Waring. “It provides fresh food, a quiet space through the Shade Garden, and connection for many neighbors and others. Finally having secure land tenure means we can focus on growing food and community for years to come." 

 

Protecting Fair Promotion Policies in the Philadelphia Police Department

Earlier this year, America First Legal – an organization founded by Trump advisor Stephen Miller – filed a class action lawsuit on behalf of five white male police officers against the city of Philadelphia claiming discrimination on the basis of race and sex. In addition to seeking monetary compensation, the plaintiffs are demanding that the city abandon recent reforms to civil service rules for hiring and promotion. 


The Guardian Civic League works to improve law enforcement in Philadelphia and has over 1,100 members, most of whom are active or retired African-American police officers. It has a strong and unique interest in fair promotion policies and practices within the Philadelphia Police Department. The Law Center, which has represented the Guardian Civic League in several cases dating to the 1970s, filed a motion for the organization to intervene, which would allow it to participate as a party in the lawsuit. 


In the past, the city used the “Rule of Two” to make promotion decisions. Under this rule, hiring managers were limited to the two candidates who scored highest on the civil-service exam. In 2021, Philadelphia voters replaced that system with a new “Varying Rule,” which allows hiring managers more discretion in determining how many eligible candidates can be considered for a vacancy. Instead of making hiring and promotion decisions based merely on test scores, managers may now consider applicants’ overall merit, including factors such as job performance, professional experience, and leadership and supervisory capability. 


As we argue in our motion to intervene, the plaintiffs’ request to invalidate the Varying Rule would likely lead the Philadelphia Police Department to revert its hiring practices in ways that would unfairly disadvantage Black applicants, including many members of the Guardian Civic League, by deprioritizing measures of merit apart from raw test scores. This would impair the Guardian Civic League’s core interest in fostering upward mobility for its members. 


Read our legal brief supporting the Guardian Civic League’s motion to intervene here.  

Trump Administration Drops Appeal in CHOP Case 

On May 6, the Department of Justice (DOJ) withdrew its appeal to the Third Circuit in the case concerning its attempt to obtain the private medical records of minors receiving gender affirming care at CHOP.  


This past November, a federal court in Philadelphia blocked DOJ’s subpoena demanding patient records, finding that the patients’ constitutional right to privacy substantially outweighed the government’s supposed purpose and calling out the Trump administration’s “wayward reasoning” and shifting rationale. 


In June, DOJ’s appellate brief is due in the Third Circuit as it appeals the district court’s decision concerning the records of minor patients at UPMC in Pittsburgh. That appeal raises many of the same issues raised in the CHOP appeal.  


Recently, however, two other hospitals in other parts of the country who had not challenged the Trump administration’s overreaching administrative subpoenas have now received grand jury subpoenas. We are closely monitoring the situations at both CHOP and UPMC in order to continue to protect patients’ privacy rights.  


The School District of Philadelphia’s Underspending Problem

In an op-ed for the Inquirer, Law Center senior attorney Dan Ureivick-Ackelsberg explains that the School District of Philadelphia’s spending problem isn’t that it spends too much – it’s that it spends far too little. 


Read more here. 

Annual Board Meeting

Three of the Law Center's newest board members (L-R: Cybil Yakira, Emily Roth, and Elizabeth Waring)


The Law Center Board’s annual meeting took place on May 28 at Hogan Lovells. We welcomed five new board members: Tom Burke, Emily Kowey Roth, Eli Segal, Elizabeth Waring, and Cybil Yakira. We also thanked outgoing members Zac Arbitman, Dean Beer, Shauna Itri, and Ellen Meriwether for their service. The Law Center’s officers – Chair Mark Kasten, Vice Chair Wes Payne, Treasurer Liz Lambert, and Secretary Rob Wiygul – were all re-elected for another one-year term.

Join Us to Help Fund Philly Schools

The School District of Philadelphia is facing a budget deficit of $300 million, and so has passed a budget for the coming school year would cut 340 teachers, counselors, and climate staff. That can't happen. 

 

To prevent cutting those critical staff members, Mayor Parker proposed a $1/ride tax on rideshare programs.

 

Philly students cannot afford these cuts. Join the Law Center and other education advocates at City Hall (North Apron) on Tuesday, June 2 at 4:30 p.m. to tell City Council to fund our schools. 

 

RSVP here. 

David Dye Returns as Emcee for the Law Center’s Annual Event: A Night of Impact

We’re thrilled to welcome back David Dye as the emcee for our annual event on October 8! A Philadelphia broadcasting legend, David was honored with a well-deserved place on the Philadelphia Music Alliance Walk of Fame last year, a testament to his incredible impact on our city’s music and culture. 


Join us as we celebrate justice and community with David at the helm. Sponsorships are now available—a great opportunity for law firms and businesses to support our mission while gaining visibility at this inspiring event. Secure yours today! 

Welcome the Law Center’s Summer Interns

Mia Milton


Hometown: Manorville, NY


Law School: Howard University School of Law


Mia Milton is a rising third‑year law student at Howard University School of Law. Before law school, she interned at the Legal Aid Society, where she served indigent clients facing food and housing insecurity. These conditions often led to unstable employment, poor health outcomes, and limited access to essential services. Working directly with clients whose challenges arise from systemic inequities strengthened her commitment to public‑interest advocacy. She is excited to continue this work with the Law Center this summer. 

Nour Elkassabany 


Hometown: Wayne, PA 


Law School: Temple University Beasley School of Law 


A rising 3L at Temple, Nour Elkassabany graduated from the University of Pennsylvania in 2020 with a degree in Health and Societies. She’s interested in environmental justice issues, especially topics like land use disputes and industrial contamination, after a formative experience in a class about the legacy of asbestos manufacturing in Ambler, Pennsylvania. Having kept up with the Law Center’s work over the past couple of years makes her excited to contribute this summer!  

Madeline Nagler


Hometown: Boston, MA 


Law School: Penn Carey Law 


Madeline Nagler is a rising 3L and Toll Public Interest Scholar at Penn Carey Law. She graduated from Wesleyan University in 2022 with degrees in psychology and documentary filmmaking. She is passionate about issues pertaining to youth justice including public education. Prior to law school, Madeline served as an AmeriCorps College Access Coach where she worked with first-generation high school students on applying to college and other forms of higher learning. She also worked for the National Youth Justice Network where she created short videos relating to various aspects of the youth justice system. She is delighted to be a part of the Law Center this summer. 

Shreya Hurli


Hometown: Columbus, IN 


School: University of Virginia 


Shreya Hurli is a rising third-year law student at the University of Virginia. Before law school, Shreya was in Durham, North Carolina working at a microscopy startup and volunteering as an external organizer with the Triangle Tenants’ Union. This summer, she’s excited to support the Law Center’s work on housing, employment, and education issues.

Juco Centeno


Hometown: Springfield, Montgomery County, PA 


Law School: Penn Carey Law 


Juco Centeno is a rising second-year student at Penn Carey Law. Born and raised in the Philadelphia area, he is passionate about addressing systemic legal issues facing communities in the region. Juco is interested in the intersections of housing, employment, and criminalization and is excited to support and learn from the Law Center’s high-impact legal strategy. 

Please consider making a contribution to support our work:


Facebook  Instagram  LinkedIn  X

The official registration and financial information of the Public Interest Law Center may be obtained from the Pennsylvania Department of State by calling toll-free, within Pennsylvania, 1-800-732-0999. Registration does not imply endorsement.