View as Webpage

RNC to SEB: Finger-pointing is Not a Plan

September 26, 2026 



Well, this doesn’t happen every day! Republican National Committee and the Georgia Republican Party publicly agree with an election-policy position Coalition for Good Governance has been urging. Their voices are important on this urgent issue and deserve your attention.



Sound election policy principles should not be partisan—and every Georgia voter’s right to a secret ballot is one of them. Inarguably, as the Republican Party organizations wrote to the State Election Board, “It is a bulwark against voter coercion, intimidation, and retaliation, protecting the fairness of the franchise.”

We were delighted to see the joint RNC and Georgia GOP letter released yesterday calling on the State Election Board to use their authority to act now while there is still time to protect Georgia voters before early voting begins on October 13. 


[Read the RNC and Georgia GOP letter here.]


What the letter says


The letter is signed by Josh McKoon, Chairman of the Georgia Republican Party, and Luke Bunting, election integrity legal counsel for the Republican National Committee. Both are attorneys experienced in election law and the administrative law governing government agencies.


Their central point is straightforward: protecting ballot secrecy is a clear and urgent responsibility of the State Election Board.  


The protection has become far more urgent given the recent discoveries that AI agents can easily pierce Georgia’s public voting system data to make most ballots traceable back to the voter. Princeton AI researcher Max Springer alerted the SEB to his findings in early August.


The Secretary of State administers Georgia’s voting system, but the State Election Board makes the binding election rules and has authority to investigate violations and the duty to require compliance with election law. The Secretary does not have that authority.  Once Secretary Raffensperger failed to update the system software in time for the election, it fell to the SEB to use its authority to act to make rules and enforce the law to protect voters. 


As the Republican orgs' letter aptly puts it:


“Jurisdictional finger-pointing is not a plan.”


Exactly.


The Republican orgs ask the Board, (consisting of four Republicans and one Democrat), to call a special meeting and adopt statewide rules before early voting begins. For the November election, they recommend having ballots securely cast in safe ballot boxes, and thoroughly shuffling them before they are scanned, which is also the policy we have been advocating since the time window for software update passed a few weeks ago. Such shuffling would break the connection between the order in which voters cast their ballots and the electronic records created by the scanners.


Why shuffling must happen before scanning


The problem is not what happens to the paper ballot after it has been scanned and processed. The problem occurs at the moment the anonymous ballot is scanned and a traceable number is improperly added to the electronic ballot record.


The current software assigns each electronic ballot record an identifier that is supposed to be random and conceal the order in which ballots were cast. Researchers have shown that the identifiers are predictable (not random) numbers and that the scanning order can be easily reconstructed, which is not supposed to happen. When that scanning order is combined with the traceable electronic ballot record, voters can be matched with their ballot choices in most circumstances.


Once that electronic traceable record has been created, shuffling the paper ballots afterward does not undo the harm to the voter. Until repaired software is used in future years, the ballots must be cast in a non-electronic ballot box, and thoroughly shuffled before they are cast in the scanner to break the electronic tie between the voter order and the sequence of scanning.  


This is about privacy—not vote totals. The concern is not that the software changes votes. The concern is that a correctly counted ballot may no longer be secret because of the deanonymizing software that adds the traceable number.


This belongs to everybody


Republican voters deserve secret ballots. Democratic voters deserve secret ballots. Libertarians, independents, minor-party voters, write-in voters, and people who do not want anyone to know their politics all deserve exactly the same protection.

No voter should have to wonder whether a government official, employer, political organization, church pastor, family member, or anyone else might someday discover how that voter voted.


We hope the Democratic Party, other political parties, candidates, campaigns, lawmakers, civil-rights organizations, and voting-rights advocates will join the RNC, the Georgia GOP, and CGG in calling for immediate voter protection action.

There should be no partisan divide over whether the government may create records connecting citizens with their votes. It should not.


Monday’s State Election Board meeting


The State Election Board meets Monday, September 28. Its agenda places emergency rulemaking and emergency complaints near the end of what may be a long meeting.

We hope the Board will first hear the scheduled cases for which respondents and their attorneys are present, and then move promptly to the ballot-secrecy emergency rulemaking and complaints. Those matters should not be left until the end of the day, when time, focus, or public attendance may be running short. The Board has stalled repeatedly on this issue with a “Voters Be Damned” attitude to keep from dealing with this crucial and uncomfortable voter protection topic.  Their feet must be held to the fire this time to take their jobs seriously.


Advance voting begins October 13. Counties need clear, binding instructions immediately so that they can revise procedures, train poll workers, obtain secure ballot boxes, establish ballot-accounting safeguards, and prepare for properly observed ballot shuffling and scanning.


Counties also have independent responsibility to guarantee the absolute secrecy of the ballot, regardless of what the Secretary of State recommends or whether the State Election Board acts. But with 159 counties approaching the same election, the Board should not leave them to develop 159 different solutions without statewide direction.


What about the poll workers?


We have heard concerns that poll workers have already been trained and that changing procedures now could be difficult.


No one welcomes last-minute changes. But we have great confidence in Georgia’s poll workers. With prompt, clear instructions and practical training, they can adapt to a straightforward change in how ballots are collected and scanned. We have seen them pivot fast to deal with last minute difficulties before. And we simply do not believe that they would want to do anything to prolong the use of the current system that violates the law. 


Poll workers accept demanding jobs for modest pay because they care about Georgia’s voters and want elections to be fair and successful. We are confident they would conscientiously follow a revised process designed to protect every voter’s constitutional right to a secret ballot, and would choose nothing less.


The answer is to give them clear instructions, training, and support now—not to continue an unlawful process because voting is drawing closer. The Board should not ask poll officials to participate in a flawed process of deanonymizing ballots. 


Learn more

·       [Read CGG’s emergency complaint.]

·       [Read our summary explainer on the complaint.]

·       [Read the detailed information sent to Georgia county election officials.]

·       [Read FAQ’s about ballot secrecy vulnerability.]


Ask the Board to act


The majority of the Board members spent the last two months deflecting and trying to avoid the issue, although SEB member Salleigh Grubbs has been relentlessly urging emergency meetings and rules to address the danger. Most members have repeatedly said that they were simply too busy to address this topic or hear from experts, or that their minds were already made up to reject the issue. Hopefully the letter from the Republican orgs will be a wakeup call to duty. 


Candidates, campaigns, political parties, lawmakers, voting-rights organizations, members of the press, and individual voters should ask the State Election Board to take immediate action to protect the November election from disruption that can be caused by trampling of the voters’ rights. 


🖋️ You may write the Board at electionboard@seb.ga.gov.


[Use or personalize this sample letter to the Board.]


We may disagree about many election policies. We should not disagree about this one.


🗳️  A secret ballot must remain absolutely secret. Secretary Raffensperger’s improper directives to conceal the problem and continue to put tracers on ballot records should be soundly rejected by the counties and the SEB. 


❓ If you have questions about the secret ballot issue, let us hear from you here.


 ✉️  Join our mailing list on this secret ballot issue, --sign up here.

Marilyn Marks

Executive Director

Marilyn@uscgg.org